Development & Aid, Environment, Headlines, North America, Population

ENVIRONMENT-CANADA: Govt Tries to Fob Off Nuclear Waste

Mark Bourrie

OTTAWA, Mar 10 1999 (IPS) - Canada’s Indian chiefs have blown the whistle on a quiet government attempt to persuade indigenous communities to store nuclear waste in isolated native reserves in the Subarctic region in exchange for money.

Government officials met Indian leaders four months ago to discuss burying nuclear waste on Native land after a government survey found that no other community in southern Canada would accept nuclear waste from Canada’s four nuclear power plants and a 50-year-old research reactor.

Assembly of First Nations chief Phil Fontaine now has revealed that the government tried to pay the chiefs to accept the waste. He said they were told not to talk about the meeting, and were told that the material was safe.

“The carrot here of course is money. People figure that First Nations would be an easier sell. It’s an insult,” Fontaine said.

About 1.3 million used fuel bundles – about 45,000 cubic feet of waste – are stored at Canada’s nuclear power plants. Unless treated, the waste would remain highly dangerous for thousands of years.

Fontaine said native Canadians would refuse to take the waste, and “there’s no amount of money that would be acceptable.”

The Canadian government already had spent 500 million dollars on consultations and studies of ways to get rid of the waste and the last federal study on the problem warned that authorities risked huge financial liabilities if they forced a community to accept the waste.

The survey showed the minimum cost of disposing of the nuclear waste would be 7 billion dollars over a period of 100 years.

Because of the costs involved, anti-nuclear activists believe the government has made up its mind to put the waste deep into the billion-year-old granite of the Canadian Shield, which lies under much of Canada’s near-north, and a research lab reportedly had been built in an isolated part of northern Manitoba, near Hudson Bay.

“The cabinet made its decision on bad advice,” said Brennain Lloyd of the Northern Ontario anti-nuclear group Northwatch.

The ministry of natural resources “is giving a clear message that they’re ready to unleash the nuclear industry in search of some community that can be lured into looking at proposals for a nuclear repository nearby,” Lloyd said.

“We want to give a clear message back that we are working with people throughout the Canadian Shield to put communities on alert that the nuclear salesmen may be on their doorstep.”

In parliament, opposition parties said the Canadian government should abandon the plan to bury the waste in the Canadian Shield. On Tuesday, Bill Blaikie, nuclear critic for the New Democratic Party, invited Natural Resources minister Ralph Goodale to promise that the waste would not be buried in the subarctic- an invitation that Goodale refused.

But he did pledge that “there will be no short-circuiting of consultation. There’s no fast-tracking of decisions.”

Rick Laliberte, a Metis (mixed blood) member of parliament from northern Saskatchewan, said he was concerned that the lure of money could cause an indigenous community to break ranks and accept the proposal to store nuclear waste in a native reserve.

“Most northern Canadian communities are economically deprived. To bring in an economic solution for their community, is a dangerous thing to be playing around with,” he said.

Advocates of northern waste disposal say the 7 billion dollars cost of getting rid of the material would be a huge influx of cash and jobs into an impoverished region of the country. But Fontaine says Native leaders are still opposed to the plan.

He said the chiefs who are members of his organization won’t even help “design a process” to pitch the idea to native communities.

 
Republish | | Print |

Related Tags