Thursday, November 19, 2026
Siva Selvam
- Even as Malaysia battles economic woes and political discord, a long-simmering religious conflict in this multi-cultural country appears to be coming to a boil.
The hostility, among the Muslims who dominate the multi-racial and multi-religious 20 million population, has become enmeshed in the political struggle between Prime Minister Mahathir Mohamad and his former deputy Anwar Ibrahim, now jailed and facing trial on corruption and sodomy charges.
Mahathir dramatised the depth of this crisis this week when he told reporters: “My pictures are shown to children and stressed to them that this person ought to be beheaded.”
The core of the conflict lies in differing concepts of how, and to what extent, Islam is to be inculcated in the everyday life of the nation.
A growing but still small group of Muslims is unhappy with Mahathir’s handling of Islamic affairs, alleging that he is only paying lip service to the religion while pushing a purely materialistic programme for this South-east Asian country.
For his part, Mahathir has openly expressed exasperation with the majority of Muslim scholars, prayer leaders and pulpit speakers.
He has admonished them for keeping the religion backward and talking only of the hereafter when the focus should be on bringing Islam into the modern world and using its values to promote such activities as science and technology.
Mahathir’s constant call has been to reduce the conspicuous gap between faith and day-to-day realities. His cosmopolitan approach is often identified as a factor that contributed to Malaysia’s economic progress in the last decade.
But for the past couple of years a quiet campaign has been waged against Mahathir, usually through Friday prayer sermons, religious talks at villages and community halls in the cities, and the publication of books and pamphlets.
Through these media, Mahathir is often directly criticised for his stance on Islam.
Mahathir has retaliated by throwing the book at these critics. The Internal Security Act (ISA), which allows for indefinite detention outside judicial purview, has been used to isolate many anti-Mahathir Muslim leaders.
Mahathir aroused much wrath when he had the religious chief of Selangor state — beside the capital Kuala Lumpur and a hotbed of “anti-official” Islamic activities — replaced by a school headmaster because of actions and “fatwah” or religious rulings that did not go down well with the government.
Anwar, on the other hand, had forged close links with religious groups since his university days and had formed the Malaysian Islamic Youth Movement (ABIM) upon graduation.
He had also qualified to give sermons at mosques, something that Mahathir has never done. This is now held against him in allegations that he has not learnt enough of the religion to talk about it.
When he sacked Anwar him from the dominant party in the ruling coalition in September, after accusing him of sodomy and adultery, Mahathir charged that Anwar “had for years been masquerading as a religious person and yet had been committing these things, not today, not yesterday but for years”.
“A man like that who appears to be religious, but in fact is not religious at all, is quite capable of swearing in a mosque, knowing full well that what he was swearing was not the absolute truth,” Mahathir said, referring to Anwar’s oath in a mosque that he is innocent of Mahathir’s charges.
Many religious groups and leaders have openly or covertly expressed sympathy and support for Anwar, and reject Mahathir’s allegations about Anwar’s conduct.
Four Islamic groups, including the Malaysian Academy of Islamic Science (ASASI), formed a “reformation movement” to arouse public awareness of the “injustices” done to Anwar, after he had sought reforms in the way the Mahathir government has run the country.
“The people should realise that the use of slander as a political weapon to bring down leaders is against Islam and humanity,” ABIM president Ahmad Azam Abdul said. He appealed to the government to give some “breathing space” for dissenting views.
Mahathir supporters have not been any less vocal in defense of the prime minister who has led Malaysia since 1981.
Religious leaders in the ruling United Malays National Organisation (UMNO) said the Mahathir was on strong ground when he removed Anwar from the government and the party for moral misconduct.
They said removing a leader with poor moral character was demanded by Islam’s teachings, more so in the case of a leader who professed to be religious and spoke often of morality.
Still, it is an uphill battle to overcome Anwar’s image as a progressive and moderate Muslim, intellectual and well-read, pro- poor and pro-environment, comfortable whether at a poetry-reading session or international economic forums and willing to listen to alternative groups and views.
His promotion of a moral, transparent and accountable society also won him admirers both at home and abroad.
The Mahathir-Anwar tussle has highlighted the growing schism among the Muslims in Malaysia.
Analysts note that the country’s close neighbour is Indonesia, home to the world’s largest Muslim population (180 million out of 200 million people) and now embroiled in violent clashes on the economic, political, religious and social fronts. Two million Indonesians, mostly Muslims, work in Malaysia, 75 percent of them illegally.
Mahathir said Muslim extremists are misusing mosques to split Muslims and stressed that they must be isolated “at all costs”.
He alleged that having deviated from the teachings of Islam, these groups hope divisions among Muslims would cause chaos. Mahathir also accused them of using Internet bulletin boards to discredit Islam and pit Muslims against non-Muslims.
The Cabinet minister in charge of Islamic affairs, Abdul Hamid Othman, says nearly 120 such groups have been identified in the country and 40 of them were involved in deviationist teaching.
Such activities are concentrated in Selangor due to various factors, including the presence of many foreigners, he added. “Followers of these groups were given counseling and they usually repent,” he claimed.