Development & Aid, Economy & Trade, Europe, Headlines

DEVELOPMENT: Germans Ponder Ways Of Easing Globalisation’s Bite

Ramesh Jaura

BONN, Jan 29 1998 (IPS) - The German government and opposition are in agreement on the principle that development aid can be used to ease the pain of globalisation in the South — but they disagree on how the principle should be applied in practice.

With a general election due here on Sep. 27, the differences on the policy detail between Chancellor Helmut Kohl’s Christian Democrat-led coalition and an increasingly confident Social Democrat opposition take on renewed significance.

At issue are the measures required to help tackle the pressing problems of global poverty, environmental degradation and population growth. And so far, says Uschi Eid, the development policy spokeswoman of the opposition Alliance 90/The Greens, Bonn has done hardly anything to narrow the global welfare gap.

The richest 20 percent of the earth’s population continue to own 85 of the world’s income, says Eid, and 1.3 billion people in the developing world live under the poverty line, 70 percent of them women.

Yet, she says, the German government talk proudly of their commitment as if they were “spearheading a Third World solidarity movement”. The ruling coalition of Kohl’s conservative CDU, its Bavarian sister CSU and the liberal FDP, have not matched their words with deeds, she says. She accuses the government of “failure to do justice to its global responsibility”.

Guenter Verheugen, spokesman for the social democrat SPD, Germany’s largest opposition party at federal level, agrees: “Whether the next century will bring greater joy to the whole of humankind than the outgoing one, will depend on whether we succeed in bridging the gap between what we know and what we actually do.”

For Verheugen, speaking during a development policy debate in the federal parliament on Jan. 15, the burden of armed conflict in the developing world has resulted in a “stark imbalance”.

Efforts for sustainable and ecologically sound development are wiped out by the arms build-up worldwide. “Of what use are investments and development aid, if everything that we are trying to build up is destroyed by wars?” he asked.

According to a recent study massive reductions in military expenditure in the industrialised countries conceal the fact that military spending remains very high, or is increasing, in many developing countries.

Paul George from the Centre for Foreign Policy Studies, Dalhousie University, in Halifax, Canada, says that though total military expenditure of the North Atlantic Treaty Organisation fell by more than 25 percent in the period 1987-1996, military spending in South Asia — Bangladesh, India, Pakistan and Sri Lanka — increased by more that 13 percent in the same period.

Corresponding figures for selected countries in the Middle East — Iran, Israel, Jordan, Saudi Arabia and the UAE — show an increase of more than 11 percent over the ten years since 1987. In South East Asia — Indonesia, Malaysia, the Philippines, Singapore and Thailand — military spending increased by a staggering 35 percent over the same period.

George says this kind of spending is often unjustified, even allowing for legitimate security requirements, and reduce the share of scarce public resources available for sustainable development.

During the development policy debate mid-January, the CDU-CSU parliamentary whip, Wolfgang Schaeuble, took up a similar line.

“It is easier said than done,” he said, “when it comes to speaking about giving a fair chance to the developing countries and helping them to help themselves.” The way the developed nations conducted themselves was not always “free from contradictions”.

Schaeuble — whose wife, Ingeborg, is the president of a leading German and European developmental NGO, Deutsche Welthungerhilfe — is the first CDU-CSU party whip to have spoken in the federal parliament on aid policy issues.

He also tackled developed nation attitudes. One the one hand, he said, industrial nations forgave developing countries’ debts, on the other they put up trade restrictions which barred them from earning foreign exchange. This in turn forced them to borrow more abroad and back into the debt cycle.

Schaeuble cited World Bank figures that projected an annual growth of five to six percent in the developing countries until the year 2020. However, official development assistance (ODA) alone could not do the job. Private capital flows were also necessary.

These in turn call for improving the political and economic framework conditions in developing countries.

Germany’s minister of economic cooperation and development, Carl- Dieter Spranger agrees on this point. “Given adequate framework conditions, the globalised capital market offers sufficient financing possibilities,” Spranger told parliament.

He says Bonn is funding some 100 projects worldwide with this objective in mind. But restructuring economies to lure globalised capital is no small task, particularly in sub-Saharan Africa where the need is greatest.

According to the IMF sub-Saharan Africa’s share of world trade fell from three percent in the mid-1950s to just one percent in 1995. The region attracted a mere 2.4 percent of foreign direct investment to developing countries in 1995 and contributes just 2.4 percent of global gross domestic product — and 40 percent of that is contributed by just two countries, South Africa and Nigeria.

Schaeuble’s “sufficient financing possibilities” are being hogged by the richer developing nations as well. Private investment in sub-Saharan Africa more than doubled between 1994 and 1995 to 11.8 billion dollars, but more than half went to South Africa alone.

Meanwhile the average per capita income in Africa has halved from 14 percent of average industrial country levels to seven percent — feeding poverty in countries that are now expected to cut spending in social provision to make their nations better suited for the globalisation rollover.

And at the same time Spranger’s ministry has had to cut its 1998 ODA budget to 7,600 million marks, down from 7,803 million marks (4,590 million dollars) last year.

“This reduction is lower than feared,” says Peter Molt, chairman of the Association of German development NGOs (VENRO) comprising 73 member organisations in Germany. “But there is no reason to give an ‘all clear’ sign.”

Germany, committed to paying 80 billion dollars a year to underwrite East German recovery, says it can only afford to spend 0.27 percent of its gross national product on its ODA this year. “This means moving farther away from the United Nations target of 0.7 percent of GNP,” added Molt.

 
Republish | | Print |

Related Tags