Global, Global Geopolitics, Headlines

DISARMAMENT: U.N. Head Loses Battle Against Landmines

Thalif Deen

UNITED NATIONS, May 6 1996 (IPS) - U.N. Secretary-General Boutros Boutros-Ghali has lost his longstanding battle to ban anti- personnel landmines, which are among the world’s cheapest and deadliest weapons.

“I must register my deep disappointment that the progress achieved falls far short of what I had hope for at this Review Conference,” he said of the outcome of a two-week meeting in Geneva.

The Review Conference, which met to assess an existing treaty on conventional weapons, refused Friday to support Boutros-Ghali’s global campaign to ban the production, use and export of landmines.

The Secretary-General has been a tireless crusader against landmines because of the devastation they have caused to millions of civilians in the ethnic conflicts raging mostly in Europe, Africa, and Asia.

Landmines are also the second biggest cause of casualties of U.N. peacekeepers, after direct fire. “A total ban would be easier to implement, monitor and verify,” Boutros-Ghali has argued.

The United Nations, which is holding a landmine exhibit in its public lobby at the New York Secretariat through May 31, already has collected more than 1.5 million signatures in support of a ban on landmines.

The Review Conference agreed only to curtail the use of landmines within the next decade. But Boutros-Ghali points out that “landmines will continue to be used by the million, produced by the million, and transferred by the million.”

The Conference also decided that mines should eventually be made easily detectable or self-deactivating. A distinction was made between “smart mines” and “dumb mines”. One will automatically self-destruct within a limited life span, and the other that will stay armed indefinitely.

“There have been attempts to differentiate between ‘smart mines’ or ‘good mines’ and bad ones. Yet no mechanism, no contraption, can legitimise a weapon that inflicts such appalling, yet random, suffering on so many societies,” Boutros-Ghali said of the decision made by the Review Conference.

The International Committee of the Red Cross (ICRC) has described the results of the Review Conference as “woefully inadequate.”

“The horror of the immense human suffering caused by landmines is set to continue,” The ICRC said in a statement. The organisation added that the limitation adopted on the use of landmines will encourage the production, transfer and use of a new generation of mines, while not prohibiting any existing types, other than, eventually non-detectable anti-personnel mines.

The ICRC says it regrets that, for the first time in humanitarian law, “measures have been adopted which, instead of entirely prohibiting the use of an indiscriminate weapon, both permit its continued use and implicitly promote the use of new models which will have virtually the same effects.”

The chances of a ban within the next five years are remote, since the next meeting of the Review Conference is not scheduled to take place until the year 2001.

“The world cannot wait for the eventual elimination of landmines,” Boutros-Ghali said. “They must be eliminated now.”

The United Nations estimates that by 2001, an additional 50,000 people will have been killed, and a further 80,000 injured by landmines. Furthermore, 10 million to 25 million landmines will have been added to the 110 million already uncleared.

“Thousands of children will continue to suffer horrific mutilation,” Boutros-Ghali said. “Thousands of farmers working in fields will be blinded or crippled. Thousands of de-miners will continue to have to risk their lives every day to try to clear the world of the 110 million landmines that already lie uncleared.”

“We encourage all states immediately to enact national legislation prohibiting the manufacture, stockpiling, use or sale of landmines,” the Secretary-General.

According to a database updated regularly by the U.N. Department of Humanitarian Affairs, the top 10 countries affected by landmines are Egypt, Iran, Angola, Afghanistan, Cambodia, China, Iraq, Vietnam, Croatia and Bosnia Hercegovina. There are 3.5 million landmines in Vietnam, 10 million in China, and 9,900 in Denmark.

The New York-Based Human Rights Watch says that a global ban on landmines is easier said than done because of the strong opposition by the world’s major producers.

“Only a handful of countries have come out in favour of a total ban,” Steve Goose of Human Rights Watch said last year. The countries seeking a ban include Sweden, Belgium, Norway, Ireland, Cambodia, Mexico, Colombia and Estonia.

The ICRC says that to date, 35 of the 185 U.N. member states have supported an immediate global ban on landmines, 16 have renounced landmine use by their own armed forces, four have suspended use, and at least five are destroying their stockpiles.

Dutch Minister for Development Cooperation Jan Pronk told IPS his government decided last year to destroy its entire stockpile of landmines because of heavy pressure from non-governmental organisations.

The United Nations says it will cost about 33 billion dollars to clear the 110 landmines scattered across the world’s battle zones. But last year, the international community spent only about 70 million dollars to clear roughly 100,000 landmines.

 
Republish | | Print |

Related Tags