Wednesday, November 18, 2026
Dipankar De Sarkar
- Britain, a fierce and proud advocate of democracy world-wide, faces a test of its own at home for greater transparency among members of its ancient Parliament.
But not all 651 members of the over-700-year-old House of Commons are entirely happy about being asked to disclose their outside earnings in Britain’s first such Register of Members’ Interests, published this month to great public curiosity and scrutiny.
In fact, a phalanx of MPs, mostly belonging to the ruling Tory party and many of them ex-ministers, are being positively evasive about what should be a straightforward democratic exercise. And some are very cross indeed.
But the irony of the exercise — begun last year by Prime Minister John Major to clean up the image of British politicians — is that not all MPs need to declare all their earnings in the first place. The salary of a British MP is 34,085 Pounds per year.
A Committee on Public Standards, set up by Major as a result of popular demand, stipulated three categories of income. Earnings for advocating someone’s position in Parliament (which is banned) and for services rendered by MPs in their capacity as Members, which must be declared. Income unrelated to their work as MPs, which need not be disclosed, is also included.
The rub is deciding what is and what is not related to somebody’s work as a Member of Parliament — his or her political status that comes out of being an MP.
The register itself is rather vague on this. Sir Gordon Downey, the Parliamentary Commissioner for Standards, says in his introduction to the Register: “Members have undoubtedly had difficulty in interpreting the new requirements and there are some apparent inconsistencies of treatment.
“This is not altogethr surprising, given the absence of precedents. The House will now be able to judge whether the information provided matches that intended under the resolution of the House.”
Dissenting MPs — led by outspoken House elder and former Tory Prime Minister Edward Heath — insist that what they earn outside their Parliament is their own business. The source of their non- Parliamentary earnings too, they grumble, is a matter for them alone.
Heath, resolutely refusing to disclose his earnings as chairman of Dumpton Gap Company, an unlimited private company, declared: “I have defied no earnings rule and have abided fully by the rules of the House of Commons.”
Their stand has led to a bizarre situation: the highest Tory earner listed in the register is a man who forthrightly lists all his outside income, which totals a relatively modest 76,000 pounds.
On the other hand, former Foreign Secretary Douglas Hurd, whose consultancy with Natwest Bank and Natwest Markets is said to fetch him earnings in excess of 200,000 Pounds, declares no outside income in the register. Neither does his former cabinet colleague David Mellor, who is reputed to earn even more than Hurd for advising companies such as British Aerospace, Racal Tacticom, Vosper Throneycroft and Shorts.
“…In relation to all the other companies, I am enaged in business development unrelated to my position as an MP,” Mellor says in the register, before going on to declare an income of 5000 Pounds for a weekly television programme.
Similarly, Timothy Sainsbury of the Conservative Party, owner of the huge Sainsbury’s supermarket chain, does not disclose his income as director of the chain. Chain-smoking Asian MP, Nirj Deva, a consultant with the cigarette manufacturers, Rothmans International, adopts a similar posture.
Overall, the league of moonshiners who have declared their outside income is topped by the Labour Party’s former deputy chief Roy Hattersley. Despite being on the left wing of the opposition party, Hattersley earns a hefty 104,300 Pounds a year from journalism — apparently the favourite indulgence of MPs outside of politics.
Honesty also characterises the declaration filed by Labour chief Tony Blair, a rock-music lover who declares among his gifts a Fender Stratocaster electric guitar — made famous by the late American rock guitarist Jimi Hendrix — and a rug by Pakistani Prime Minister Benazir Bhutto.
“The change is that MPs are being more careful than in the past,” says researcher Ian Mckenzie of the Labour Party, which pushed the issue of decency in public life as part of its campaign against political sleaze.
“A lot of the MPs have actually given up consultancies, or allowed their consultancies to lapse,” he adds. “The real test will come when MPs are caught lying about whether or not incomes that they do not declare are the result of services related to their work as MPs.”
The first public indication that some MPs were not being entirely above board in their public dealings came in the winter of 1994. A Sunday Times newspaper reporter, posing as a director of a fictitious company, lured two Tory MPs — Graham Riddick and David Treddinich — into accepting a bribe of 1000 Pounds for tabling Parliamentary questions about the firm.
Following a public outcry and a Labour complaint, Major set up an inquiry committee headed by a senior judge, Michael Nolan. Lord Nolan made a series of recommendations on standards of conduct among ministers, MPs, civil servants and the many quasi government agencies.
Labour’s Anne Taylor, shadow leader of the House, said the 1994 cash-for-questions episode reinforced “a widespread distrust of politicians. The British people lost faith in their own Parliament.”
A Gallup poll shows that 64 percent of British people believe most MPs “make a lot of money by using public office improperly.” Another opinion survey by the agency MORI indicated the proportion of people thinking that Parliament works “very” or “quite” well has slipped from 59 percent in 1991 to 44 percent now.
According to Anne Taylor, decision-making has been taken away from elected bodies and a whole layer of unaccountable quasi- government agencies known as ‘QUANGOS’ regarded as the ‘unelected state’ which spend billions of pounds of taxpayers’ money.
“The adverse consequnces of this sense of betrayal are too serious to be understated,” Taylor wrote in the Parliamentarian magazine. “A generation of citizens, ignored by political masters and progressively excluded by the economic and social rubric of the eighties, has become increasingly angered by its treatment.”