Development & Aid, Europe, Headlines

DEVELOPMENT: Non-Church NGOs Play Marginal Role in Germany

Ramesh Jaura

BONN, Apr 19 1996 (IPS) - Non-governmental organisations affiliated to the Church or linked to political parties predominate in German development cooperation with the Third World and independent NGOs play only a “marginal role,” says a new report.

The secondary role played by independent NGOs in Germany, says the author of the study Peter Molt, is underlined by the meagre funding they get from their government — in contrast to their counterparts in other western donor nations

“And this in spite of the fact that the NGOs’ activities are increasingly regarded as a significant flanking support to the state-to-state development cooperation,” added Molt, chairman of Germany’s new Confederation of Development NGOs (VENRO).

The Organisation for Economic Cooperation and Development (OECD) club of developed nations has described NGOs as significant supporting pillars of development; Germany’s Minister of Economic Cooperation and Development, Carl-Dieter Spranger dubs them “the second leg” of cooperation with the developing world.

Yet compared with other donor nations German funding of development NGOs is relatively slight — no more than 6.22 percent of Official Development Assistance (ODA). In Sweden, their counterparts receive some 30 percent of ODA funds.

What is offered mainly goes to German political foundations (45 percent) and Church organisations (38 percent). Close to 13 percent of ODA funds to NGOs goes on food aid and emergency humanitarian assistance.

Three percent, goes to independent NGOs — about 27 million marks (18.4 million dollars) a year — working on building up social structures and promoting their work. This adds up to no more than 0.32 percent of the average annual budget of the German Ministry of Economic Cooperation and Development.

The report is shortly to be published by the Konrad Adenauer Foundation (KAS) — with close links to Chancellor Helmut Kohl’s Christian Democratic Union (CDU).

Donation collecting agencies such as the German UNICEF Committee and the German Foundation for UNHCR, raised more than 110 million marks (75 million dollars) in 1994.

Molt points out that since German NGOs have “rather a weak structure”, a growing number of foreign non-governmental bodies were establishing themselves in the country. He noted that recently the French NGO Medicins sans Frontieres and the British NGOs Oxfam and Save the Children had started collecting donations in Germany too.

Molt said there was a clear dominance of anglophone, Scandinavian and Francophone NGOs in several countries of Africa, Asia and Latin America. In contrast, German NGOs played a significant role there only if they happen to be affiliated to the Church or political parties.

Against this backdrop, the study points out: “In view of the growing importance of international social commitment, we might do well in pondering whether the absence of independent German NGOs in the community of international NGOs is conducive to the much needed German presence there.”

The globalisation of development cooperation was a fact the German government must take into account, especially as NGOs can and should play an increasingly significant role in the implementation of cooperation policy of major donor nations.

Not without reason had the U.N. and several of its special organisations — the World Bank, the European Commission and the OECD — shown a growing interest for dialogue and cooperation with the NGOs.

“Because of their structural weakness, the German NGOs have until now hardly have the chance to participate in that dialogue,” the study says. The main church based NGOs are the Catholic Church’s KZE and Misereor and the Protestant Church’s EZE and Bread for the World. There are five major political foundations.

Of the independent NGOs, the main ones are the Deutsche Welthungerhilfe, Terre des Hommes, Kindernothilfe, ADRA, Andheri- Hilfe, DESWOS, Kuebel Stiftung, Internationales Kolpingwerk and Deutscher Hochschulverband.

According to Molt, the NGOs could play a much larger role in combating poverty than they have done until now.

Since in many countries poverty alleviation projects need be funded through foreign aid, because national NGOs there do not have adequate financial and professional resources and the support of their governments, a direct and long-term cooperation between northern and southern NGOs was indispensable, he said.

This was because in cooperation with the NGOs of the South and directly with the organisations of the poor a long-lasting trustworthy relation is of enormous advantage.

“The cooperation between the NGOs of the North and those of the South is not subject to time limitations which state- backed projects as a matter of rule are,” he said.

“Also, it promotes long-term personal relations. It is less anonymous than the support through large state organisations.”

 
Republish | | Print |

Related Tags