Development & Aid, Economy & Trade, Europe, Headlines

DEVELOPMENT-EUROPE: Court Ruling Throws EU’s NGO Funding Into Chaos

Niccolo Sarno

BRUSSELS, Jun 12 1998 (IPS) - The European Union’s executive Commission has temporarily frozen funding to a number of social and development programmes following a ruling by the European Court that has called the technical legality of the payments into doubt.

Despite the rising concern of non-governmental organisations whose social development programmes have been left in question by the ruling, Commission spokesman Thierry Daman says he will not name the specific projects or EU funded NGO activities that are at risk.

“At this stage there is no action, project or contract that will not be honoured or financed” says Daman. A Commission statement added: “New commitments will be suspended but the payments of monies already committed will be made as usual.”

Some 41 projects are reported to be affected, and one EU source said project funding worth about 395 million ECU, some 435 million dollars, was at risk. The Commission says it is still assessing the court ruling.

The legal problem “would not affect humanitarian or emergency aid for people hit by earthquakes or other natural catastrophes,” said Eila Nevalainen, spokeswoman for Erkki Liikanen, European Commissioner for budget and administration.

But an EU source said that new money for some programmes in developing countries, such as removal of land mines in Angola, would be suspended. Some EU sources cited by European media said that a number of projects supposed to stop social marginalisation, including minority communities and the elderly, may never be cleared under certain readings of the ruling.

However the Commission officially says many of the budgets brought into question will be unblocked once it is sure that they are not affected by the Court ruling. The ruling concluded that the Commission had, wrongly, allocated funds to the programmes without the approval of the EU’s ruling Council of Ministers.

Many NGOs are particularly angered by the Commission’s refusal to identify the projects that in doubt, or even to confirm the projects that will escape a long term freeze.

The Brussels-based European Anti-Poverty Network (EAPN) said the freeze by the Commission is “appalling and uncalled for since it goes much further than the strict respect of the Court judgment would require”.

Technically the Commission officials themselves may be personally liable for refunding improperly paid millions, but EAPN director Marie Francoise Wilkinson told IPS that the Commission was applying an overly strict interpretation of the court’s ruling.

“On its present interpretation, the Commission will find at the end of its review that the execution of many (budget) lines, in particular concerning cooperation with NGOs, the family, children, social exclusion, racism, has to stop as far as the 1998 budget is concerned, and that these lines will disappear altogether from the 1999 budget. This is clearly unacceptable.”

The Court of Justice ruling resulted from a case brought by the former Conservative government in the United Kingdom, which objected to a number of projects set up to tackle social problems and social exclusion, particularly the work of NGOs in rehabilitating women forced into prostitution in Spain and Germany. The test case was backed by Germany and Denmark.

Yet the range of projects affected by the court ruling covers many more schemes, including many in the developing world.

“The responsibility for this deplorable situation rests with the Council and particularly with Britain, Germany and Denmark, who brought this lawsuit,” the Italian member of parliament and Socialist group spokesman told the London daily Guardian this week.

According to the daily, the process of making the payments ‘legal’ again would be highly complex. The Commission must first draft a regulation and a budget provision, which then goes to the ruling Council for its agreed ‘common position’ on the proposal.

This goes to the European parliament for its views, where after it is amended, if necessary, by the Commission and resubmitted to the Council. Then it is published in the EU’s official gazettes. If all the stops are pulled out, says the Guardian, this process can take six weeks — though it can take years.

Before the current crisis broke, the Commission had already announced plans to cut roughly 110 million dollars in its development cooperation funding in 1999 — despite its intention to raise its budget overall by more than six percent on this years’ figure.

The 1999 draft budget was released on May 12, beginning a long process of revision and approval by the various EU institutions and member states, needed before its final adoption.

The Commission wants to more than double the 1998 budget increase and plans a hike in the overall budget of 6.47 percent for 1999.

Yet at the same time, says the NGDOs Liaison Committee, a network of 900 European development NGOs, budgets intended for sectoral actions in the field of development and support for democracy and human rights in developing countries could be slashed by 22.3 percent.

Overall, budgets for development cooperation in the world’s poorest countries face a 4.4 percent cut under the proposed budget. These cuts would affect NGO projects and programmes, decentralised cooperation, rehabilitation and reconstruction, family planing and reproductive health, the environment and human rights.

 
Republish | | Print |

Related Tags