Headlines, Latin America & the Caribbean | Analysis

HAITI-DOMINICAN REPUBLIC: Relations, after Balaguer

Analysis - Yves Marie Chanel

PORT AU PRINCE, May 14 1996 (IPS) - Economic pressures and the pull of democracy may help bring about rapprochement between Haiti and its closest neighbour, the Dominican Republic — regardless of the outcome of Thursday’s presidential elections.

President Rene Garcia Preval would not comment on the outcome of the Dominican vote, adopting a non-committal positon. “It is a sovereign country. A democracy. Let the best one win,” he said.

But Preval added that rapprochement between the two countries was irreversible. And privately, Haitian officials say the fact that Joaquin Balaguer, the 89 year old outgoing president, will be out of office after the elections is sufficient room for optimism.

“There is no ground for anxiety within the government regarding these elections,” said Gerard Pierre Charles, a leader of the Lavalas Political Organization (OPL), one of the three political parties in the left-wing coalition now ruling Haiti.

“The progress of democracy in the Dominican Republic, together with the demise of President Balaguer, who was known for this anti- Haitian feelings, should work for a reconciliation and the development of relations,” he said.

Pierre Charles asserts that everything will change, no matter the outcome. As a result of the economic and trade embargo against the Haitian military regime (1991-1994) the Dominican Republic has become sensitized to the importance of cooperation with Haiti.

This is especially true in regard to the expansion of markets and the establishment of a common market between the two nations.

Similarly, the three major political groups involved in the elections consider Haiti an important factor, to the point of making this a major these of electoral campaigning.

As an example, Pierre Charles mentions the discreet visit to Prime MInister Rony Smarth last month of a delegation composed of influential members of the Dominican Revolutionary Party (PRD) and of the Party for Dominican Liberation (PLD).

Last month, President Balaguer officially invited President Rene Preval to visit his country. This suggests a softening of the stance on Haiti of the ruling Reformist Christian-Social Party (PSRC) whose canidate is Jacinto Peynado.

While his attitude regarding Haiti over the last few years has been very ambivalent, even Leonel Fernandez, the businessman who is the PLD candidate – and who is reportedly favoured by the wily Balaguer — might ease the rapprochement.

Fernandez has always vacillated between identifying with the economic interests of Dominican business circles and a sensitivity to issues of democracy in Haiti.

But there is no doubt who is most favoured by Haitians: Jose Francisco Pena Gomez, the frontrunner and candidate of the Dominican Revolutionary Party (PRD).

“Pena Gomez has many connections with democratic circles in Haiti,” says Pierre Charles. “He has repeatedly visited Haiti and is very sensitive to the fight for democracy in Haiti. He would be favorable to a rapprochement with Haiti.”

However, he acknowledged that Pena Gomez, who is black, might try to balance out his political stance towards Haiti and thus act cautiously in an attempt to neutralize the negative propaganda that has been conducted against him.

“Haitians wish for a Pena Gomez’ victory. Pena Gomez’ presence in power in the Dominican Republic will lead to an improvement of the lives of sugarcane-cutters in this country and facilitate the establishment of more formal trade relations,” said Claude Desrosiers, co-manager of an important mutual fund society.

“If Pena Gomez wins the elections, we can expect an improvement in Dominican policies regarding labour migration” said Privat Trecil, assistant-coordinator of the official National Office of Migration.

Many Haitians have a negative perception of the current Balaguer government.

Balaguer is author of the book “La Isla al Reves,”(The Island in Reverse) in which he defends his anti-Haitian position. He was Minister of the Interior, in the government led by dictator Leonidas Trujillo y Molina in 1934 when 34,000 Haitians living in the Dominican Republic were massacred.

“Anti-Balaguerism” in Haiti was further reinforced following the deportation in the summer of 1991 of more than 12,000 Haitians (small traders, illegal farmworkers, or people born in the Dominican Republic).

At the time, this attitude of Balaguer’s government was seen as a demonstration of his hostility and attempts to destablize the government of President Aristide.

Since then, left-wing intellectuals in both countries (Party for Dominican Liberation (PLD) and Revolutionary Dominican Party (PRD) on the Dominican side, Haitian socialist parties, student groups on the Haitian side). have organized various social, cultural and athletic events to improve ties between the neighbours.

 
Republish | | Print |

Related Tags