Development & Aid, Headlines, Human Rights, Middle East & North Africa, Population

JORDAN-PALESTINE: Refugees’ Long Wait For A Homecoming

Deborah Horan

AMMAN, Apr 3 1997 (IPS) - When the conversation in the Shihadeh home turns to the possibility that the family may one day return to their family homes in what they call Palestine, everyone starts to shout.

“He will never let us back,” says Adnan, one of the sons, ‘he’ being Israeli prime minister Benjamin Netanyahu.

Adnan’s mother, Fatima, an old woman draped in the long white head scarf favoured by older Palestinian women, clasps her hands together. “It’s all the Americans fault that we’re here because they support Israel,” she cries.

Her husband, Ahmed, dressed in a long white jalabiyyeh shirt, scoffs at hope. “(Palestinian president Yasser) Arafat will never get anything out of these negotiations with Israel,” he says.

One son, Amer, who owns a successful software company, maintains he would go back. “It is my homeland,” he says. “I would go back because of political reasons”.

The plight of the Shihadeh family mirrors that of almost four million Palestinians, according to the United Nations. They are refugees from two Middle East wars, one in 1948 that created the state of Israel, and one in 1967, in which Israel captured the West Bank and Gaza.

Today, they are dispersed across Jordan, Lebanon, Egypt and Syria, as well as the partially Palestinian-ruled West Bank and Gaza. For decades they have waited in limbo for a political resolution to their predicament.

If Netanyahu gets his way, negotiators may tackle the issue earlier than planned. The 1993 Oslo peace agreement signed between Israel and the Palestinians put the refugee issue on the negotiating agenda, but postponed discussions until the final stage, which were to have begun last month and end in 1999.

Netanyahu has been pressing the Palestinians to discard the timetable set up by the 1993 accord and move straight to the final talks.

Right now, relations are strained by the daily violence that has raged in the West Bank and Gaza since Israel started construction of a new Jewish housing project in historically Arab east Jerusalem.

But Netanyahu has not given up on the idea of scrapping the old timetable in favour of a quicker solution, assuming the two sides overcome the current impasse, said a Netanyahu aide. If both sides agree, the refugee question would be put on the table now with a view to a final resolution in less than a year.

“That issue would be brought up in the final status talks,” said Michael Stoltz, a spokesman in the prime minister’s office. “If the talks are intensive enough we should get them finished within six to nine months.”

Israel is pushing for intensive negotiations similar to the talks at Camp David between then-Israeli Prime Minister Menachem Begin and then-Egyptian President Anwar Sadat that led to the breakthrough 1979 peace treaty between the two nations.

Stoltz said Netanyahu would likely bring up the demand to move to final negotiations when he meet U.S. president Bill Clinton on Monday. The day before, according to Isreali Radio, he is scheduled to meet Jordan’s King Hussein, who is in Minnesota receiving medical treatment.

But Stoltz declined to comment on what Israel’s negotiating position would be regarding refugees. Israel’s past position has held firm against the return of refugees who fled in 1948 to villages that are now within the sovereign borders of the state. Such an influx would drastically change the demographic balance of Israel, which is now about 82 percent Jewish and 18 percent Arab.

Refugees from 1967, who left homes in the West Bank and Gaza, are more likely to be considered possible returnees, although some Israeli government officials have expressed an interest in monitoring the flow.

So far, some 50,000 Palestinians, mostly members of the Palestine Liberation Organisation who returned from Tunis to set up the Palestinian self-rule government, have returned to the West Bank and Gaza.

Included in that number are several thousand police who were once in Palestine Liberation Army units attached to the armies of Egypt, the Sudan, Jordan and Yemen.

Palestinians maintain that all refugees should have the right to return to their homes and property, regardless of whether they fled in 1948 or 1967.

“All Palestinians must be entitled to come back to their homes,” said Saeb Erekat, a top Palestinian negotiator. “This would include the refugees from 1948 and 1967.”

But for most refugees in Jordan, the idea of returning to land lost in Palestine is a right that they claim, a dream they hold in the back of their minds, and a topic for leisurely, if emotional, discussion.

Many say they don’t see it happening in the near future. “I think it’s a useless question because it will never happen,” said Aisha Alan, a Palestinian born in Amman whose parents were from the Jerusalem suburb of Ein Kerem.

In Jordan, returning is not a pressing subject for most Palestinians. Compared to other Arab countries, the refugees here are relatively well off.

There is poverty in the camps, but they look more like villages, with an underground sewage systems and paved streets, and most Palestinians do not live in camps.

Until 1988, when King Hussein renounced his country’s claim to the West Bank, Palestinian refugees were given Jordanian passports.

At least 70 percent of Jordan’s four million citizens are of Palestinian origin, including 1.3 million registered with the United Nations as refugees. Palestinians have held ministerial posts in many Jordanian governments.

By comparison, the 350,000 Palestinian refugees in Lebanon cannot work legally and are not given citizenship. Over half of the refugees there still live in the squalid and burned-out camps that were at the epicentre of the bloody 15-year civil war that officially ended in 1990.

Even if many Palestinians would opt to stay in Jordan if given a choice, most say they still want to establish a state in the West Bank and Gaza so that stateless Palestinians scattered around the globe have a place to call home.

They point to Libya’s expulsion last year of hundreds of Palestinians, most of whom ended up in camps in no-man’s land between the Libyan-Egyptian border or Egypt’s border with Gaza.

Others spent days floating in boats on the Mediterranean. No Arab country would take them in and Israel would not allow them into Gaza or the West Bank.

Even in Jordan, there are some individual families, like the refugees in Lebanon, are desperate to return to the West Bank or Gaza because it is their only possibility to take citizenship somewhere.

Tahani, a 33-year-old computer analyst in Amman, has family stuck in Iraq, the only country that would take them in. But she is not optimistic. Her family fled the coastal town of Jaffe in 1948 and made their way to Kuwait.

In 1991, following the Gulf War, they were expelled. Tahani and her mother, a Jordanian, came to Amman. Her father and brothers went to Iraq.

“I don’t think the refugees from 1948 will ever be discussed in negotiations,” she said. “Today, we do not have the right to return.”

 
Republish | | Print |

Related Tags