Thursday, November 19, 2026
Mark Bourrie
- Indigenous women in Canada, worried that increased self-government in native reserves also would increase discrimination, used International Women’s Day Monday to push demands for legislation that would protect their rights.
Representatives of the fledgling First Nations Accountability Coalition, made up mainly of Native women in five Canadian provinces, accused Canada’s federal government of turning a blind eye to increasing oppression and intimidation by chiefs and band councils on Native reserves.
Leaders of the group said their political and property rights are being ignored by traditional male power structures.
“We must have accountability, democracy, and equality and these three factors are non-existent,” said Leona Freed, president of the First Nations Accountability Coalition.
“Self-government is a noose for our people. It is self- destruction, not self-government,” she added.
Freed, from the Dakota Plains reserve in south-western Manitoba, appeared before the Canadian Senate aboriginal affairs committee last week to demand the federal government create a First Nations ombudsman’s office with independent power to audit and investigate allegations of mismanagement and discrimination on Canada’s Native reserves.
Freed said she had been pressured by the all-male band council of her reserve, who threatened to kick her out of the reserve and sue her for defamation after she wrote to the Canadian health minister to report that the reserve’s sewage system was polluting local wells.
Her group has the backing of the right-of-centre Reform party, the largest opposition bloc in Canada’s federal parliament. It has introduced private member’s legislation proposing an ombudsman’s office to protect women’s rights on reserves and provide financial accountability.
In the Canadian parliament, however, legislation introduced by opposition parties is rarely passed.
Mary Tobique, a Micmac women’s activist from New Brunswick, said Native women are often forced from reserves after divorces. They can’t collect their share of matrimonial assets because nearly all property on Native reserves is communal.
“It’s especially bad when women from a different First Nation or a different band moves to another reserve when she marries, then gets divorced. Everything is against her. She usually ends up with nothing.
“Women lose their life’s work, their kids, everything, because on many reserves, the power structure is all men,” she said.
“Our demand is for equality, honest and responsible government and it’s against the mismanagement of funds,” she added.
Indian Affairs Minister Jane Stewart tried to reassure Freed that Ottawa won’t impose self-government on bands that are not ready for the transition.
“The last thing I would want to do as minister of Indian Affairs is say that everybody will be self-governing by such and such a date,” Stewart said. “There is nothing in the work we are doing that says communities will be forced to become self-governing.”
Freed’s coalition said an independent watchdog was needed to oversee individual First Nations because residents “on a majority of reserves” have no way of challenging the authority of chiefs or fighting back when they see corruption.
Reserve residents were at the mercy of band chiefs and councils that received direct transfers from the federal government and control social assistance, on-reserve jobs, and other services, Freed said.
“We have self-appointed chiefs, silent chiefs, illiterate chiefs, bought-and-paid-for chiefs, band custom chiefs, hereditary custom chiefs, and above all, chiefs and families who make all the rules with no sensitivity to band members’ needs,” she said.
“If a band member opposes the chief and council, all services are cut off. They are chased off the reserve. . .There is abuse of authority and intimidation tactics of members by chief and council.”
Canada’s Department of Indian Affairs currently transfers about 3 billion dollars a year to the country’s reserves, a large portion of which goes toward social assistance.
Last month’s federal budget promised to put up an additional 220 million dollars, spread over the next three years, for housing, sewage, economic development, education, and treaty discussions.