Thursday, November 19, 2026
Deborah Horan
- Yoyoda and Tamar Nizri are staying put. For this young Israeli couple, the wild deer and unspoiled landscape surrounding this isolated West Bank settlement is enough to persuade them to stay.
They don’t think about the fact that their settlement 15 miles north of Ramallah is likely to become a tiny enclave in a sea of Palestinian-controlled land if Israel carries out the long-awaited troop withdrawal that U.S. mediators have been asking for.
In fact, instead of abandoning Ofra’s manicured gardens and red- roofed houses for the relative safety of Israel proper, last month, they moved in even deeper — to one of six caravans perched at the end of a winding dirt road a half mile away from Ofra.
“We live here now and we don’t think about what will be if…” said Tamar Nizri, a 19-year-old newlywed with freckles and blonde hair wrapped in a tie-dyed scarf. “Maybe if we think about it we will be afraid. But we don’t think about it,” said Nizri, who teaches Jewish studies to children from secular Israeli communities in Jerusalem.
Her sentiments echo those of many of the 161,000 settlers sprinkled throughout the West Bank. Shocked by the prospect of living as Israeli satellites in what will likely become Palestine in any final peace deal, many settlers prefer not to dwell too much on an uncertain future.
Instead, they take each day at a time and hope that their government will find a way to keep all of the 144 West Bank settlements under Israeli sovereignty.
“It’s a cloudy situation,” said Nizri’s husband Yoyoda, 22. “We ignore it. Because if you think about it, then you can’t live in a way that plans for the future, you can’t have peace of mind.”
But as U.S. pressure to cede additional territory to Yasser Arafat’s Palestinian Authority grows, the settlers’ ambiguous situation gets harder to ignore. For months, Secretary of State Madeleine Albright has been pushing Israel to withdraw from an additional 13 percent of the West Bank. Israeli Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu has held firm with an offer of nine percent, citing security reasons.
The implication is that the margin of four percent gravely endangers Israel’s security. On Thursday, Netanyahu said he was ‘close’ to an reaching an agreement, but refused to go into detail. But the fact remains that few people here know exactly how.
Netanyahu has guarded his negotiating positions so closely that members of his own cabinet complain that no one has seen prospective maps except the four members of the inner ‘kitchen’ cabinet.
U.S. mediators have not drawn up maps to avoid seeming to be deciding Israel’s security, which they have said only Israel can decide. The 13 percent figure was chosen so that Palestinians, who now fully or partially control 27 percent of the West Bank, would hold an even 40 percent when negotiations on a final peace deal begin.
That means settlers have had to guess for themselves what the various percentages will mean for them. In 1996, they asked Hebrew University hydrologist Haim Gvirtzman to draw up maps in secret that could be used to determine how much land could be ceded to Palestinians while keeping all settlements in place.
Gvirtzman, a religious settler from the West Bank settlement of Dolev, determined Israel would be able to withdraw from only 30 percent — about the amount they have already turned over to Palestinian control.
Anything more would affect at least some settlements, Gvirtzman determined in maps published by the Begin-Sadat Centre for Strategic Studies at Bar-Ilan University.
According to these maps, a nine percent withdrawal would affect about 1,700 settlers living in 10 settlements. If the percentage jumps to 13, about 9,000 settlers in 18 settlements would be affected — including Ofra, home to the Nizris, which would be totally isolated.
Settler leaders are slightly more vague, partly because they want to keep the focus on Israel’s security rather than on the more political argument over the viability of settlements that Palestinians and left-wing Israelis view as the main ‘obstacle’ to peace.
Yehudit Tayar, spokeswoman for an umbrella settler organisation called Yesha, will say only that ‘about 20 communities’ would be affected if Israel met the U.S. halfway with an eleven percent withdrawal.
“It’s hard to find a community that’s not going to be affected one way or the other — it could be water, it could be electricity, it could be access roads,” Tayar said. “But eleven percent would isolate certain settlements… where you would have one access road surrounded by Palestinians.”
Amid these concerns, Ariel Sharon, Israel’s formidable security hawk and minister of national infrastructure, has focused on purely military issues in frequent tour of the West Bank. He follows the Israeli consensus with the view that Israel must retain the Jordan Valley, the Judea Desert and a wide corridor to Jerusalem.
But in his view, Israel must also retain the mountain of western Samaria, under which a major water aquifer lies, hilltops near Nablus, where early warning stations are located, and a radius around Ben Gurion Airport east of Tel Aviv that would cut into part of the West Bank.
While Sharon’s concerns are aimed at Israelis, they have the potential to affect tens of thousands of Palestinians who live in these areas.
Netanyahu claims that 98 percent of the Palestinian population is under Palestinian rule. But that figure is misleading, says Gvirtzman. That 98 percent is under the Palestinian Authority’s civilian control — meaning Palestinian Authority (PA) officials collect taxes and run schools there — but only 37 percent live in areas under full PA jurisdiction.
For them, the difference is crucial. Israeli soldiers cannot enter areas under full PA control. But they still patrol the areas under PA civilian control — and can still set up roadblocks, make arrests and clamp curfews.
Yet for the Nizris, Sharon’s concerns may make little difference. Surrounded by more Palestinian villages than Israeli settlements, Ofra stands a chance to survive any further withdrawal only if Israel builds a by-pass road connecting it to the Jordan Valley to the east.
If that happens, the Nizris might move north to the Galilee region or south to the Negev Desert. Or they may stay near Ofra in their tiny caravan with bean bags on the floor and wooden Indian carvings on the wall.
“I believe that this land is ours,” said Yoyoda Nizri. “And I believe we should live here. But I didn’t come here for those reasons. Anywhere we live in Israel will strengthen our country and I don’t see a difference between here and anywhere else.”