Development & Aid, Headlines, Middle East & North Africa

DEVELOPMENT-MOROCCO: NGOs Band Together to Fight Corruption

Nizar Al-Ali

RABAT, Jan 28 1999 (IPS) - Abdelmajid Nawara tells his story with resignation: a Moroccan lawyer and a court official stole the money granted to him for a work accident eight years ago.

“My father had a work accident in 1990 and throughout the past eight years, his lawyer used to tell us that the court had not issued a ruling on his case yet. In the end, we learned that the court had ruled on the case in 1994,” he said.

Nawara’s case may seem shocking but it is not unusual. It tells much about corruption and bribes that spare almost no sector of activity in Morocco, an Islamic country whose prophet Muhammad says, “God’s wrath befalls he who gives bribe, he who accepts it and he who conveys it”.

“We cannot deny that there are honest people in justice. but the corrupted elements deal a great harm to the country’s judicial apparatus as a whole,” said Ali Farabi, an attorney at the Casablanca court of appeal.

Corruption in the Moroccan justice system has reached such an alarming extent that the government of socialist Prime Minister Abderrahmane Youssoufi vowed to place it on top of the sectors needing reforms.

“The reform of the vital sectors of justice and administration and the consolidation of the respect of ethics in public affairs top the agenda of the government,” Youssoufi said.

But the planned reforms do not seem to gain the trust of involved people like Moussa El-Wali, who has been working at the Casablanca courts for 28 years. “Court agents in charge of implementing rulings deliberately toughen administrative procedures for those who refuse to pay”.

Aicha Kinane, an intern lawyer, lashes out at the emergence of a group of renowned attorneys “who form a real mafia specialised in insurance and work accident cases”.

“These lawyers have agents in courts who help them in the hunt for victims. They conceal court rulings, give false dates for sessions and resort to all means to prevent people from attending the sessions concerning their cases, in order to skim the compensation,” she pointed out.

In a drive to foster public awareness of the dangers of corruption, Transparency Maroc, a Moroccan non-governmental organisation, drummed up support from 35 other civil society associations to get the authorities “to find a cure to this cancer that saps all development efforts in Morocco”.

But beyond pushing for greater awareness, the campaign is seen as insufficient on its own to stamp out entrenched corruption.

“We have been living with corruption for years. It has become a fait accompli for practically all components of the society”, said Mohammed Kharif, a Rabat-based sociologist.

Kharif cites a 1988 study of the United Nations Development Programme, which classifies Morocco 36th out of 52 countries where corruption and lack of transparency prevail.

Corruption, lack of transparency and excessive bureaucracy are always cited among the main obstacles hindering the flow of foreign investments into Morocco.

Mourad Sharabi, who owns a garments factory in Casablanca, concedes that Morocco’s bad reputation makes foreign investors shy away from conducting business in this North African country of 26 million people.

Government spokesman Khalid Alioua told the press last week that foreign investments in Morocco remain modest, with 500 million U.S. dollars in 1998 against 1.2 billion dollars in 1997.

“A foreign investor would never accept to waste his time trying to find a way out of the labyrinths of our bureaucracy and would not venture to sacrifice parts of his capital in bribes to have his dossier approved by corrupted executives,” Sharabi explained.

A Saudi businessman who requested anonymity added: “Morocco offers good investment opportunities. But some executives, especially in the investments and industrial administrations, push away foreign investors who fear to fall in the trap of deliberate administrative procrastination and bureaucracy.”

To mend the situation, experts call for toughening laws reprimanding executives found guilty of corruption.

“Amending the existing laws in such a way to make them tougher in dealing with guilty executives is one way of curbing the plague,” said Noureddine Shaoush, a teacher at the law school of Casablanca and member of Transparency Maroc.

Under a 1965 law, corruption and bribes-related cases, involving state executives, fall under the prerogatives of the Cour Speciale de Justice (Special Court of Justice).

The laws on corruption were amended in 1980, to make farud or bribe a crime only if the amount involved exceeds 2,500 U.S. dollars.

“Instead of reinvigorating the law, the amendment only contributes to encouraging corrupted executives in their misdeeds,” Shaoush complained.

Low salaries in the public sector are another factor cited among the reasons behind the propagation of bribes.

Youssef Tamri, a militant of the Islamist party ‘Al-Adala Wa Attanmya’ (Justice and Development) argues that bribes cannot be given or accepted under any pretext, because this practice is banned by Islam.

“People resorting to such illegal and irreligious practices are strongly condemned and reprimanded by God,” he stressed.

NGOs activists and economists agree that the Youssoufi government has to intensify the fight against corruption, if it is to put the country on track toward economic take off. This is what it promised in the declaration it made before Parliament when it came to power in March 1998 amid growing popular hopes for change.

“But this fight will be doomed to failure without an integrated economic and social strategy, favouring the citizen’s prosperity and dignity, the shield against pervert behaviour,” as Noureddine Shaoush put it.

 
Republish | | Print |

Related Tags