Economy & Trade, Global, Global Geopolitics, Headlines

POLITICS: U.N. Ponders Future of Multi-Million Dollar Project

Thalif Deen

UNITED NATIONS, Mar 25 1998 (IPS) - The United Nations is reviewing a multi-million dollar computerised data project whose costs have zoomed from an estimated 28 million to 73 million dollars – before the system even is running.

The Integrated Management Information System (IMIS) – regarded by some critics as a white elephant – has been plagued by such heavy cost overruns that some member nations want the world body to cut its losses and terminate the project.

“The IMIS story was amazing but not surprising, because this was the United Nations,” says Nester Odaga-Jalomayo of Uganda, “Where else would it be possible to have a project of this sort protected?.”

Addressing the U.N.’s Administrative and Budgetary Committee, the Ugandan delegate described the project as “terminally ill.” To be treated, he said, more resources were needed, but member states were not being given a clearer picture of the health of the patient.

“The 10-year-old project must be brought to an end,” contends Djamel Moktefi of Algeria who says that IMS has been poorly managed and poorly monitored.

IMIS is a massive data base covering every single aspect of the U.N. system, including payroll, requisition, contractors, property management, staff entitlements, insurance, cash management, fund distribution and travel and transportation. Orginally estimated at only 28 million dollars, the costs have more than doubled, reaching nearly 73 million dollars.

The project, launched in 1988, has missed its a completion deadline of January 1994 and now is due to completed by the end of 1999.

IMIS was designed to replace current administrative systems, many of which are more than 30 years old. Described as both “complex and challenging”, it is intended to link up the Secretariat with all of the U.N. regional commissions, field offices and U.N. Funds and Programmes.

The New York-based consultancy firm, Price Waterhouse, the IMIS contractor, was paid about three million dollars purely on account of delays attributed to the Secretariat.

“The IMIS project was ill-planned, poorly defined and executed,” says Humayun Kabir of Bangladesh. “It was not clear who was responsible for the mismanagement,” he told delegates.

Kabir accused the Secretariat of failing to maintain “transparency and accountability” on such a major financial undertaking. “The contract had been amended 14 times,” he said.

The U.N.’s Advisory Committee on Administrative and Budgetary Questions has said the cause of the delays had not been analysed or addressed objectively. “Why had the Organisation been forced to bear that financial burden, and under what circustances,”? asked Kabir.

Ahmed Farid of Saudi Arabia says that a further analysis of the entire project should be carried out by the U.N.’s Office of Internal Oversight Services and the results submitted to Secretary- General Kofi Annan.

Farid sought information on the reasons for the increase in costs. That could not be compared to the cost of constructing a building. “It was cheaper at this point to demolish the building and buy a new one,” he added.

Eva Silot Bravo of Cuba said it was troubling to discover that after 10 years in existence, IMIS was so costly for the Organisation. “The Organisation had now become vulnerable to demands for additional payments from IMIS contractors,” she said, adding that no payment could be made until there was an updated system and updated work plan.

U.N. Under-Secretary-General Joseph Connor, head of the Department of Administration and Management, said the failure rate on constructing systems of this type was over 60 percent. “That was not a proud record of accomplishment and should be kept in mind,” he added.

The initial concept on which the estimate of some 28 million dollars had been made was for a different type of end product, he added. There was nothing available today that had all the functionalities the United Nations needed, Connor said. “There was no intention to expand the project. Getting the system up and running by the end of 1999 was the priority,” he said.

In justifying the project, former U.N. Secretary-General Boutros Boutros-Ghali said tha present “antiquated system” cannot be relied upon. “They provide bad information and late; they lead to wrong decisions from a management perspective; they are beyond repair; and eventually they will collapse,” he says. “Realistically, there is no alternative but to complete the (IMIS) project,” he advised.

The Secretariat says that IMIS already has more than 1,200 active users connected across six buildings housing U.N. offices in New York city alone, and is in operation in eight other locations around the world.

 
Republish | | Print |

Related Tags