Headlines, Middle East & North Africa

PALESTINE-ISRAEL: Likud And Labour Forge ‘Final Status’ Objectives

Deborah Horan

JERUSALEM, Jan 23 1997 (IPS) - In an effort to find common negotiating ground in the run up to ‘final status’ talks between the Israelis and the Palestinians, members of Israel’s ruling Likud party have quietly strack their own peace pact with the opposition Labour Party

The Likud, once vehemently opposed to territorial concessions to the Palestinians, wants to see if they can agree on what the Israeli position during final negotiations with the Palestinians should be.

“It is such a critical issue, it’s advisable to see where the two parties converge or overlap,” said Israeli political analyst Dr. Mark Heller, a senior analyst at the Jaffee Center for Strategic studies.

“If the present government presented an agreement that contains elements acceptable to both parties, it would be easier to get it through the government,” he said.

The talks, which have been centered around the Likud’s Michael Eitan and Labour’s Yossi Beilin, are so far unofficial. But the Likud-led government has been groping with some possible ideas of its own to counter the Palestinian demand for an independent state in the West Bank and Gaza with East Jerusalem as its capital.

Israeli prime minister Benjamin Netanyahu said Tuesday he envisions Palestinians living under a “very generous autonomy”, but one without control over water, airspace, or the ability to enter into military pacts with third countries.

But his senior advisor, David Bar-Illan told the U.S. daily New York Times that Israel was “probably closer” to agreeing to a Palestinian state because “developments point in that direction.”

While Likud members have been bracing for this since entering office in June, with the long-awaited deal on the divided West Bank city of Hebron finally out of the way, the discussions are becoming public as both Israelis and Palestinians position themselves to move into negotiations on the ‘final status’ of the West Bank and Gaza, set to begin in two months.

In those talks, negotiators are supposed to discuss the divisive issues of Jewish settlements, Palestinian refugees, final borders, and the future of Jerusalem. But the two sides have much to resolve before they get to that day.

“In the next year, both sides are going to vie for territory in the West Bank,” said Khalil Shkaki, a politcal pundit who heads the Center for Palestine Research and Studies, a respected West Bank think tank. “The Palestinians want to see Netanyahu make large territorial concessions, while the Israelis want to keep it small.”

Over the next 18 months, Israel is supposed to slowly cede rural West Bank territory to the Palestinians as it ‘redeploys’ its troops, so that ultimately they are based only at Jewish settlements and ‘specified military locations.’ According to the agreement, all territory outside these designated areas should come under Palestinian control.

The question is how much territory that will be. Today, Palestinians are sovereign in eight cities, but which total land accounting for less than seven percent of the West Bank. They have partial sovereignty in an additional 450 villages, or just over 20 percent of the West Bank, but Israeli soldiers still patrol those villages.

Palestinians say that after these redeployments take place, some 85 percent of the West Bank will be theirs. Israel is not divulging figures, but Israeli analysts put the Israeli number closer to 50 percent. Netanyahu told an Israeli audience, after signing the agreement, that the 85 percent figure was a product of the imagination of Palestinian leader Yasser Arafat.

The figure is crucial because it will greatly affect the bargaining positions of both sides as they negotiate the terms of the ‘final status’ arrangement, say analysts. “If the Palestinian version is carried out, then Israel loses a lot of its bargaining cards,” said Heller.

Heller explained that Isarel wants the territory to give back as its big concession, side-stepping any discussion of dividing Jerusalem or dismantling settlements. “Israel has an interest in keeping these redeployments small.”

Netanyahu will likely get his way on the first Israeli troop pullback, due March 7, and keep it small. He has the backing of U.S. special envoy Dennis Ross, who said last week that the amount of territory given to the Palestinians at each redeployment stage was “Israel’s decision”.

With scenes of jubilation in the streets of Hebron still fresh in people’s minds, Arafat is unlikely to push too hard. Shkaki believes it will be the second and third redeployments “that are crucial.”

To deflect criticism, Netanyahu may open the ‘safe passage’ between the West Bank and Gaza and to release Palestinian prisoners, two Israeli obligations that have yet to be fulfilled and which were reiterated in the Hebron agreement.

The ‘safe passage’ is crucial for Palestinians, whose economy has been devastated by repeated Israeli “security closures” that prevent the movement of goods and people between the two areas. With roads joining the West Bank and Gaza, more commerce will be possible.

In return for keeping those promises, Netanyahu is likely to demand Palestinians live up to their commitments to “fight terrorism”, reword the Palestinian National Covenant, which presently sanctions violence against Israel, and extradite Palestinians that Israel says have carried out attacks.

While Palestinians will probably welcome those moves, they are not likely to give up the quest for large tracts of West Bank land. They reject the American position that the extent of the troop pullbacks is up to Israel. “We will not accept the U.S. permitting Israel to choose what lands she wants to return,” Arafat’s spokesman Marwan Kanafani said.

If Israel’s interpretation holds, Shkaki says he expects Arafat to stall on final negotiations and rally world international support.

“No reasonable man would believe that settlements and military locations make up 50 percent of the West Bank,” said Shkaki. “If Netanyahu insists on this, the Palestinians will take their case to outside governments.”

 
Republish | | Print |

Related Tags