Europe, Headlines

HUNGARY: Religious Freedom Brings No Joy For Monastic Orders

Anna Jancso

BUDAPEST, Aug 15 1996 (IPS) - The political changes seen in Hungary over the last few years also ushered in a new era of religious freedom, yet the church reports that the number of young men taking up holy orders in the country’s monasteries has drastically fallen.

Religious orders that barely survived the best efforts of the former communist regime to ban them in the 1950s and 1960s are now in danger of following them into history.

Of the 23 Christian male orders in Hungary, five have no candidates at all for their vacant spaces in their monasteries and even major international orders like the Franciscans are shrinking in numbers in Hungary, albeit at a slower pace.

Several Hungarian based orders have fewer than ten monks, and statistically the average age of monks across the country’s religious community is getting older, stacking up more problems in the decades to come.

Before the communist authorities, in line with others across east and central Europe, abolished the religious orders in 1950, more than ten thousand monks and nuns lived in Hungary. By 1996, the number had dropped by two thirds.

But though forty years of oppressive communist rule had its effect, senior Franciscan Provincial Fr. Jakab Varnai warns that the years of atheist government cannot exclusively be blamed for the current problem.

“We see the same thing happening in western democracies too,” Varnai said. “Worldwide experience shows that it is not the current wave of politics that determines our futures, but our own ability to attach (our faith) to a new era driven by communication, technology and science.”

The issue opens up some complex and difficult questions for the monks and their leaders — not least the fact that the number of women entering nunneries has not declined by anywhere near as much.

Of the country’s 3,605 full members and novice trainees in its various religious orders, just over 2,600 are women and only 985 are men.

Again this is a worldwide phenomena. Three quarters of all the world’s members of religious orders are women and the largest order in the world is female, the Vincentians, with 29,000 members, compared with the 23,000 men who have dedicated themselves to the Jesuits and the world’s 19,000 Franciscan monks.

“I could not give a satisfying answer to why nuns are in such an overwhelming number as opposed to monks,” Varnai told IPS. He did not think it reflected the Catholic rule that women could not become priests. “I rather believe that women’s spiritual attitude is closer to the kind of life lived in a convent,” he said.

Free market economic reform has made even the ordinary person’s life that much harder in Hungary. The troubles and high cost involved in recovering or buying new property to serve as monasteries and then equipping them — as well as providing for the monks within them — has proven a heavy burden.

“The problem is that during the political changes in 1989 many orders did not monitor needs properly and did not know what a hard task they were facing when reopening a monastery,” said the Franciscan Provincial.

Also it takes at least four years for a novice to become a monk, and the austere lifestyle tempts many to abandon their would-be vocation. In a few cases — four in 14 years — some fully professed monks have left the Franciscans for the outside world.

Varnai says it would be a mistake to take the traditional view and dismiss those who giv up the vocation as ‘children of perdition’. Instead, he argues, the order’s own responsibilities should be reviewed in such cases.

Partly due to the years of Communist repression there is a missing generation of monks who would normally provide the support the older monks need and the guidance the younger novices deserve, he says.

“It makes things even worse that the generation of 40-50 year olds are completely missing from the orders,” says Varnai. “They should provide the backbone of monastery life.” He notes that the monasteries are increasingly full of the elderly and offer little attraction to the young.

The Provincial cites his own case. “I am 38 now. In normal circumstances it would be unimaginable that someone of my age performs the task of a provincial and presides over the Conference of Senior Convent Prefects.”

Senior religious leaders are taking note and representatives of the orders and the Hungarian Catholic Episcopacy are expected to form a joint committee in the near future to review the situation.

Varnai hopes that the committee will also examine whether all the orders have managed to successfully refound themselves since the fall of communist rule. The committee is likely to suggest that number of active religious orders be reduced in number and the members of the smaller orders encouraged to join others.

According to canon law, an order can only be abolished 100 years after its last representative dies. During this period there is also an opportunity to reorganise the order in another country.

However, the Pope has the right to abolish religious orders within this ‘tolerance period’. And closing down or integrating individual communities within individual orders can be carried out by a bishop.

Despite the historic traditions that might be lost or diminished by such mergers and closures, Varnai thinks the step may be a positive one in the long run.

“It is not the number of members of an order, but the quality of religious life that counts. And I am absolutely sure that this improved quality will attract a rising number of applications to monastery life.”

 
Republish | | Print |

Related Tags