Asia-Pacific, Headlines

RELIGION-THAILAND: Buddhist Miracles for Sale

Satya Sivaraman

BANGKOK, Dec 22 1998 (IPS) - It is a Thai sect that seeks to put up the equivalent of Mecca or the Vatican for the world’s Buddhists, but its critics say the Dhammakaya group is creating a “spiritual casino” more than anything else.

Since 1989, the group has been dead set on putting up a centre here in Thailand for Buddhists all over the world. But its methods of achieving that goal have been questioned by devout Buddhists here and other Thai observers.

For one, it raised funds from its followers by promising religious merit in return for money. For another, the sect’s acquisition of land measuring more than 400 hectares led to the forcible ejection of farmers.

The Dhammakaya sect has also attracted criticism for its penchant for exchanging “holy merchandise”, religious merit and promises of prosperity for hard cash.

However, the group is facing even more scrutiny from media and the government after launching a controversial plan to raise more than 300 million dollars from its estimated half a million followers for the construction of a platinum pagoda that will be the attraction of its sprawling complex.

Last month, the Ministry of Education, which oversees Thailand’s Buddhist monasteries, voiced concern that the sect was using “improper methods” to solicit donations.

The Sangha Supreme Council, the highest Buddhist authority, has appointed a senior monk to review Dhammakaya’s activities.

About 95 percent of Thailand’s more than 60 million people are Theravada Buddhists. The Dhammakaya sect’s history goes back to 1969 when a small group of devout Theravada Buddhists began a meditation centre 50 km outside Bangkok. By the mid-1970s, the centre had become an officially recognised monastery.

As part of the fund-raising drive for the Maha Dhammakaya Chedi, sect devotees have been asked to contribute 800 dollars each in exchange for the installation of an icon representing them inside the pagoda. For 280 dollars, the icons will be installed at the pagoda’s base.

In recent weeks, Thai media have been flooded with tales of devotees giving up savings — during economic crisis — to the temple. The sect also sells amulets to help people do well in business by “sucking away money” from “people with low merit”.

The drive was preceded in September with claims of a “miracle” at the Dhammakaya temple site. According to a temple publication, tens of thousands of people who had gathered for a mass meditation are believed to have seen the sun disappear, replaced by a crystal ball.

The publication also says they claim to have seen an image of the late Luang Phor Wat Paknam, the monk whose meditation techniques the sect espouses.

The group’s latest scheme comes as no surprise. After all, the Dhammakaya Foundation’s aggressive business-like approach had won the group a 1988 award from the Business Management Association that extolled its “market planning strategies”.

The religious group is practically a business empire, with influential politicians — like former Thai Prime Minister Chavalit Yongchaiyudh — and businessmen said to be followers.

But many Thai intellectuals have just about had enough of the sect’s corporate approach to faith. Comments well-respected social critic Sulak Sivaraksa: “The Sangha Supreme Council will do Buddhism a service by having the Dhammakaya temple’s assets audited.”

He says the sect teaches its followers greed and promotes a consumerist, materialist culture — a far cry from basic Buddhist principles. Buddhist scholar Sathianpong Wannapruek says the temple’s teachings are dangerous because they contribute to the false belief that religious merit can be bought with money.

Many Thais apparently agree. In a poll conducted by Bangkok University, nearly 90 percent of 1,300 respondents rejected the sect’s method of soliciting donations by promoting “miracles”.

Some 88.5 percent also said the temple’s tactics of having worshippers “buy merit” was not right, while 87 percent said construction of the expensive Maha Dhammakaya Chedi was not the right way of propagating Buddhism.

Deputy Education Minister Arkom Engchuan has said the Sangha Supreme Council will soon rule on what constitutes a “proper” limit to solicitation, the promotion of religious objects and temple buildings.

But the Dhammakaya sect’s publications justify the commercial approach to religion by claiming devotees need simplistic ways of getting merit because they are not “spiritually strong”.

“People need something to have faith for morale and support,” argues one such publication. “Patients don’t like swallowing bitter pills even though they know the medicine is healing. But pills coated with sugar are easier to swallow.”

Dhammakaya follower Luenchay Vongvanij, scion of a prominent Thai business clan, adds: “There is a growing realisation throughout the Buddhist world of the need to adapt religious values to the modern world of high technology driven life.”

Indeed, some observers say the rise of modern, materialistic sects like the Dhammakaya is a response to the changing social and economic realities of Thailand, which in just a few decades has grown from a rural, agriculture-based society to one dominated by an urban, industrial culture.

The sudden shift in the pace of life, say observers, has produced material insecurity and spiritual confusion that traditional religious approaches have failed to address adequately.

Interestingly, another Buddhist religious sect whose popularity has run parallel to the Dhammakaya’s rise is the Santi Asoke sect, which preaches simple, austere living and a rejection of material wealth.

Observers say a failure by Buddhist authorities to crack down on the Dhammakaya sect’s “grand sale” of religious merit will confirm growing suspicions that the real problem lies as much with mainstream Buddhism as with the sect.

They note that both have in common the association of spiritual salvation with power and wealth — the very same things Buddha spurned all his life.

 
Republish | | Print |

Related Tags