Headlines, Latin America & the Caribbean

RIGHTS-JAMAICA: Religious Community Divided on Hanging Issue

Lloyd Nicholas

KINGSTON, Dec 3 1998 (IPS) - Religious leaders have begun to add their voices to the debate on hanging that is raging here but that move is also showing up sharp divisions in that community.

“My position is clear on this issue. I believe in hanging. If you destroy another’s life you must pay the highest price…it is only the highest price that is appropriate. I am not asking the state to premise its actions on an eye for an eye doctrine but there are extreme circumstances that require extreme actions by society,” says Oliver Daley a prominent Minister of Religion here.

“Human life is sacred (and) it belongs supremely to the God who creates it, values it, sustains it, and sacrificed Christ for its redemption. On account of this, the deliberate destruction of human life is unacceptable ” says Neville Callum, executive member of the Jamaica Council of Churches (JCC).

The JCC is an umbrella grouping for Catholics, Anglicans, Moravians, Methodists among other denominations.

Callum was quick to point out however that even within this body it is difficult to obtain consensus on the issue. “Our diverse positions on spiritual issues make it difficult for us to see eye to eye at all times,” he adds.

The issue of whether to hang or not to hang has been back on the agenda since January this year when the government withdrew from the Optional Protocol on the death penalty of the United Nations Convention on Human Rights.

The withdrawal took effect after the Geneva-based UN Committee on Human Rights ordered stays of execution for several prisoners on Death Row.

Last May the government of the southern Caribbean country of Trinidad and Tobago also withdrew from the Optional Protocol for similar reasons. Several other Caribbean states including The Bahamas, Belize, Dominica, Grenada, St. Kitts and Nevis and St. Lucia never became signatories to the Protocol.

Then just last week the Jamaican government served notice that it is considering pulling out from the Inter-American Commission on Human rights (IACHR) if that body fails to hold to the six-month deadline given to rule on cases brought before it.

The IACHR reviews murder cases after they have been tried by the Judicial Committee of the Privy Council in the United Kingdom.

If the government goes ahead and breaks with the IACHR it would clear the way for hanging to resume in accordance with the time limit set out in a 1994 ruling of the privy Council.

That ruling in the Pratt and Morgan case declared that to hold prisoners on Death Row for more than five years constitute cruel and inhumane punishment.

Earl Pratt and Ivan Morgan were two Jamaicans who had been on Death Row for some 14 years. The Privy Council commuted their sentences to life imprisonment.

The IACHR currently has six Jamaican death penalty cases before it on which it was supposed to rule in July but has now indicated that it may not make a decision before sometime next year.

That, says Prime Minister Percival Patterson is “unacceptable”. He added that the IACHR’s stance smacks of “a lack of respect for the vital interests of member states and places in jeopardy the hemispheric system of human rights petitions”.

Then there are those who argue that with a murder rate of 1,038 last year and 878 since the start of this year, hanging would act as a deterrent to the would-be murderers.

But Chairman and Managing Director of the Gleaner Company Ltd., Oliver Clarke argues that this is not necessarily the case and what the country needs is an effective police force along with a proper justice system.

Not so says Purcell Brown, Minister of Religion at the Church of God and Saints of Christ denomination, “the scriptures are clear and God approves revenge on evil doers…”

Richard Albert, a Roman Catholic Priest disagrees. “I cannot conceive of any situation in which the death penalty can be justified,” he says.

The last hanging took place here in 1988.

 
Republish | | Print |

Related Tags