Monday, November 16, 2026
Nadire Mater
- Ragip Duran became the latest Turkish journalist to end up in jail this week. He began a ten month sentence refusing to accept the verdict of a military court that ruled that his reporting encouraged ‘terrorism and separatism’.
“I do not believe I am guilty, for one cannot commit a crime by expressing his or her thoughts,” Duran told colleagues before he travelled to Saray district prison in south west Turkey to start his jail term. There are 95 journalists now held in Turkish jails.
Some 100 people gathered outside the Turkish Journalists’ Association on Tuesday to bid farewell to Duran, Istanbul reporter for French daily Liberation and a columnist for the pro-Kurdish daily Ulkede Gundem.
“This is injustice, but it cannot last long. Citizens daily become more aware of the negative effects that the lack of freedom of expression has on their own lives.” Several of his colleagues held banners with the words ‘Duran In, Shooters Out’, a reference to the recent release of senior security officials charged with scores of killings in a dirty war against Kurdish dissidents.
Some 30,000 people have died in the fighting around the country’s south eastern provinces, where the guerrillas of the Kurdish Workers’ Party (PKK) have been locked in conflict with Turkish forces since 1984. An estimated three million have been forced out, including many cleared from 3,000 remote villages destroyed by troops in an attempt to deprive the insurgents of local support.
Nail Gureli, Turkish Journalists Association chair, says Turkey’s legislators should lift all restrictive articles in the Turkish Penal Code. “Ragip Duran’s arrest once again tarnishes Turkey’s image. The Turkish people does not deserve this wretchedness.”
The Istanbul State Security Court found Duran guilty of violating Article 7 of the anti-terror law, “by propagating the terrorist organisation and expressing opinions against indivisible unity of the country.” The offence was drawn from an April 1994 article based on his impressions of Kurdish guerrilla leader Abdullah Ocalan, whom he had interviewed the same year.
Duran notes that a 1993 feature on Ocalan that compared the PKK leader to turn of the century Mexican rebel leader Emiliano Zapata, without prosecution. But that article was for the Istanbul mainstream daily Cumhuriyet.
“But one year later, I compared him (in another article) to Italian republican hero Giuseppe Garibaldi (leader of the 1860 war of Italian liberation) in the pro-Kurdish daily Ozgur Gundem, alas, this seemed to have been too much for the authorities: Zapata was a loser, Garibaldi a winner. I paid the price.”
In a letter to Turkish prime minister Mesut Yilmaz, the U. S. based Committee to Protect Journalists (CPJ) described to protested Duran’s imprisonment as “a flagrant violation of the most basic right of journalists — the right to seek receive and impart information and ideas through any media regardless of frontiers.”
The CPJ calls on Yilmaz “to examine all possible legal options to rescind the court ruling against Duran in accordance with internationally recognized norms for press freedom.”
“One of Turkey’s finest journalists is being sent to jail as punishment for his thoroughly professional reporting on one of Turkey’s biggest stories,” says CPJ’s executive director, William A. Orme Jr. The CPJ has also released an English translation of Duran’s condemned article to back up their case.
“Duran’s case exposes the very limits of freedom of expression in Turkey,” Robert Menard, head of the Paris-based Reporters Without Frontiers (RSF) media rights group told IPS. The case is now going to the European Court of Human Rights.
Duran will join fellow ‘criminal of conscience’ Saruhan Oluc in Saray district prison. The deputy chair of the left-wing Freedom and Solidarity Party, Oluc was jailed last week for a 1994 article critical of the army’s hardline policies against the Kurds.
Oluc’s case is unusual in that he is the first prisoner of conscience to be sentenced by a military court. Oluc was sentenced to three months in jail for violations of Article 155 of the Penal Code, which prohibit the provoking of “anti-military sentiments among public,” in a 1995 article in his Socialist Worker magazine.
“Freedom of expression does not exist in Turkey” Oluc told IPS. “You are completely deprived of the right to criticise the army and its functioning, yet you are free to exalt it. And the worst is that any civilian, without military responsibilities, may at any moment face prosecution by the military.”
The third case on rights activists’ lips is that of Esber Yagmurdereli, the blind lawyer and peace activist jailed in October 1997 but later released for health reasons. Last month he was returned to prison on a technicality — that according to Ankara police he had “failed to display a report validating his release on health grounds”. He says he never received it.
Yagmurdereli is presently serving a 10 months term, but is likely to stay in jail, as the new offence breaches the terms of his release in 1991, when he was 13 years into a 36 year sentence. Since he has “repeated a similar crime” under Turkish law his parole is rescinded and he now has to serve another 23 years.
Ironically Turkey’s record had improved a little in 1998. The number of jailed authors and writers in Turkey has actually fallen since the passing of temporary legislation to release jailed journalist Isik Yurtcu. Another 18 editors were released with him and scores of new cases have been dropped.
Current prisoners of conscience include writer Haluk Gerger, Kurdish parliamentarians Leyla Zana and Hatip Dicle and sociologist Ismail Besikci. Besikci, 53, doyen of Turkey’s prisoners of conscience, is currently serving his 15th year in prison for his views on the Kurdish separatist question.
His latest stint began in 1991. Already condemned to a total of 100 years in jail, Besikci currently faces more charges, bearing sentences of up to 104 years more imprisonment.
“There is one common aspect in all of the recent jailings,” says Bulent Forta, a columnist with the bi-weekly Istanbul magazine V-Ozgurluk. “The jailed are known for their determined stand for a peaceful and political solution to the Kurdish conflict.
Forta notes the mainstream media’s cool stand towards the ‘elimination’ of dissidents and the ‘accelerated transfer’ of Turkish intellectuals and journalists from their desks to prison beds. She cites the current “authoritarian restructuring of Turkish political and juridical system under the pressure of the military”.
“The military, through indirect pressure on the judiciary and through imprisonment of the dissidents, sends fresh signals that the Kurdish issue will be handled in silence and behind closed doors, not through public debate.
“Recall the first time Yagmurdereli was jailed. The media poured all sorts of denouncements on the then Islamist-led coalition. However (jailed again), Yagmurdereli is the same man, but the reaction is totally different. The media has got its signal.”