Development & Aid, Europe, Headlines, Population

POVERTY-BRITAIN: Poverty is Someone Else’s Problem

Lucy Johnson

LONDON, Apr 23 1996 (IPS) - Mominuddin Khatum, a first generation immigrant from Bangladesh, came to Britain with his parents at the age of 14. He landed with the optimism of migrants everywhere, of those granted the chance of a new start in a new land.

Twenty three years on, Mominuddin is unemployed, living with his wife and five children in a two-bedroom council flat in the East End of London. There are bright purple flowers on the wallpaper, but the damp shows through in the winter.

Still, Mominuddin says he would not return to Bangladesh. “There’s so much poverty in Bangladesh. Not everybody has electricity. Here, at least, we have water and electricity.”

Unintentionally perhaps, his comment would strike a chord with many members of the British government. This month the ruling Conservative party made its clearest statement yet that poverty is relative, and by its standards, Britain has no ‘poverty problem’.

Arguing that as long as everyone in the country has clean running water and enough to eat, it denies the existence of poverty in Britain — or at least poverty on a scale that demands state action.

The announcement has angered welfare groups who claim that not only is the British government backing out of agreements made at last year’s U.N. social summit in Copenhagen but is willfully ignoring evidence that suggests that far from having eradicated poverty, Britain is witnessing its return.

“We’re not suggesting that Britain has poverty on the scale of the Third World,” says Sally Witcher, director of the Child Poverty Action Group.

“What we are saying is that there is a rise in people living in poverty and that their experience of poverty is very acute.”

Mominuddin may have electricity and water but, he says, bringing up a family of seven on 120 pounds (180 dollars) a week in a ‘council home’ (city authority maintained public housing) he still knows a thing or two about poverty in Britain. “Yes, there is poverty here,” he says. “It’s called ‘council poverty’.”

The debate about poverty in Britain has become a battle of statistics. The government dismisses recent figures showing a rise in poverty, claiming that they are flawed, and points to a 37 percent increase in average incomes and the number of video recorders, cars, washing machines and refrigerators found in many of Britain’s nominally poorest households now own.

But a number of recent reports claim that Britain has seen a rise in poverty over the last fifteen years. Last year, the Rowntree Foundation brought out a report claiming that the gap between rich and poor was growing faster in Britain than in any other country in the developed world. It claimed that the poorest 10 percent in Britain were 17 percent worse off in real terms over the last 15 years.

Now a new report claims that the number of people living in poverty has also increased. There is no official measure of poverty in Britain but two semi-official indices, published in the report by a poverty action group in the east of London this month, suggest that the number of people living in poverty has doubled.

According to the report by the Child Action Poverty Group, 14 percent of the population lived on or below the qualification level for government benefits in 1979.

In 1992, this figure had increased to 24 percent. The other measure, comparing incomes with the national average, shows that the number of people whose income is now half the national average has risen from nine percent to 25 percent.

With increasing evidence to suggest that poverty is on the rise in Britain, welfare groups believe the government’s decision to renege on the agreement it signed up to at the Copenhagen social summit last year is particularly cavalier.

The summit’s final document called on countries to set up a poverty eradication plan, something the British government claims is appropriate only for Third World countries.

Welfare groups claim the fundamental problem in Britain is one of denial. “Poverty is not a concept that people want to accept or, in this country, are used to accepting. It hasn’t been around very much,” says Audrey Bernstein, director of the development NGO Oxfam’s British programme.

“The only poverty that tends to be visible and therefore believed is on the streets. Poverty is invisible here. Most people have houses to live in and the doors are closed,”

Oxfam, world famous for its anti-poverty and disaster relief work in the developing world, set up its British programme only last year, partly as a result, Bernstein says, of concerns about increasing poverty in Britain.

“The government says ‘look at all these people with videos’. But in many cases now what we’re looking at is people who can’t even afford running water as they can’t afford to pay their water rates,” says Bernstein.

According to James McCormick, an economist at the left-wing Institute for Public Policy Research, Britain is experiencing a growth in poverty because of a sea-change in its employment patterns.

Under Britain’s former Prime Minister Margaret Thatcher, Britain underwent a massive social restructuring. The privatisation of Britain’s bloated national industries and the cutting back of its manufacturing base unlocked much of its wealth, expanding Britain’s well-off middle classes.

But, a rise in unemployment, a pruning back of social security and a shift towards part-time, low paid work have all left Britain’s poorest people worse off — and could be forcing more and more people into poverty.

Under Thatcher’s successor, John Major, Britain has resisted a European Union-wide standard code of conduct for employers — the so-called ‘social charter’ — including a minimum wage. Major makes no secret of his aim to draw in low-capital manufacturing jobs to Britain by offering workers at the lowest pay scales in Europe.

“What we’re seeing is not just poverty through unemployment but a new factor of low income poverty,” says Chris Pond, director of the Low Pay Unit, who claims that Britain’s move towards becoming the cheap labour pool of Europe is breeding a new class of poor.

“I’ve heard about companies from Korea and Taiwan are cutting their labour costs by coming to England, not just because labour costs here are less than Europe but because it costs half as much for a skilled worker on Teeside (in northern England) than it does in Korea or Taiwan.”

On an estate in the East End of London, the grime covered tenement blocks, the uncleared piles of rubbish and the groups of young men passing the time of day tell their own story.

“They (government ministers) don’t know what they’re talking about. They should try living like us instead of in their big houses,” said Jacky, a 28-year-old mother of two.

Jacky lives on 71 pounds (106.25 dollars) a week; 40 pounds (60 dollars) of that goes on food, 10 pounds (15 dollars) on electricity and three pounds (4.50 dollars) on water. That leaves her 17 pounds (25.50 dollars) for clothes and all the consumer goods she can buy.

“I really just clothe the kids with hand-me-downs, you know friends help out and relatives,” she says. “Once a week we have chicken. But we make do.”

 
Republish | | Print |

Related Tags