Economy & Trade, Headlines, North America

FINANCE-US: Bush’s ‘Compassionate Conservatism’ Goes Global

Tim Shorrock

WASHINGTON, Jul 17 2001 (IPS) - US President George W. Bush brought his campaign for “compassionate conservatism” to the global arena Tuesday, asking the World Bank to give more and lend less to developing countries.

Bush proposed that up to 50 percent of development funds provided to the poorest nations by the World Bank and other multilateral banks come in the form of grants, rather than loans, for education, health, water supply and other needs.

In a speech delivered a day before leaving for a summit in Italy of heads of government from the Group of Seven (G-7) industrial powers plus Russia, Bush also blasted the thousands of protestors planning to demonstrate at the G-7 as protectionists who are “no friends of the poor.”

“They seek to shut down meetings because they want to shut down free trade,” said Bush of protests planned for the G-7 meeting in Genoa. “We must reject a protectionism that blocks the path of prosperity for developing countries. We must reject policies that would condemn them to permanent poverty.”

Bush said his proposals for increasing the World Bank’s share of grants are part of his administration’s efforts to help developing countries “to remove the huge obstacles to development” and help them fight unsustainable debt.

“This is compassionate conservatism at an international level,” he said.

Some critics of the World Bank and its lending policies said Bush’s proposal to cut back on lending was a step in the right direction.

“In general we’re supportive of a shift to grants,” said Carol Welch, deputy director of international programs for the environmental group Friends of the Earth. The bank’s lending programmes, she added, “have left developing countries with the legacy of the debt trap.”

Others, however, said World Bank grants would come with the same onerous conditions it attaches to loans.

Development grants provide a way out for countries caught in a debt trap, said Njoki Njoroge Njehu, director of the Fifty Years is Enough. The group has campaigned for 100 percent grants. Tuesday’s proposal, she said, “means something but it’s not much if they’re still operating within the World Bank-IMF (International Monetary Fund) model, which is neo-liberalism.”

“I don’t think it’s a very good idea,” added Doug Hellinger, executive director of Development Gap. “The World Bank has already shown they can’t spend money very well. This further empowers an organization that has brought on lots of pain and suffering.”

Hellinger said the Bush administration might see grants as a way for the United States to gain more leverage over bank programmes and, in turn, over recipient countries. “If they (the Bank) can separate the money from leverage, then we can start talking,” he said.

World Bank officials said Bush’s plan to increase grants to 50 percent would require a doubling of US annual contributions to the bank, to more than 800 million dollars per year. Bush did not offer any increase in his speech, however.

At a White House briefing later in the day, press secretary Ari Fleischer said the administration would not ask Congress for more US funds to help pay for a larger grants programme. He also disputed the World Bank officials’ estimates, saying Bush’s idea “won’t affect the World Bank’s cash flow for ten years.”

His proposal reflects concerns voiced by many conservatives, including senior administration officials, that loans to poor countries from the World Bank, the IMF and other institutions often are mismanaged, do little to alleviate poverty, and encourage investors to make risky bets with the expectation that they’ll be bailed out as they were in the Mexican peso crisis of 1994-95 and the Asian financial meltdown of 1997-98.

Last year, the Meltzer Commission, which studied the World Bank and the IMF on behalf of the Republican-controlled Congress, recommended that multilateral banks emphasize grants above loans. On Tuesday, Treasury Secretary Paul O’Neill explained the need for a shift in policy on the opinion page of the New York Times.

The World Bank and other multilateral institutions must “adopt a bolder, more aggressive stance on the use of outright grants of money, as well as loans,” O’Neill said. “During the past two decades, many of the poorest nations became so highly indebted that now they are unable to make payments on their current loans, let alone borrow and pay back more.”

Loans “should be made only when there is an expectation that principal and interest will be paid back in full and on time,” he added.

In his speech to the World Bank, however, Bush made clear that he and O’Neill don’t support the idea of a 100 percent write-off of creditors’ claims against the poorest countries, a demand that will be highlighted by many of the demonstrators in Genoa.

Instead, he praised a World Bank-IMF program, known as the Heavily Indebted Poor Countries (HIPC) initiative, that is designed to alleviate the debt of 41 poor countries, most of them in Africa. So far, 23 countries have reached agreement under HIPC for around 34 billion dollars in debt relief.

Proponents of debt forgiveness see the HIPC program as a poor substitute for cancellation because the poorest countries are getting an average cut of just 27 percent in their annual debt service payments – and only on condition that they follow World Bank and IMF policy prescriptions.

Without naming the programme, Bush pointed out that “23 of the world’s poorest nations are benefiting from efforts to relieve them of the crippling burden of massive debt. These nations have committed themselves to economic reform and to channeling the savings from debt relief into health and education.”

The United States, he said, “has been, and will continue to be, a world leader on responsible debt relief.”

However, “debt relief is really a short-term fix,” he added. “The proposal today doesn’t merely drop the debt, it helps stop the debt.”

Bush also used his speech to press legislators to give him Trade Promotion Authority, formerly known as ‘fast-track’, so he can negotiate new free trade agreements with South America and other regions without fear of Congressional amendments.

He took issue with those who believe globalisation has been harmful to workers and the environment. “What some call globalisation is, in fact, the triumph of human liberty stretching across national borders,” he said.

 
Republish | | Print |

Related Tags