Headlines, Human Rights

HUMAN RIGHTS: Africa Absent from UN Debate on Racism

Gustavo Capdevila

GENEVA, Mar 2 1998 (IPS) - No representatives of sub-Saharan Africa are taking part in the discussions bates within the United Nations’ Committee on the Elimination of Racial Discrimination this year.

The Committee started its first annual period of sessions Monday, with a representation of nations biased toward the Western countries.

Of the 18 members of the body, 10 come from European countries, four from Latin America, three from Asia and only one, Egypt’s Mahmoud Aboul-Nasr, from the continent of Africa.

The absence of representatives from southern Africa was judged by the other members as a delicate problem for the body, compounded by the scarce representation of women, with only three in the entity.

Outgoing Committee president, Britain’s Michael Parker Banton, said the distribution of seats “creates a very serious panorama.”

Indian expert, Shanti Sadiq Ali described the situation as “tragic” because the International Convention on the Elimination of All Forms of Racial Discrimination states “all civilisations must be represented geographically in our committee.”

“But Africa is not represented and the composition of the commitee is dominated by Europe,” stressed Sadiq Ali.

The last two representatives of sub-Saharan Africa to the committee, the Nigerian Hamzat Ahmadu and Zumbabwe’s Andrew Chigovera, withdrew from the body in 1997.

The Convention member States designated the US Gaye McDougall, and Sweden’s Peter Nobel. McDougall, Sadiq Ali and the Chinese expert Zou Deci, are the only women on the Committee.

Sadiq Ali said the member states “do not designate women as they think the issue has nothing to do with them.”

But the absence of delegates from sub-Saharan Africa is due to internal problems of the sub-regional bloc, according to sources in human rights entities.

Venezuela’s Enrique ter Horst, UN Deputy High Commissioner for Human Rights, explained the governmental delegates from sub- Saharan Africa could not reach the agreement necessary to designate representatives during the meeting of member States in New York, last January.

“The African States are not well organised. They have many very good candidates, but they did not reach a consensus,” said Theodoor van Boven, the Committee member from the Netherlands.

This was the first time the problem of consensus had come up for the racial discrimination committee, but this had already happened with the Africans in other specialist entities, like the Human Rights Commission and the Human Rights Committee, said Van Boven.

The committee members are independent experts recommended by the government of their countries and chosen by all the states parties of the Convention on the Elimination of Racial Discrimination.

This designation procedure creats “great political involvement,” stated van Boven, an human rights expert who took a lead role during the military dictatorships of the seventies in South America.

The panorama became complicated for the Committee because in the current two-year period, which started Monday, the presidency of the body is held by an African representative.

The committee finally chose Egypt’s Aboul-Nasr, who said he had refused the designation up until the last moment as a sign of his disagreement with the make-up of the committee.

Aboul-Nasr told IPS that Western cultural representation predominated in the body, between East and West Europe, the United States and the Latin Americans.

The Egyptian expert maintained the scarce presence of the Asians and Africans in the committee contradicts the principles of the convention of balanced representation betweeen all civilisations, cultures and legal systems.

Van Boven shared the criteria that the Committee has an out of unbalance composition but said “the Commitee does not represent Western interests.”

He said the Committee for the Elimination of Racial Discrimination has taken a very critical stance on the West at times and “although its members are influenced by their background they do not necessarily play to the West.”

And the problem is not restricted to racial discrimination, as there is also ethnic violence in almost all the countries, which the committee has sworn to censure. This has earnt the body much criticism.

The Committee, responsible for lobbying for the fulfilment of the racial discrimination convention, elected Argentina’s Mario Jorge Yutzi, Romania’s Ion Dianconu and Cyprus’s Michael Sherifis as vice-presidents.

 
Republish | | Print |

Related Tags