Europe, Headlines

ITALY: Widespread Dismay as Priebke Walks Free

Jorge Pina

ROME, Aug 1 1996 (IPS) - A military tribunal freed former nazi captain Erich Priebke, accused of the execution of 335 Italian civilians during World War Two, in this city Thursday, bringing cries of outrage from the government, political parties and human rights organisations alike.

For while Priebke was found guilty of “multiple homicide” the nature of the Military Code he had sworn alliance to before ordering the 1944 Ardeatine Caves massacre was taken into account, and he walked free.

The verdict also classed the massacre as the lesser crime of “multiple homicide” as Priebke had acted in response to orders from above, is now 83 years old.

The sentence provoked angry reactions from the victims’ families, Jewish community representatives and all the nation’s political parties.

The military prosecutor, Antonino Intelisano, who had called for a sentence of life imprisonment, Wednesday, said he would be appealing against the decision.

“The whole world is watching you. It is up to you whether you reaffirm that war crimes confirmed by the United Nations have an expiry date or not. May God guide you,” said Intelisano Wednesday.

The prosecutor and the victims’ lawyers had called for the president of the Tribunal to be replaced, as he had been overhead to say he was in favour of Priebke being pardonned in private conversation.

Their appeal was rejected.

For the first time in history, the municipal authorities of Rome turned out the lights on the main city monuments as a sign of their distate at the outcome, leaving lights on only at the Ardeantine Caves, the disused mines on the outskirts of Rome where the massacre had taken place.

Italy’s head of government, Romano Prodi, expressed his regret and support for the victims’ families, while the leader of the Chamber of Deputies, Luciano Violante, went to the Ardeatine Caves to pay homage to the victims, and the Senate stopped working to keep a minute’s silence as a sign of respect.

The Democratic Left – part of the government alliance – announced it would be proposing a bill to abolish military tribunals in the Chamber of Deputies on Friday.

Meanwhile, Tullia Zevi, president of the Italian Hebrew Communities criticised the “terrible sentence,” adding that “a superb occassion was lost to issue a definitive condemnation of a system (nazism) which affected Europe 50 years ago.”

The Jewish community of the north Italian city of Milan also announced a protest march for Friday.

“We are extremely angry,” siad Simon Samuels of the Simon Wiessenthal Centre, an institution which works seeking to prosecute fugitive nazi war criminals.

“Italy had an appointment with history today, and they have sabotaged justice. Italy has supported genocide,” he added.

Massimos D’Alema, secretary of the Democratic Left Party (PDS), the main governing party, described the sentence as “an embarrassment,” while leader of the right wing Gianfranco Fini National Alliance said it was “morally unfair.”

“The crime of the butcher Priebke will never expire in the Italian consciousness,” said Communist Refoundation deputy Armando Cossuta, to applause from his colleagues.

“Fascists, fascists,” shouted an angry public mob, outraged that the man guilty of the biggest massacre of civilians in wartime Italy had been absolved.

When the verdict was read out, Priebke remained as impassive as he has been throughout the three month trial.

This former nazi officer had lived quietly hidden away in the south Argentine city of Bariloche for the last 50 years until he was extradited this year.

His future is now uncertain, for if he leaves Italy he could be arrested under an international warrant to be tried again under German law.

The Ardeantine Caves massacre was a particularly brutal episode in nazi repression, with 335 men and children, 75 of them Jewish, shot dead to pay for the lives of 33 German soldiers killed by the Italian resistence during the occupation of Rome.

Priebke was the man who chose which people to arrest, and was seen to kill two of the victims. The nazis had sworn to kill 10 Italians for each German, and the five extras were included as they could otherwise have served as witnesses to the events afterwards.

Intelisano stressed Priebke could have excercised free will, citing cases where nazi officials had refused to take part in vengence killings or murderous acts, adding that Priebke’s guilt was even deeper as this massacre had been “totally disproportionate and not even necessary.”

 
Republish | | Print |

Related Tags