Development & Aid, Global, Global Geopolitics, Headlines, Human Rights, Population

RIGHTS: UN Group Discusses Age Limit for Sending Kids to War

Gustavo Capdevila

GENEVA, Feb 9 1998 (IPS) - One of the most controversial humanitarian norms, which authorises 15-year-olds to be sent to war, could be left standing due to failure to reach an agreement on its reform in the United Nations.

The working group designated by the UN Human Rights Commission which is attempting to establish an age limit of 18 is nearing the end of its current sessions (Friday) without any outlook for an agreement.

Up to now, U.S. objections had held up the reform sought by independent humanitarian institutions and specialised UN agencies.

But while the minimum age for recruiting soldiers in the United States is 17, the U.S. delegation said it would accept an 18 year age limit, but only referring to direct participation in armed conflict.

Washington’s proposal would allow under 18’s to participate in an indirect manner. While a 17-year-old could help load bombs, for example, the bomber would have to be flown by someone over 18, a U.S. delegate explained.

Pakistan and Syria, meanwhile, requested that any modification of the norm refer to a peoples’ right to self-determination, as a form of recognising an exception to the age limit in cases of liberation struggles.

On Monday, UN High Commissioner for Human Rights Mary Robinson urged the delegations that had put forth objections not to block approval of the reform by the rest of the countries.

“The time has come to demostrate more than ever an international solidarity on behalf of children in armed conflicts,” Robinson told the plenary session of the working group.

Alluding to the U.S. objections, Robinson added that “I also share the view that national legislation should not be presented as an obstacle to the elaboration of such new and more advanced international standards.”

The working group was commissioned to draft an Optional Protocol to the Convention on the Rights of the Child on involvement of children in armed conflicts.

Sweden’s Nils Eliasson, the group’s chairman, suggested it attempt to reach an accord in informal sessions, which got underway Monday.

Studies conducted by independent organisations indicate that in the past few years more than 250,000 children under 18 have served in government armed forces or armed opposition groups.

Although the Convention on the Rights of the Child defines under 18-year-olds as minors, article 38 establishes the controversial age limit of 15 for recruitment and involvement in armed conflicts.

A UN-commissioned study of the problem of child soldiers carried out by Mozambican expert Graca Machel graphically demonstrated the impact of armed conflict on the children involved, and abuses against girls in particular.

Last year UN Secretary-General Kofi Annan designated African diplomat Olara Otunnu as his personal representative on the question of children in armed conflicts.

Otunnu’s first report reflected the gravity of the problem, and demanded measures to sanction governments and armed groups that recruit children.

The campaign against the involvement of minors in wars has also been supported by non-governmental organisations such as the International Committee of the Red Cross and the Red Crescent, the International federation Terre des Hommes and the Global Alliance of Young Christian Associations.

 
Republish | | Print |

Related Tags