Environment, Europe, Headlines

ENVIRONMENT: Germany Slackens Pace of Mitigating Global Warming

Ramesh Jaura

BONN, Apr 8 1996 (IPS) - Germany has abandoned its promise to cut climate damaging carbon dioxide (CO2) emissions by 25 percent by 2005 — as vowed at last year’s U.N. Conference on Climate Change in Berlin — and set itself a lower target instead.

The decision has come under sharp attack from independent environmental groups as well as the opposition Alliance 90-The Greens and the social democratic SPD.

Instead of cutting emissions by 25 percent of the 1990 level by the year 2005, as German chancellor Helmut Kohl personally assured the Berlin meet on Apr. 5 last year, Germany now aims for an easier target of 20 percent.

NGOs and foreign analysts argue that even this lower target may not be met given the current state of German environmental and economic policy.

The responsibility for achieving the reduction goal will not lie with the German government but with industrial enterprises, Kohl’s official spokesman Peter Hausmann said in a low key government announcement on Mar 27.

Carbon dioxide, methane and chlorofluorocarbons (CFCs) are the most important of the so-called greenhouse gases blamed for global climate change and a potentially devastating worldwide rise in atmospheric temperature.

Rich industrial countries such as Germany are expected to take a lead in cutting their own emissions before pressing similar cuts on developing nations, where the economic burden of reducing global warming will be felt the hardest.

Hausmann said the industry was aware of the significance of its role. In fact enterprises which had pledged themselves to the 20 percent goal accounted for four-fifth of total energy consumption by the industry in Germany.

After a year long negotiation with the Ministries of Environment and Economic Affairs, the industry agreed to an independent and comprehensive monitoring system. It will be supervised by the Rhine-Westphalian Institute for Economic Research in Essen, some 110 kilometres from Bonn.

The Institute will not only monitor the implementation of the emissions reduction goal but also establish whether the industries which had undertaken voluntary commitments were bringing about necessary changes in product and production patterns.

Hausmann said the government would strive to have the German industry exempted from an eventual CO2-energy tax now under consideration by the European Union.

However, this presumed that the monitoring system proved to be effective, the objective of diminishing CO2 emission levels were by 20 percent in the next ten years was being achieved, and the industry was taking necessary steps towards protection of the climate.

“The federal (German) government is evading its responsibility for protection of the climate,” said president Hubert Weinzierl, president of the environmental group BUND, affiliated to the international NGO Friends of the Earth. He added: “The meaningless voluntary commitments of the industry are serving as an excuse for doing nothing by itself.”

“Voluntary commitments by industry threaten to result in the federal government abandoning its responsibility,” added Sascha Mueller-Kraennar, a spokesman for the DNR, an alliance of nature and environmental protection organisations.

“The industry has promised reduction in CO2 emissions per production unit and not in absolute terms, but we are likely to end up with higher emission levels if the economy grows fast.”

He said the German government and industry claimed credit for reductions in CO2 emissions in eastern Germany, reductions that resulted from mass factory closures and economic collapse in former communist ruled regions, not as a result of active policy in Bonn.

“While they go around telling success stories about eastern Germany, CO2 emissions in western Germany last year have turned out to be four percent higher than in 1990,” said environment policy spokeswoman of the Alliance 90-The Greens in Germany’s federal parliament, Michaele Hustedt.

Though the level of CO2 emissions in eastern Germany had been lowered by 48 percent since 1990, they have started rising again since last year, largely because of increased traffic on the road.

As a result, last year for the first time since the two German states unified in 1990, CO2 emissions in the whole of Germany had increased to 893 million tonnes. In western Germany, these had increased from 705 million tonnes in 1994 to 729 million tonnes last year.

“Newest forecasts say that this upward trend will continue,” Michael Mueller, environment policy spokesman of the social democratic SPD told the federal parliament (Bundestag).

The eminent Swiss-based research institute Prognos recently predicted a maximum of 10 percent CO2 emissions reduction on 1990 level by the year 2005, if the German government continued its present policy of sitting back and doing nothing. By the year 2020 the CO2 emissions are expected to be just 13.5 lower than in 1990.

“This forecast is not only a slap in the face for the German government, but also a sad declaration of bankruptcy for climate protection,” said Mueller.

Besides, Germany had missed “a grand opportunity” for making climate protection an engine for innovation and modernisation. These, he added, would have offered an appropriate basis for protecting the environment and creating new jobs.

According to latest figures, Germany has reached a record level of unemployment in the country’s post-war history, with every tenth person eligible to work being out of job.

 
Republish | | Print |

Related Tags