Europe, Headlines

DISARMAMENT: Plugging The Gaps In New EU Code For Arms Exporters

Niccolo Sarno and Dipankar De Sarkar

BRUSSELS/LONDON, Jun 1 1998 (IPS) - The fight goes on for NGOs pressing for tighter controls on the arms trade. They are urging the European Union to plug the “worrying shortfalls” in its new Code of Conduct for weapons sales and exports.

Organisations campaigning for a more ethical arms export policy say the voluntary Code remains far from the kind of transparent and effective system that members of the NGO community had asked for.

“This is the beginning, not the end, of a process and the key now is that it is implemented rigorously and continually developed and strengthened,” said Paul Eavis, Director of the London-based NGO Saferworld.

The EU announced the new Code on May 25. The NGOs object to its failure to allow parliamentary scrutiny of arms deals, the lack of a clear definition of what constitutes human rights abuse, its lack of a means to control arms brokers, and the fact that s o much of its consultations will be reached privately and its conclusions remain secret.

EU countries have agreed to compile an annual report on defense exports and on the Code’s implementation, but not to make it public, or release it through their parliaments.

“They are not going to publish an annual report of who has been selling what to whom, and that is really a shame, because that was really the first thing we wanted to see,” said Geraldine O’Callaghan of the British-American Security Information Council (BASIC.) “If this is not the beginning of a process, then it’s bad news.”

“I think one of the areas that needs immediately to be strengthened is the area of transparency,” Saferworld’s Andrew McLean told IPS in Brussels. “In a democratic Europe it should be the right of parliamentarians to know to which countries their gove rnments are selling arms.”

Another perceived problem is that the Code is not legally binding, so member states could theoretically sidestep it, although diplomatic pressure might stop them from doing so. And there is a large degree of flexibility allowed in the interpretation of t he guidelines.

The new Code says the 15 EU member states will not issue arms export licences if the export breaches international sanctions or treaties, such as last year’s Ottawa treaty to ban landmines. The Code also says licences will not be issued if the exports ma y be used for internal repression by the importers, or if they may provoke or prolong armed conflicts.

Past efforts to impose moral order on the arms trade have not been successful. The EU introduced eight non-binding criteria governing arms export in 1991, but according to the Brussels-based umbrella organisation Eurostep, a network of European developme nt NGOs, “they have had virtually no impact on arms exports policies from within the EU”.

Eurostep says the EU is currently responsible for 30 to 40 percent of the trade in conventional weapons to the developing world. “Many EU companies and individuals, either directly or through brokering and licensed production agreements, have supplied a rms to many of the world’s most unstable countries,” the group said in a statement.

Many, as listed by the NGO Human Rights Watch, are guilty of human rights abuses as well, among them the governments of Angola, Burundi, Colombia, Indonesia, Israel, Rwanda, Sudan, Turkey and DR Congo. Rebels in DR Congo, Angola, Burundi, Rwanda, Sri Lan ka, Sudan, and Turkey, also took deliveries from EU firms.

“The principal suppliers were the United States the Russian Federation, Britain, France and China — not coincidentally the five permanent members of the U.N. Security Council — but also regional powers like Brazil, Egypt, Iran, Israel and South Africa ,” says the NGO.

O’Callaghan thinks it is important for NGOs and the media to help monitor the implementation of the Code. “Will it stop Britain from selling arms to Indonesia or Turkey?” she asks. “We will be monitoring and looking at country behaviour.”

Human Rights Watch estimates the world arms trade to be worth around 31.8 billion dollars. The U.S. share was 35 percent (11.3 billion dollars) followed by the United Kingdom at 15 percent (4.8 billion dollars) and the Russian Federation 14 percent. Almo st two thirds of these agreements, 19.4 billion dollars worth, were sales to the developing world.

This multi-billion dollar industry is of increasing value to the EU. The Code itself stresses that the EU countries “wish to maintain a defense industry as part of their industrial base as well as their defense effort”.

“The European defence base is shrinking because there are too many manufacturers producing too many of the same things,” said researcher Steve Shropshire at Saferworld in London. The EU industry is gearing up for a series of mega-mergers to give them t he power to seriously challenge the big U.S. arms manufacturers.

“The defence industry has been calling for a common export policy because it makes exports difficult. For instance, there are many areas of the world where the Swedish government does not do business where Britain does, and vice versa.”

British Aerospace and Sweden’s Saab jointly manufacture the Grippen JAS39 fighter aircraft — the Swedes build the airframe, the British company manufactures the tail and wings. But a Swedish decision to allow the Grippen to be sold to Chile reportedly u pset the British, while Britain could sell them to Indonesia, which is under a trade Swedish embargo.

British Aerospace is the top European arms manufacturer in revenue terms, having earned 6.4 billion dollars in 1996. Thomson of France comes second with 4.68 billion dollars, followed by GEC of Britain (4.12 billion), Le Gardere of France (3.29 billion) and DASA of Germany (3.25 billion).

But even the total earnings of these five European giants were still less than the U.S. market leader, Lockheed Martin, which had revenues of 25.09 billion dollars in 1996.

 
Republish | | Print |

Related Tags