Headlines, Human Rights, Middle East & North Africa

PALESTINE: Administrative ‘Ethnic Cleansing’ In Jerusalem

Deborah Horan

JERUSALEM, Apr 30 1997 (IPS) - One morning in January, Farida al-Falah, a Palestinian born in Jerusalem, went to Israel’s interior ministry to renew the old and torn identity cards that belonged to her and her 18-year-old son, Hatem.

She brought documents proving that her husband worked in Jerusalem, that the family’s home was in the city, and that they had paid municipal taxes for the last decade. She brought birth certificates and receipts for electricity and water bills going ten years back.

But instead of renewing the cards, ministry officials deleted both of their names from the computerised registry.

Al-Falah said no explanation was given, but she suspects it was because of her son’s report card: it showed he went to school in the West Bank, just north of Jerusalem’s city borders. “It’s the only document out of all of them that connects us with the West Bank,” she said.

Israeli and Palestinian human rights activists allege that the al- Falah’s, like hundreds of other Palestinians who have had their Jerusalem identity cards revoked by the interior ministry, are victims of a policy designed to change the demographic balance in east Jerusalem.

The aim of the policy, they say, is to pre-determine the outcome of negotiations over Jerusalem by creating a Jewish majority in the eastern half of the city before negotiations are concluded in May 1999.

“They want to achieve a demographic situation in Jerusalem where the Palestinian population is small enough that the Palestinian negotiators cannot use demographics as a basis for claims of sovereignty,” charged Ingrid Jardat-Gassner, a researcher at the Alternative Information Centre, who has been documenting cases of lost identity cards.

So far, close to 2,000 Palestinians have lost their Jerusalem residency cards because they moved to housing outside the Israeli- defined borders of the city, according to human rights groups’ estimates.

But roughly 60,000 of the 160,000 Palestinians holding Jerusalem identity cards have moved to suburbs that fall in the West Bank because of a severe housing shortage in the city, Palestinians estimate. All of them risk losing their residency cards.

Today, Palestinians make up about 28 percent of the city’s overall population. They are concentrated in the east, where one of every two residents is a Palestinian. If 60,000 Palestinians lose their residency cards, their number in east Jerusalem will drop to about one in every three.

“We think this will have far-reaching consequences,” said Jardat-Gassner. “Tens of thousands of Palestinians may be affected by this.”

Interior ministry officials deny that the policy is connected to upcoming negotiations over the city, which have been on hold since Israeli construction of a new Jewish housing project in Jerusalem last month led to a breakdown in the talks.

But ministry officials admitted that if a resident of Jerusalem moves to the West Bank, the ministry will revoke his residency card and he will lose his right to return to the city. “It’s considered like moving out of Israel,” said Tova Ellinson, a spokeswoman at the ministry.

The policy rests on a 1952 law that says a permanent resident loses his residency if he lives outside of Israel for seven years or more. Most Palestinians in east Jerusalem are permanent residents, not citizens, of Israel.

The law has been upheld twice by Israel’s Supreme Court. First, in a 1988 case involving Mubarak Awad, a famous Palestinian pacifist deported from Israel for his political beliefs, the Court said the ministry could revoke his residency because he had been living in the United States for more than seven years.

Then in 1994, the Supreme Court opened the door for a less rigid application of the law. In a case involving Fathiyyeh Shkaki, the widow of assassinated Islamic Jihad leader Fathi Shkaki, the Court denied her residency although she had lived in Damascus for less than seven years. It held that she had moved her “centre of life” outside Jerusalem.

Human rights activists say that by the end of 1995, the interior ministry began using that ruling to revoke residency rights from Palestinians who had spent less than seven years abroad. And they began to apply it to Palestinians who moved their ‘centre of life’ to West Bank villages outside Jerusalem.

“The situation is so bad that people are afraid to go to the interior ministry,” said Yuval Ginbar, a senior researcher at the Israeli human rights group, B’Tselem. “They don’t know where they stand so they don’t apply for travel documents, they don’t try to renew old cards.”

Palestinians may not be able to escape the trip to the interior ministry for long. Ministry officials said they plan to begin issuing new magnetised identity cards to both Israeli citizens and permanent residents over the summer. The old cards will no longer be valid.

Palestinians who lose their residency in effect end up trapped in the West Bank. They cannot get to Jerusalem without risking a 150 dollar fine. They cannot travel abroad.

They are no longer legal residents of Jerusalem, yet they are not allowed to become residents of the West Bank either. The Palestinian Authority cannot give them passports. “It is an issue for negotiations with Israel,” said the Palestinian’s deputy interior minister, Ahmed Tamimi.

For the al-Falahs, the loss of Farida and Hatem’s Jerusalem residency means the family must now think about moving to the West Bank. As it is, neither Farida nor Hatem can now get pass the Israeli army checkpoint that lies between the family’s home in the north of the city and the city centre. Hatem cannot get to his job in his father’s clothing factory in the city.

“This is an impossible situation,” explained Farida’s husband, Younis, who, along with the other al-Falah children, still has his identity card. “My wife and my son cannot live without any identity documents.”

 
Republish | | Print |

Related Tags