Asia-Pacific, Development & Aid, Headlines, Health, Population

POPULATION-INDONESIA: Government Keen on Easing Abortion Law

Richel Dursin

JAKARTA, Sep 7 2000 (IPS) - Indonesia is open to allowing “limited legal abortions” to stem the alarmingly high incidence of maternal mortality caused by unsafe abortions performed by unqualified persons.

“There is a need to provide safe abortion as most of the maternal deaths are caused by unsafe abortion,” says Trisnawaty Loho, of the reproductive health and family planning division of the Ministry of Health.

Currently, a team from the Ministry of Health and Ministry of Religious Affairs is working on a proposal to carry out safe abortion or what it calls “limited legalisation of abortion” in predominantly Muslim Indonesia.

“What we are promoting is safe abortion, not liberalising abortion. In Islamic countries like Malaysia, Tunisia and Turkey, abortion is justified under certain conditions,” says Azrul Azwar, the health ministry’s director general for community health.

In terms of maternal mortality, Indonesia has one of the highest in Asia, with 450 per 100,000 live births, compared with India’s 410 per 100,000 and Nepal’s 540 per 100,000, according to the UN Human Development Report 2000.

The Philippines, Jakarta’s partner in the Association of Southest Asian Nations, has 170 per 100,000.

Indonesia’s health ministry estimates that at least 35 per cent of maternal deaths is due to unsafe abortion.

In countries that allow abortion like the Netherlands, there is almost a zero incidence of maternal deaths because of good nursing care, monitoring and supervision, according to Azwar.

The Ministry of Health is inclined to sanction abortion provided the procedure would be carried out by a team of medical experts, and done under safe conditions. It should not be performed for commercial reasons.

“We should consider cases of incest, rape or contraceptive failure,” Azwar says.

Under article 15 of the Indonesian Health Law No. 23 issued in 1992, a certain medical act, which could mean abortion, can be performed in an emergency situation to save the life of a woman and-or her foetus.

According to the law, legal abortions are to be conducted in government hospitals by an obstetrician-gynaecologist under strict supervision by a special medical team.

“The law is being improved in relation to the plan to provide safe abortion,” Loho says, referring to Health Law No. 23.

Medical experts argue that the lack of a government regulation in executing abortions has led to the uncontrolled illegal practice in the country.

“It has been eight years since the issuance of Health Law No. 23 and the government has not yet issued a regulation,” says obstetrician and gynaecology expert Sudarji Sumapraja of the state-owned University of Indonesia.

“The content of article 15 of Health Law No. 23 contradicts itself. A termination of pregnancy is never understood as an effort to save the foetus,” Sumapraja argues.

When legal abortions are not possible, Indonesian women seek a variety of methods to terminate their unwanted pregnancies, including the intake of a traditional medicinal herb, locally known as “jamu” and excessive eating of pineapple.

According to the Ministry of Health, there are about 2.3 million abortions performed every year in Indonesia. The number is more than half the World Health Organisation’s estimate of 4.2 million cases for the entire southeast Asian region.

“Many illegal abortion clinics are in operation,” Sumapraja observes.

An abortion procedure in Indonesia costs up to three million rupiahs or 363 U.S. dollars, quite steep for an average wage earner.

Unwed pregnant Indonesian women are under intense pressure from their families as well as society to abort their babies as they face public humiliation, difficult economic conditions and even tribal punishment.

Last year, some 750,000 young, unmarried women resorted to abortion, according to the State Ministry for Women’s Empowerment.

“Very few unmarried Indonesian women who are sexually active have access to accurate information, education and counselling for responsible sexual behaviour and prevention of unwanted pregnancies,” says Adrianus Tandjung, head of the reproductive health service division of the non- governmental Indonesian Planned Parenthood Association.

Most of the illegal abortions in Indonesia are performed by traditional “birth attendants” who often use abdominal massage, which experts say threatens both the foetus and the woman. Other methods include hormone injections or the use of unsafe instruments.

“Many traditional birth attendants illegally perform abortions and leave the women bleeding. The women bleed to death before they can reach the hospital,” Loho says.

But not all of those who resort to abortion are unwed women. In fact, most are married women who had unplanned pregnancies or who experienced contraception failure.

“Contraceptives are not 100 percent effective,” says Richard Makalew, adviser in population strategies of the United Nations Population Fund (UNFPA) in Jakarta.

Pills, which are preferred by most Indonesians, have a usage failure of one to eight percent, according to UNFPA. Condoms, which are widely used by Indonesian men, have a usage failure of five to 20 percent. Other methods such as implants, have a failure rate of one to three percent, while injectables and intrauterine device, both have one percent failure rate.

Abortion is a sensitive issue in the country that Indonesians do not use the term at all. “We use the term menstrual regulation to refer to abortion,” Tandjung says.

The legalisation of abortion has been a subject of frequent debates between the medical community and religious leaders, known here as “ulamas”.

In 1997, after reports of a shockingly high demand for abortion gained public attention, the Indonesian Doctors Association appealed for public support to legalise abortion under strict conditions such as limits on the allowed gestation period.

The Indonesian Ulamas Association rejected the proposal, saying it was tantamount to murder. The religious leaders are again expected to raise a howl this time around.

 
Republish | | Print |

Related Tags

Headlines

POPULATION-INDONESIA: Government Keen on Easing Abortion Law

Richel Dursin

JAKARTA, Sep 7 2000 (IPS) - Indonesia is open to allowing “limited legal abortions” to stem the alarmingly high incidence of maternal mortality caused by unsafe abortions performed by unqualified persons.
(more…)

 
Republish | | Print |

Related Tags