Environment, Europe, Headlines

ENVIRONMENT: British Nuclear Waste Threatens Irish Over The Sea

Sarah O'Hara

DUBLIN, May 22 1996 (IPS) - Over 300,000 people would have to be evacuated from Dublin and the east coast of Ireland if there was an major accident at the Sellafield nuclear waste plant in England, a scientist told local politicians on Wednesday.

Up to 50,000 people could die if such an accident occurred, said radiobiologist Peter Taylor, presenting the preliminary results of his study to county councillors in Dun Laoghaire-Rathdown, one of the three councils representing the Dublin area.

Dublin is geographically closer to the British Nuclear Fuels plant at Sellafield than some of the Ukrainian and Belarussian villages evacuated after the 1986 Chernobyl blast were to the scene of that disaster, so far the world’s worst.

Taylor said that a leakage at one of Sellafield’s twenty-one Highly Active Liquid Waste (HAW) tanks could result in the deaths of ten thousand to thirty thousand Irish people over a 50-year period.

“This risk does not need to be run,” Taylor said in a commentary on the results. “There are alternative methods of storage.”

However, a spokesman for British Nuclear Fuels defended the security of nuclear waste storage at Sellafield. “All our tanks are designed to strict regulations so we take everything into account at the design stage, at the construction stage and at the operational stage,” David Young, a press officer at Sellafield, told IPS.

The councillors were told that if an accident were to occur, the cost of death and illness to the Irish economy would be equivalent to about three billion dollars.

Taylor works with environmental consultancy Terra Mares and the research was commissioned by the 32 local authorities in Britain who are committed to the closing down of nuclear plants, the National Steering Committee of Nuclear-Free Local Authorities.

The figures are based on a conservative assumption, that ‘favourable’ weather conditions could limit the spread of any radioactivity spilled into the Irish Sea by a potential disaster.

Successive Irish governments have called for the closing down of the Sellafield plant, which they regard as accident-prone. “We want it shut down, it’s as simple as that,” a spokeswoman for the Irish government’s Department of Transport, Energy and Communications told IPS.

“And we avail of every opportunity to voice our concerns and opposition not only to Sellafield but also to the expansion of the nuclear industry.” Mary Sheerin, a spokeswoman for the department, said that Ireland — which has declared itself nuclear- free — raises the issue as often as possible in international fora.

However, environmentalists here believe that the Irish government are too passive in their opposition to Sellafield.

“The word that comes to mind is ‘paralysed’,” says Bernadette Connolly, the Green Party councillor who organised Taylor’s visit to Dublin. “Paralysed in not seeing a way forward. The (Irish) government has looked in a narrow fashion at the potential for action.”

The Republic of Ireland declared itself nuclear-free following public opposition to a 1987 plan by the country’s Electricity Supply Board to build a nuclear power plant in Carnsore, County Wexford.

Connolly was critical of the fact that the Irish government had never publicly raised the issue with the British government.

The Green councillor quoted a December 1995 report by the (British) Nuclear Industry Inspectorate (NII) which stated that Sellafield was “acceptably safe” but that it “did not meet modern safety standards in some respects”.

An Irish government agency, the Radiological Protection Institute, regularly monitors air and sea samples that might be affected by Sellafield.

A spokesman for British Nuclear Fuels, David Young, was reluctant to comment on whether the company had done any research on the impact on Ireland of an accident at one of their tanks.

“Which tank?” he asked IPS, as a form of reply. “Any tank, any one of the 21 tanks.” “That is so hypothetical — and implausible — that we would not do that sort of research,” Young said.

Asked for his view on safety at Sellafield, Jack O’Sullivan of Environmental Management Services offered “the following facts” to IPS. “One is that Sellafield has been plagued by accidents since the site was initially constructed, very rapidly, under what you could call post-war crisis conditions in the 1940s in Britain. It is accident prone.

“Secondly, it is worthwhile noting that we are closer to Sellafield than some of the villages that had to be evacuated after Chernobyl. And the third thing is that there is much more radioactive material stored in Sellafield than there ever was in Chernobyl.

Sellafield is a waste processor so it has a much greater inventory of radio nuclides.” For Connolly, the Terra Mares study underlines the importance of taking immediate action. “Do we sit around and wait for this to happen,” she asks “or do we insist on better safety now?”

“Sellafield has a history of having a number of incidents which were a cause for concern for the country,” said Sheerin. “There is a long history of what appears to be unsafe practices and incidents which have given rise to concern and continue to give rise to concern.

“The fact that we want it closed down speaks for itself.”

 
Republish | | Print |

Related Tags