Asia-Pacific, Headlines | Analysis

SOUTH ASIA: Put Aside Disputes, says China

Analysis - Praful Bidwai

NEW DELHI, Dec 5 1996 (IPS) - The just-ended visit to India, Pakistan and Nepal by Chinese President Jiang Zemin could be the beginning of a new era of Sino-South Asian friendship.

Under President Jiang, China seems to be recasting its policy towards India with whom ties were frozen for a quarter century over a still-unresolved border dispute.

While continuing to maintain close military ties with New Delhi’s arch-foe Pakistan, Beijing is moving towards a more even handed and balanced approach towards the subcontinent.

On the first ever visit to India by a Chinese head of state, Jiang proposed a set of rules for international conduct in the Sino-South Asian region. This will require Beijing, New Delhi and Islamabad to put aside contentious issues such as Kashmir and the disputed Sino-Indian border.

“If certain issues cannot be resolved for the time being, they may be shelved temporarily so that they will not affect normal state-to-state relations,” Jiang declared.

This is seen as a shot in the arm for New Delhi and a let down for Islamabad which questions India’s rule over Kashmir and insists that any progress in ties with India depends on resolving the Kashmir dispute.

With New Delhi, Jiang signed a major confidence-building agreement to reduce troops on the disputed border. This specifies the types of weapons to be pulled back, and commits the two sides to limit the number of troops deployed in military exercises.

It also bans flights by combat aircraft within 10 kilometres of the line of actual control — defined by the position of Indian and Chinese troops since the 1962 border conflict in which China occupied large chunks of Indian territory.

Together with agreements to prevent drug trafficking, extend consular relations after Hong Kong’s unification with mainland China, and establish shipping lines, this marks a big jump in Sino-Indian ties since the border ‘Peace and Tranquillity’ accord signed in September 1993. Tibet did not figure in Jiang’s discussions in India and Pakistan.

Jiang called for greater cooperation among the Sino-South Asian nations, “non-hegemonic relations” and regional unity to “effectively resist hegemonism and outside interference … and safeguard their independence”.

The new Chinese approach is is reflected in Jiang’s December 2 statement in Islamabad referring to Kashmir, which for the first time did not endorse Pakistan’s stand on the dispute.

China still insists that it will help Pakistan in the latter’s civilian nuclear programme and sell it arms. Beijing is assisting Pakistan to build a 300 MW nuclear power reactor. It was recently accused of having sold sensitive nuclear equipment with potential military uses and M-11 missiles to Pakistan.

However, under pressure from the U.S. and other Western states to prevent possible missile and nuclear proliferation, China has promised not to do so in the future and limit nuclear cooperation with Pakistan to the civilian field. China claims that the M-11s are not medium-range missiles and their sale is in keeping with the Missile Technology Control Regime.

The change in China’s position has been noted in Pakistan with a measure of concern. However, Indian leaders who raised the issue of nuclear and military cooperation between China and Pakistan, did not receive any assurance from Jiang.

“In India, the degree and extent of such cooperation tends to be greatly exaggerated,” says Achin Vanaik, a political scientist and foreign policy and strategic expert.

Jiang’s visit has opened up the possibility of a long-term non-adversarial relationship between China and India which can help pave the way to a breakthrough in the vexed border dispute.

India insists that the boundary is along the so-called MacMahon Line drawn by the colonial British rulers, whereas China argues that it always had a right to the Western Himalayan region known as Aksai Chin. Beijing has long proposed a give-and-take formula to turn the disputed boundary into into a permanent border.

Another traditional Chinese concern pertains to Tibet. The Dalai Lama is based in India along with 80,000 Tibetan refugees, but New Delhi has assured Beijing that it will not allow anti- Chinese activities by the Tibetans staying in India.

This stand has been criticised by human rights activists. However, the Tibetan stand too is changing with the Dalai Lama recently indicating that an arrangement involving greater

autonomy for Tibet within China could be acceptable.

With contentious issues thus put aside, China and India can work closer together. “This very possibility shows that conventional wisdom about two major states inevitably playing big power politics is wrong,” says Vanaik.

“China need not be a rival or adversary; nor need it be an ally. Those who want mutual military and political competition with China could be making a self-fulfilling prophecy.”

However, some analysts think that that China is changing policy towards South Asia to counter Western threats. “Beijing has real concerns that the United States is drifting towards a containment of China … building cooperative relations with all of the subcontinent could be an important counter to incipient containment,” says the English language daily, ‘The Hindu’.

 
Republish | | Print |

Related Tags