Tuesday, November 17, 2026
Nadire Mater
- The Turkish military and Islamist prime minister Necmettin Erbakan are yet to bury the metaphorical hatchet, despite the latter’s public climbdown, under pressure, on accepting the army’s demands on stricter measures against ‘fundamentalism’.
The days leading up to Erbakan’s compliance had fed countrywide fears of a army takeover. Now the confrontation seems to have turned into a political race to establish as accepted fact, each side’s preferred interpretation of what was actually conceded.
Confronted with a 20 point list of demands from the army-led National Security Council (MGK), Erbakan initially refused to sign, buckling only when faced with a withdrawal of support from his junior partner in coalition government, the True Path Party (DYP).
He inked the list, but it remains unlikely that he can abide by its demands — it is specifically designed to cut off Erbakan’s Welfare Party from its Islamist supporters by forcing it to effectively renounce all its previously stated principles.
Erbakan put a brave face on an impossible situation, finding victory of a sorts by claiming that traditional secularist Turkey would now have to come to terms with Islamist opinion, which has given him the largest number of seats in the Turkish parliament of any single party.
“The fascist kind of secularism is now irreversibly buried in the past,” he told the military’s closest civilian ally, Republican People’s Party leader Deniz Baykal. Baykal Tuesday demanded Erbakan immediately implement the MGK demands.
The MGK itself tagged the original list with the clear warning that the terms had to be met immediately or “necessary sanctions are inevitable”. For this, read ‘coup’, said some. Husamettin Cindoruk, leader of Democratic Turkey Party, a splinter group from the DYP, urged Erbakan to implement of the MGK decisions, in order to save Turkish democracy from a military take over.
One of the major points included in the military’s required measures is a substantial reduction in the number of Turkey’s present 688 religious seminaries and Koranic courses — the heart of Islamist activism in Turkey. The MGK even advised the vacant properties that the resultant “excess capacity” should be turned over to vocational schools.
Welfare Party members concede that the seminaries are the main source of party cadres and grassroots activists. “We market religiously trained youth like (conventional) marketing specialists,”says Nevzat Laleli, chairman of the pro-Welfare Party National Youth Foundation (MGV), whish is in turn linked to students of religious seminaries and Koranic courses.
He cites several prominent Welfare Party figures who are also graduates of religious seminaries, including Greater Istanbul mayor Tayyip Erdogan. Laleli says some 14,000 seminary graduates have joined the Welfare Party, and that the aim is to quadruple that figure in the near future.
The MGK also “recommends” that the government close down all privately run Koranic courses, and bring all religious courses under the direct control of the Education Ministry. There are some 6,000 private courses currently approved by Turkey’s Religious Affairs Department; 1,219 are operated by voluntary associations, 53 by religious foundations and 80 by private individuals. The MGK claims that thousands more unlicensed courses are being run and want all of them shut down.
Four parties, including the DYP and the main opposition Motherland Party have already moved a joint bill covering the MGK demands. Should the parliament pass the draft the new legislation will effectively eliminate private religious courses across the country and restrict access for religious seminaries — stripping the Islamists of sizeable public funds for training its ‘believers’.
According to official figures there are now some 500,000 Turkish students of secondary and high school age now being trained in the country’s 687 religious seminaries — which means one in eight students aged between 12 and 17 years of age are receiving Islamic training. Another estimated 1.5 million students were certified by private Koranic courses in 1994 alone.
Secular Turkey’s religious seminaries were first opened in 1950 with the original aim of providing proper training for state- employed imams running the country’s mosques.
But over the last five decades the religious seminaries have been turned into a political tool in the hands of successive right wing governments, desperately seeking the backing of more conservative and traditional rural voters.
Religious seminaries have today extended their realm farther than their original purpose of training a supposedly limited number of imams.
Originally cut off from the university systems the seminary students were allowed into the further education system during the 1980’s and 1970s’ governments of then prime minister — now president — Suleyman Demirel. Most enrolled as students of political sciences and administration, which put another generation of seminary trained youth into the country’s civil service.
Ironically, the proposals are part of an even more detailed package of measures from the MGK that will make eight years elementary education compulsory for all — a long time demand of Turkish educationalists.
“Originally we too were for an eight year compulsory elementary education system,” says Kemal Bal, chairman of Turkey’s School Teacher’s Union. “However we are not for a total ban on religious seminaries,” he told IPS.
“The problem with the present system is that it is not the youth themselves but their families who make the decisions on their secondary education.”
Presently Turkey has a three tier education system; five years of compulsory primary education for children of seven to 12 years, followed by a non compulsory three years of secondary schooling and another three years of high school education. The new act, if passed would make education compulsory upo to 15 years.
It is at the secondary school level that parents get the chance to choose between places at vocational schools, general schools and religious seminaries for their children. An eight year system would effectively deny them that choice.
Decisions on choices of courses would be made within the school gates, not just at home by parents. “Once a eight year elementary education system is implemented, then children themselves would have relatively greater say on their future education,” Bal argues.
“The eight year compulsory education system has been under discussion for 25 years,” he said. The system most recently won the support of the country’s ruling National Education Council.
But even the support of the military — whatever the motive — may not see educational opportunities opened to the country’ youngsters.
It’s unlikely that even if the parliament passes the legislation Turkey might shift to an eight year system in the near future, Bal concedes. In the real world he doubts that any act that undermined the position of religious seminaries would ever be enforced.
“The seminaries play too great a part; almost all successive secularist governments have been forced to play their card in pursuit of Islamist votes.”
“It is highly unlikely that legislation making an eight elementary school system compulsory would be passed by the parliament,” says analyst Rusen Cakir, a specialist on Islamist movements. “Even if it is passed it is unlikely that it might be implemented in the near future.
“Its implications alone imply potential crisis. Eight year elementary education enables the youth to make their own decisions — which may not necessarily coincide with wishes of their relatively more conservative parents — and challenges the significance attached to religious seminaries by Islamist families.”
On Tuesday education minister Mehmet Saglam maintained that the eight year system will start in the 1997-98 school year, and will be established nationwide by the year 2000.
“Starting from 2000 we will be shifting to an 11 year compulsory education system,” he further claimed. But his commitment was already qualified.
“Nevertheless,” he said, “we are ready to counsel our coalition partner (the Welfare Party) and arrive at a reasonable solution.”