Headlines, Middle East & North Africa

PALESTINE-HUMAN RIGHTS: Press Freedom, Past and Present

Deborah Horan and Pam van de Bunt

GAZA CITY, May 27 1996 (IPS) - After nearly a week of intense local and international pressure, the Palestinian Authority has released a well-known human rights activist jailed for telling The New York Times that during Israel’s military occupation of Gaza he was “100 times freer” than under the new Palestinian government.

Dr. Eyad Sarraj is one of Gaza’s leading psychologists and human rights activists and member of one of Gaza’s most influential families. He was released late Sunday night after spending six days in Gaza City’s main police installation where one of his cousins, Samir Sarraj, is second in command.

The release came after relentless pressure on the Palestinian Authority (PA) from members of the newly elected Palestinian Legislative Council, which passed a resolution against Sarraj’s detention.

Other members of the government as well as local and international human rights organizations also urged that he be released.

“I was really supported throughout this detention,” said Sarraj, after leaving the jail, “even by people in the Authority and in the elected council and other citizens of Palestine and abroad, through posters and articles.”

The week-long detention was the second time Sarraj has been arrested for speaking to the foreign press — on the first occasion, he spent 10 hours in interrogation and was released. It has raised grave concerns about the lack of freedom of speech and freedom of the press under the Palestinian Authority.

Since the Palestinian Authority entered Gaza in July 1994, several Palestinian journalists have been arrested for publishing articles, including a leading opposition Hamas editor jailed for three years for printing articles opposing the Oslo peace agreements signed with Israel.

Most recently, an editor of the Jerusalem-based daily newspaper Al-Quds was arrested for several days for failing to print a picture of Palestinian President Yasser Arafat on the front page. For lack of space, he published it on page eight.

On Dec. 18, Sarraj was held for nine hours at police headquarters in Gaza after he spoke to a group of journalists at a seminar organised for Arab and Israeli journalists by Inter Press Service (IPS).

Last week, the Arab Journalists Association organised work stoppages and a sit-in at the Shawa Cultural Centre in Gaza during a meeting of the Palestinian Legislative Council. They demanded freedom of press and protection of the rights of journalists.

A letter containing the names of 33 Palestinian journalists arrested and intimidated over the last two years was given to the Legislative Council with the request to stop the continuous harassments and arrests of journalists.

Fayez Nureldine, a photographer from Agence France Press (AFP) was the last name on the list. Nureldine was arrested on May 13 after his picture of a donkey on the beach of Gaza appeared in the Palestinian newspaper ‘Al Ayam’.

The photographer claims he was told that pictures of donkeys on the beach gave the Palestinian community a bad image.

“I tried to explain them that I did not want to embarrass anybody with this picture, it was just an image from the beach in Gaza,” the photographer told IPS. ” But this photo was apparently reason enough to beat me and keep me arrested for eight hours.”.

Nureldine’s colleague, Nabil Jouda, suffered the same fate four months ago. “There were clashes between the Palestinian Authority and Hamas when I tried to make a picture from an injured Palestinian. The police prevented me to take this picture and arrested me for three hours.”

However, Hassan el Kashef, General Director of the Ministry of Information, says the situation is improving.

“It is getting better now, there are much less incidents now than just after the arrival of the P.A. The problem is that we have to learn how to build a civil society. We hope to build a Palestinian civil society controlled by democracy and by the people,” El Kashef said.

“So in the future there will only be arrests for people with guns but we will speak to the people who have opinion and to the people who write.”

Also Sakher Abu Eloun, bureau chief of the French press agency AFP in Gaza is optimistic about the future. “Now the PA and their officials think they do not need us anymore but I am sure one day they will need us again. So I am sure it will become better for us again.”

The Palestinian Authority has not yet completed a Basic Law that would govern civil rights. Human rights organizations have criticized a hastily drawn up executive order governing the press as too broad and giving the government too much discretion.

Similarly, human rights organizations have criticized the Palestinian Authority’s decision to uphold a 1936 British Mandate law that curbs freedoms of press and speech.

In the offending New York Times article, published May 6, Sarraj was quoted by Times writer Anthony Lewis as stating that “…during the Israeli occupation, I was 100 times freer. I wrote in the Israeli press and the Arab press. Today I am boycotted by our press and television.”

Elsewhere in the article, Sarraj is quoted saying, “There are so many arbitrary arrests now, without charge, without reason. The Authority has nine security organizations, each with its own detention center. And people are systematically tortured.”

Palestinian Minister of Justice Freih Abu Middain said Sarraj was arrested because he offended Palestinians by unfavorably comparing their government to the occupation they fought and died to get rid of.

“This is an insult,” said Abu Middain, two days before Sarraj’s release. “He insulted every one of us, every mother who lost a child to Israeli gunfire, every Palestinian sitting in an Israeli jail.”

A day after his release, Sarraj refused to recant.

“I do think the situation is worse as far as the freedom of the press is concerned and that is because the newspapers are afraid of publishing,” Sarraj said from his home Monday afternoon.

But this time he emphasized that much had improved under the Palestinian Authority in the way of personal security — going to the beach or walking in the streets. His main complaint, he said, lay with the lack of freedom of speech and arbitrary arrests.

By speaking out against these injustices, he said he hoped to embolden others to do the same. But when news of his arrest first rippled through the Palestinian street, it seemed to have the opposite effect.

With a brother who is the director general of the Ministry of Economy and Trade, a cousin who is in Arafat’s inner circle of advisors, and another cousin high up in the police, Sarraj’s arrest sent a negative signal. If he could be arrested, what about ordinary Gazans?

“Draw your own conclusions,” quipped Dr. Haidar Abdel Shafi, a council member and one of Gaza’s most outspoken critics of the Oslo agreement and some of the actions of the Palestinian Authority.

 
Republish | | Print |

Related Tags