Africa, Headlines

CULTURE: Codification Of Customs In Swaziland

Joyce Barrett

MBABANE, Nov 25 1998 (IPS) - Swaziland’s absolute monarchy is in the midst of reconciling centuries-old custom and tradition with modern practice, an undertaking women’s advocates fear could stunt progress women are making in advancing their rights.

The ambitious codification effort includes everything from citizenship rights to marriage and criminal law and is part of the kingdom’s look at whether to adopt a constitution and subsequently weaken the authority the monarchy wields in this land-locked country sandwiched between South Africa and Mozambique.

If government decides to pursue a constitutional monarchy, then portions of the customary law could be adopted as part of the constitution.

“As long as it’s not written down, we can manoeuver around it,” says Zakhe Hlanze, research associate with the advocacy group, Women and Law in Southern Africa about the reams of customary law applicable to women.

Maureen Magwaza, program officer for Women in Law and Development in Africa, also fears the codification effort. “Our customs have evolved with time,” Magwaza says. “Which aspects of the custom will be codified?”

Yet Fikile Dlamini, who is in charge of the codification effort at the Swaziland Ministry of Justice, defends the process and says it will eliminate the arbitrariness of Swaziland custom. “Customs aren’t changing,” she says, “but their practice is. If a custom is eventually included in Swaziland’s code of laws, we say the practice must be flexible. We have to find a way of saying we will accommodate all.”

Swaziland’s customs, as many elsewhere in southern Africa, are notorious for diminishing any rights women may claim, and the discriminatory treatment begins at a girl’s birth and persists throughout her life. Girls are viewed as temporary members of their families until their marriage. Then, once married, they become inferior members of their husband’s families. Husbands wield absolute power over their wives and must grant their permission from everything to whether a woman can work to whether she can acquire a passport.

“Marriage for a man is a happy occasion,” Hlanze says. “For a woman, she’s giving all of her rights away and will never represent herself again … I’ve wondered if I was ever a citizen of Swaziland because just men are given rights. All I have the right to do is pay taxes.”

Women’s inheritance rights are practically nonexistent and even their children can be taken away. When a husband dies, it’s his family who assumes control over the estate. Widows even can be dispossessed of their status as widows, a particularly dangerous event because then her male children could not inherit and she could be left destitute.

The mourning period for Swazi widows also is contentious. Custom requires that women mourn for a period that can extend to beyond two years. During that time, widows are forbidden from participating in a variety of everyday activities such as being forbidden from standing in the front of a line, speaking unless spoken to, and running for a bus. They may be prohibited from practicing their professions and must sit on the floor during the official mourning period. Men, on the other hand, are customarily required to mourn for a month.

Women are adapting the customs to fit their modern-day lives, Hlanze says. For instance, some are wearing their mourning dress to and from work, but take it off when in the workplace.

Dlamini also points to the customary mourning period and notes that women are changing it. “If a custom is written into law, we must say that it’s practice can be flexible,” she says. “Among Swazi women, the debate is centered on the mourning period, not on the custom of mourning. We must understand the practice vs. the custom and find consensus.”

Under the codification process that Dlamini has organised, week- long briefings are held each month with individuals identified by each chief as experts in customary law. The interviews are videotaped and recorded and then transcribed. Once the data on a particular custom and its origin is collected, it’s then taken back to each region of the country for verification.

Once the customs have been documented in this manner, they are then reviewed to see if any modernisation in practices is needed. This process will require a country-wide consensus, something that could be difficult to attain.

Laura Sasman, a research assistant with Women and Law in Southern Africa, fears it will be difficult for Swaziland to modernise its culture. “Swazi culture is a way to cement a country identity,” she says. “Swaziland is very small, and its neighbor, South Africa, is very large. Swazi culture is very entrenched and permeates everything. I see it as a way for Swaziland to establish its identity with South Africa and globally.”

“Swaziland is a very closed nation,” Hlanze says. “We want to make sure we lock ourselves in, and as a true born Swazi, we can’t challenge or criticize anything Swazi.” The process also is complicated because in Swaziland, the king can decree what is a cultural tradition.

With hundreds of people participating in the process and with an all-encompassing agenda, the resulting document will comprise thousands of pages, Dlamini says. The custom codification has been divided into the following categories: the law of persons, which pertains to individual rights; the system of government, which addresses citizenship, sovereignty, the monarchy, traditional leaders, chiefdoms, and property rights; marriage; guardianship; succession or inheritance customs; the law of contract; and the law of torts and criminal laws.

The entire process is to be finished within a year. The United Nations Development Program has contributed 500,000 US Dollars toward the two-year codification effort, and the Swaziland government has contributed a matching amount. A UN spokesman says that the project is viewed as critical because 70 percent of Swazis, out of a population of about one million, live in rural areas and in practice are governed by the traditional system.

“There are two parallel systems of government in Swaziland and they are never integrated,” the UN official says. “There is the system of chiefs throughout the country and the official government, which consists of the cabinet, parliament and the king. We can’t neglect the traditional system when we’re dealing with government reform,” he says.

The UN official dismisses the fears of the women’s advocacy groups. “Some practices may be based on ignorance and we may find they have no relevance to modern day,” he says.

“This is the process of harmonising Western and customary law,” he says. “This is a fair exercise for both men and women as long as harmonisation is followed.”

Dlamini agreed and said that the codification was valuable because many Swazis are losing their customary traditions and don’t know their origins. “This will be the first time that all aspects of customary law are written down,” she says. “Many books about Swaziland have been written by Whites, but they don’t have the insights we do and have often distorted things. This provides Swaziland with an opportunity to challenge the distortions.”

Swaziland is not the first African country to codify its custom. Lesotho, Botswana and Kenya have codified their customs to varying degrees of success.

But Hlanze is skeptical that codifying Swazi custom will bring any benefits to its women. “It’s very difficult to advocate any change in Swaziland,” she says. “Here, the king is the custodian of everything, and when something is challenged, Swazis believe you are challenging the king, which is forbidden. When a Swazi says that something is tradition, that means it’s sacred.”

 
Republish | | Print |

Related Tags