Thursday, November 19, 2026
Deborah Horan
- As the gateway between Europe and the Arab world, Palestine, like Turkey and Lebanon to the north, created a cultural blend of East and West.
Influenced by the Mediterranean countries as well as the desert kingdoms over the centuries, the people roaming the biblical land took liberally from both, developing a mix of architecture, cuisine, and traditions that can be found on both sides of the Levant.
Now, as Palestinians develop the institutions of statehood, including the first-ever parliament, they have the chance for the first time in their history to create their own body of law — law that will reflect the type of society they want to create.
The parliament, set to be voted into existence this coming January, will have broad legislative powers.
Although it is technically a ruling “council” according to the Oslo agreement that outlines Palestinian self-rule in the West Bank and Gaza, the 82-member body will have the ability to enact sweeping changes in Palestinian society — as long as they do not contravene agreements signed with Israel.
“Pretty soon, we hope we an get it together like other democratic countries in the world,” said one Palestinian ministry of justice official, who spoke on condition of anonymity.
When polled, many Palestinians say they would like to see an Islamic state come into existence. Others are pushing for Western- style democracy, albeit with a Middle Eastern imprint.
Almost all know what they don’t want: a dictatorship reminiscent of those governing states throughout the Arab world. “Hopefully, we’ll be different than other Arab governments in the region,” said the Justice ministry official.
Ideology aside, Palestinians have a huge task in front of them as they extend their self-rule powers throughout most of the still- occupied West Bank in coming months. Centuries of foreign rule in Palestine has left a trail of legal paper that will have to be sifted through, consolidated, updated, and modernized.
Laws dating back to the time before World War I when the Ottoman Empire ruled Palestine are still on the books. Then came the British, the Jordanian, the Egyptian, and finally Israeli military orders.
Every power left its mark. From the Ottomans, Palestinians are left with anachronistic land laws with a village-based system of parceling that can be a nightmare in today’s courts for those who hope to prove ownership.
The British left a series of emergency laws that Palestinian human rights activists say they would like to see expunged, such as an order often utilized by the Israeli military that allows a house to be demolished if illegal activity took place there.
Jordan left its court system in place with procedures governing trials that Palestinians say they would like to see updated. And Israel added to the piles of legal paper military orders that governed daily life in minutia, such as orders forbidding the picking of certain plants in the West Bank and others designating the color of fishing boats off the Gaza coast.
“We are in the process of unifying all the laws,” said Sliman Dahdouh, a legal consultant at the ministry of justice. “But there are many differences and this will not be corrected overnight.”
Some of the differences, though seemingly insignificant, point to a larger problem. If, for instance, a Palestinian dies in an accident on the job in Gaza, an old Egyptian law provides for compensation from the employers equal to 3,000 days of work.
But in the West Bank, the amount is not fixed, but determined on a case-by-case basis taking into consideration the worker’s family, his income, and other factors, according to a Jordanian law.
Because the West Bank and Gaza experienced different rule — Gaza was under Egyptian rule after the creation of Israel in 1948 while the West Bank was annexed to Jordanian — many of the laws are disparate. If Palestinians want to unite these two self-rule areas into a future state, they will need to develop one system under one rule of law.
“The judicial system has to be defined very quickly,” said Camille Mansour, a Palestinian professor of law at Birzeit University in the West Bank who is part of a team compiling existing laws for future legislators.
“You need to develop a pyramid system of courts so that at the end you know who has the final say — and appeals court, a high court,” said Mansour.
Especially in economic spheres, Palestinians need to move quickly to create laws that will spur investment, banking, and commerce, said Mansour. “You cannot have economic activity when you have to systems,” he said.
Birzeit’s program is intends to publish the laws in force today from all periods — Ottoman to Israeli — so that once the parliament gets going, members will have a basis from which to start repealing or amending laws.
Only then will Palestinians be organized enough to tackle the larger questions that define their nation, whether they will follow the East or the West.
Deborah Horan
- As the gateway between Europe and the Arab world, Palestine, like Turkey and Lebanon to the north, created a cultural blend of East and West.
(more…)