Thursday, November 19, 2026
Analysis Kalinga Seneviratne
- Symptoms of infection were becoming already apparent a few months ago, but now it’s finally official: Vietnam has caught the Asian financial flu.
From the economic indicators released recently, the prognosis is not good. For the first time since the financial virus began spreading across East Asia, officials here are admitting Vietnam is not immune from it, and that the country’s 1998 GDP growth target of nine percent may be unattainable.
Even after one economy after another succumbed to the financial flu starting July 1997, Vietnam had thought itself safe. After all, since 1991, its version of socialist market reforms – called ‘doi moi’ – had brought breakneck economic development, a stable singe-digit inflation and booming export.
But the Indochinese country failed to take its trade dependence on its neighbours, which account for nearly 70 percent of Vietnam’s export earnings, into consideration. And as the fortunes of those nations fell, it was only a matter of time before the numbers on Vietnam’s ledgers would reflect such a change as well.
Vietnam’s export growth has shown a sharp decline so far. Although exports in the first half of 1998 increased by 13 percent over the same period last year, the rise was only half the usual growth rate of more than 25 percent.
Shoe and textile exports – which account for 21 percent of Vietnam’s export earnings – were hardest hit. Shoe exports were up just 10.2 percent compared to 63 percent last year and textile and garments exports up 7.1 percent compared with 39 percent.
Deputy Industry Minister Nguyen Xuan Chaun said the Asian economic crisis had made an “enormous” impact on the Vietnamese manufacturing sector.
He announced a 190 million-dollar modernisation plan for the manufacturing sector that was aimed at addressing the alarming fall in Vietnam’s competitiveness.
Hanoi also plans to spend 60 million dollars upgrading garments factories and have already bought used equipment at bargain prices from South Korea.
Added to the export woes is an exodus of foreign investors. Nearly every South Korean and Thai bank executive has left and Singapore and Hong Kong developers have pulled out of projects.
Indications are that more foreign investors are now leaving Vietnam than coming in. From January to May, 295 foreign representative offices closed down while only 120 new offices opened, says the Vietnam News Service.
During the 1994-97 foreign investment boom years, between 400 to 500 foreign representative offices were opening up yearly.
Others argue, though, that Vietnam’ opening up had created a false sense of new-market opening euphoria. “The current ambivalence of sentiments does reflect a genuine sense of disappointment among a portion of foreign investors that Vietnam has not met their initial expectations,” observes Nick Freeman, Indochina head of ING Barings in Bangkok.
“And,” he says, “it is wholly valid to recognise that some foreign investors have become disenchanted with a market that, in their view, has failed to match its initial promise.”
Addressing the first mid-term review of the Consultative Group of donors in Hue last month, Premier Phan Van Khai pledged to quicken the process of ‘doi moi’ despite the regional crisis.
He acknowledged that economic growth rate has been only 6.8 percent in the first half and export growth was lower than expected, adding that all these negative factors have affected the nation’s macro-economic balance and would do so for years to come. But he said the figures “indicate great efforts”.
Still, Khai admitted that there are weaknesses in the banking and the financial sector and promised to give them priority.
Both the World Bank and the International Monetary Fund have called on Hanoi to close down unviable financial institutions or merge them with bigger banks. The World Bank said bad loans and mounting debts have eaten up almost all available capital to the four state-owned banks. Vietnam has about 53 commercial banks.
“The IMF has taken the view that a comprehensive package of market-oriented reforms is urgently necessary in Vietnam,” says IMF resident representative Erik Offerdal. “Such a package would include tax reforms, trade liberalisation, state-owned-enterprise reforms, financial sector reforms and prudent fiscal and monetary policy.”
With investments from Asia drying up, export markets shrinking and unemployment rising, Hanoi is under heavy pressure to give more concessions to foreign investors, especially from the West.
Anthony Salzman, co-vice chairman of the American Chamber of Commerce in Vietnam, has said Vietnam “would need to embrace a willingness to make many large concessions of all sorts, and be genuinely happy to enjoy a smaller share of a bigger economy, which would be a vast improvement over the present situation”.
“In order to truly change, Vietnam’s leaders and bureaucrats would have to concede a tremendous degree of control, to domestic as well as outside influences, and they would have to allow foreigners to participate in major portions of their economy” wrote Salzman in the ‘Vietnam Business Journal’.
In his first news conference, however, Premier Khai said Vietnam rejected the shock therapy followed by other countries to open up their economies, because it would lead to mass unemployment, economic instability and social unrest.
Vietnam’s policy, said Khai, is to create favourable conditions for profit-making state-owned enterprises and provide loans to those facing difficulties in getting capital. He stressed that Vietnam will raise new resources by mobilising domestic capital and by greater efficiency.
Vietnam is also trying to tap the wealth of overseas Vietnamese, of which there are now around 2.5 million. Last year, they sent home at least 800 million dollars to families and friends, as well as invested 79 million dollars in 32 development projects, says the Vietnam Investment Review (VIR).
VIR estimates that if one to four percent of the overseas Vietnamese community invest in their homeland, there will be an inflow of 12.5 billion dollars to a massive 50 billion dollars.
The government is now moving to provide investment security to such investors. A bill has recently been submitted to the National Assembly to amend the State Revenue Law, the Foreign Investment Law and the Domestic Investment Promotion Law.
Meantime, one of Japan’s biggest corporations has begun to build a 54 million-dollar industrial park outside Hanoi.
“Vietnam still has good potential, that’s why we still went ahead with our project here,” said Sumitomo’s Vietnam general manager Yoshifumi Tsujio. “We think that the financial crisis will be over soon and that it is time to build the project and wait for the influx of foreign investors.”