Thursday, November 19, 2026
Ranjit Dev Raj
- There seemed irony in the Indian government’s guarantee of safety for writer Salman Rushdie. Especially after a year of paralysis in stopping fundamentalist attacks on artists and Christian missionaries.
The ‘irony’ was not lost on Opposition groups in Parliament this week. They accused the Hindu right-wing Bharatiya Janata Party (BJP) heading an 18-party coalition government of trying to incite religious passions by allowing Rushdie to visit India.
Among those who demanded withdrawal of the recently granted visa to Rushdie in London were Mulayam Singh Yadav and Laloo Prasad Yadav, powerful regional bosses in the two northern states which have sizeable Muslim populations.
Said E. Ahmed, leader of the ultra-conservative Muslim League party in Parliament, “Rushdie has committed blasphemy and wounded the sentiments of the Muslims – the visa should be withdrawn.”
Ahmed and the two Yadavs were supported by Ajit Jogi speaking for the Congress party whose government originally banned Rushdie’s “Satanic Verses”, a month after its publication in September 1988.
India’s ban served as cue for similar proscription of the book in Sri Lanka and Pakistan and perhaps the famous death ‘fatwa’ on Rushdie ordered by Iran’s Ayatollah Khomeini in February 1989. It forced Rushdie into hiding in Britain, where he enjoys elaborate security cover.
Although Iran has lifted the ‘fatwa’ last year, its Foreign Minister Kamal Kharrazi told reporters here this week that he was “disappointed” that India has granted Rushdie an entry visa.
“India should concentrate on creating understanding between Muslims and non-Muslims – anything divisive should not be encouraged,” Kharrazi said, Wednesday, ending a two-day visit in the midst of controversy in Parliament over the visa.
The BJP decision to grant a visa to Rushdie is not surprising because it’s main political plank has been opposition to what its leader and present Home Minister Lal Krishna Advani has often described as the “Congress party’s policy of pseudo-secularism and appeasement of minorities.”
By granting the visa to Rushdie, the ruling may have executed a brilliant political manoeuvre because, it is in line with demands by artists and writers that the freedom of expression needs to be protected in India.
“We need to reinforce freedom of expression especially after the many incidents of the past year which have made artists extremely anxious,” said celebrated painter Anjoli Ela Menon.
On the face of it there is no reason why Rushdie should not be allowed to come to India, she said. “After all it was the Islamic world and not India which proclaimed a ‘fatwa’ on Rushdie – this is a great distinction.”
Menon said she was opposed to the “use of artists as pawns in a political game – but when Iran has lifted the ‘fatwa’ on Rushdie there is no need for India to act holier than thou.”
According to Menon, Rushdie has been punished enough by being made to stay cut off from the land of his birth and the source of his art. “I am delighted he is coming …”
Said Vivan Sundaram, another prominent painter, “Rushdie has paid the price. He has a deeply anguished relationship with India and cannot be exiled from his country (of birth).”
Sundaram, however, conceded that Rushdie should not have made “certain transgressions while dealing with Islam even if they were just four lines out of the millions he has written.”
Painter, Jatin Das said he did not want to say anything on the issue of a visa for Rushdie except that “India is a very volatile country.”
Last year, Das was manhandled by activists of the fundamentalist World Hindu Council, better known by its acronym VHP, when he tried to remonstrate them for trying to set aflame the Academy of Fine Arts and Literature, here.
The object of the VHP’s ire was a 20-year-old lithograph by India’s best known painter Maqbool Fida Husain depicting the rescue of the Hindu goddess Sita from captivity by the monkey god Hanuman. Sita is shown riding on Hanuman’s tail.
If Rushdie offended Muslim sensibilities in the ‘Satanic Verses’, he has not flattered the most prominent of Hindu fundamentalists and chief of the Shiv Sena, Bal Thackeray, by caricaturing him in a later work, ‘The Moor’s Last Sigh’.
Thackeray’s Shiv Sena (army of god) which rules western Maharashtra state in partnership with the BJP nearly sabotaged a recent India-Pakistan cricket test series played in this country, because of his hatred of Pakistan.
If Rushdie visits India it is difficult to see him including Thackeray’s city Mumbai or Bombay in the itinerary although his experience of growing up in the port city inspired a significant portion of the autobiographical, ‘Midnights Children’.
He may also not be able to visit the old quarter of Delhi where the hereditary Grand Imam of the Jama Masjid mosque built by the Mughal emperor Shah Jahan has upheld the ‘fatwa’.
The visit if it does come off may be confined to New Delhi, where Rushdie can share the awesome security apparatus normally used to protect politicians and to Shimla in the Himalayan foothills where he plans to convert his family home into a retreat for writers and artists.