Thursday, November 19, 2026
Deborah Horan
- Israeli settlement expansion in the West Bank and Gaza overshadowed a summit Tuesday between Israeli Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu and Egyptian President Hosni Mubarak in the Egyptian resort of Sharm el-Sheikh.
Still, the summit was the first high level contact between Israeli and Arabs in more than two months and the first signal that a negotiating freeze in place since Israel began a new Jewish housing project in east Jerusalem may be thawing.
After the meeting, both Netanyahu and Mubarak said that more time was needed to get the peace process back on track. “We need another meeting and we need more deliberations,” Mubarak told reporters after the mid-morning summit.
“This is a positive beginning,” Netanyahu told reporters. “But we need more work and we are committed to work together with you (Egypt) to achieve progress.”
Palestinian President Yasser Arafat met with Mubarak Monday for deliberations prior to Mubarak’s meeting with Netanyahu. Last week, he characterised Israel’s continued settlement expansion as a dangerous action that would lead to “not only war, but confusion in all of the Middle East”, according to local Israeli press reports.
The Hebrew daily newspaper Yedioth Ahronot speculated that Netanyahu would propose a compromise on the key issue that has been holding up progress in negotiations: the building on Har Homa, the southern Jerusalem hilltop that Palestinians call Jabal Abu Ghneim. Israel’s March groundwork at the site precipitated the negotiating breakdown.
According to the newspaper, Israel would pledge to finish preliminary work at the site, such as roads and sewage, and then halt construction while it began building housing for Palestinians in Jerusalem. Then, both housing projects would be constructed simultaneously.
However, an Israeli spokesman denied that any such compromise had been offered to Mubarak. “There are no plans to halt construction in Har Homa,” said Michael Stoltz, a spokesman in the prime minister’s office.
Arafat dismissed Israel’s promise to build housing for Palestinians in the city. “The problem is not building for Palestinians, but halting the settlements,” he told the Israeli daily Ha’aretz newspaper.
“The most important thing now is to stop the violations,” Arafat said. “The construction . . . is one of the gravest violations.”
Palestinians have conditioned a resumption of peace negotiations on an Israeli freeze of the Har Homa project and of all settlement construction in the West Bank and Gaza. Since the negotiating impasse, talks on all peace issues have been put on hold and security cooperation has been scaled down to a minimum.
Since the Netanyahu government came to power last June, building in settlements deemed “political” and therefore not allowed to expand by Israel’s previous peace-seeking Labour government has resumed, according to a report published by Peace Now, an Israeli organisation opposed to settlements.
Netanyahu’s right-wing government coalition, which includes a party representing the settlers, has said additional housing is needed to keep up with the natural population growth of the settlements.
But a U.S. government report made public week cast doubt on the need for additional settlement construction. The report found that 26 percent of settlements in the West Bank and 56 percent in Gaza were actually vacant.
Settler leaders called the report “ludicrous”, while Netanyahu said it was “false by an order of magnitude, to put it mildly.”
“The (U.S.) numbers were totally out of context,” said Yehudit Tayar, spokeswoman for the Yesha Council, an umbrella settlers’ organisation. “It’s a very transparent attempt to mislead the public. Obviously there’s a scheme in why they are saying this”.
Even Peace Now leader Mossi Raz also said the figures were much larger than those his organisation’s ‘Settlement Watch’ committee had gathered. He put the number of vacant houses in settlements closer to 12 percent. The U.S. stood by its report.
But the U.S. report may explain in part why the Americans have stepped back to allow Egypt to play matchmaker, despite that country’s vocal support for the Palestinians. After a nine-day visit by U.S. envoy Dennis Ross failed to produce a breakthrough, Egypt agreed to host the summit while U.S. Secretary of State Madeleine Albright said “the parties themselves have to make some hard decisions.”
A smaller U.S. role may please the Palestinians. An opinion poll taken by the Jerusalem Media and Communications Center, a Palestinian research centre, found that 91 percent thought the U.S. was biased toward Israel.
But a smaller U.S. role has not translated so far into fewer settlement construction plans, one of the festering issues likely to lead to an all-out confrontation between Israelis and Palestinians.
A report in the Sunday Times of London said Netanyahu agreed to meet with Mubarak after receiving a classified document from his Shin Bet security service explaining that continued settlement expansion could lead to violence and even war. Netanyahu’s spokesman, David Bar-Ilan, denied the report and said the document did not exist.
Instead, Stoltz said, Israel plans to continue building in the settlements. “We’re not required to (stop building settlements) under the Oslo accords and there’s no intention to strangle the existing Jewish communities,” he said.
That policy suits the settlers as long as they see it in action, said Tayar. “We have a lot of people interested in moving into our communities,” she said. “There is a very large demand. There are people on waiting lists.”