Asia-Pacific, Economy & Trade, Global, Global Geopolitics, Headlines

ECONOMY: Asian Crisis Worse Than Foreseen

Thalif Deen

UNITED NATIONS, Apr 8 1999 (IPS) - The Asian financial crisis that devastated the economies of Thailand, Indonesia, South Korea and Malaysia was more widespread and deeper than originally foreseen, according to a UN report released Thursday.

The crisis in Asia – which began in mid-1997 in Thailand – has caused “dramatic and severe social problems with unemployment and poverty increasing rapidly in several countries,” Ambassador Asda Jayanama of Thailand told reporters here.

Jayanama pointed out that Asian countries were unfairly blamed as being primarily responsible for the economic turmoil in the region but “it takes two to do the tango.”

“The crisis couldn’t have happened by itself,” Jayanama said. “International banks were competing with each other to provide loans. They came begging to our countries, and said ‘please borrow our money’.”

Interest rates were as low as 7.0 percent compared with 14 percent by local banks. “The international banks were looking for good returns on their money. They knew that Southeast Asian nations would provide them with those returns,” he said.

But when the crisis hit the region, they “just pulled out all their monies from all the countries causing a contagion effect,” Jayanama added.

Launching the UN report, Jayanama said that seven out of 19 economies in mainland Asia had suffered negative growth rates in 1998, compared with none in 1996 and only one in 1997.

The economies that took a beating were: Indonesia, Malaysia, the Philippines, Thailand, Hong Kong, South Korea and Iran. Of the developed economies in the Asia-Pacific region, Japan suffered a negative growth rate of 2.7 percent last year while Australia and New Zealand had positive growth rates.

The report, published by the Bangkok-based UN Economic and Social Commission for Asia and the Pacific (ESCAP), said that for Southeast Asia, 1998 was perhaps one of the worst years on record.

There were large contractions in gross domestic product (GDP) in several countries, including Indonesia, Malaysia and Thailand, while GDP growth remained virtually flat in the Philippines and Singapore, two countries that were spared the devastation.

Poverty increased dramatically in Indonesia, from 11 to 40 percent, in Thailand from 11 to 15 percent and in Malaysia from under 7.0 percent to 8.0 percent.

At the same time, unemployment rose in Indonesia, from 4.7 percent in 1991 to 21 percent in 1998, from 2.7 to 6.4 percent in Malaysia, from 2.6 to 7.7 percent in South Korea and from 1.9 to 4.4 percent in Thailand.

“The governments’ ability to address social problems has been constrained by reduced revenues and in some cases by conditionalities of the bail out packages (from the International Monetary Fund),” the study said, adding that some of these conditions were recently relaxed.

As a result of the crisis South Korea sought an IMF bailout package of about 58 billion dollars, Indonesia about 43 billion dollars, Thailand about 17.2 billion dollars and the Philippines about 1.0 billion dollars.

Malaysia refused to accept any handouts because it did not want to subject itself to IMF conditions – such as lowering budget deficits and interest rates, removing state subsidies, and enforcing tighter discipline in the banking system.

The report, however, predicted a mild recovery in the region in the latter part of 1999 – provided there were no further shocks in financial markets, a decline in interest rates, stability in exchange rates and stock markets, improved current account positions, higher foreign exchange reserves and implementation of financial sector reforms.

The report pointed out that policies at the national, regional and international levels were needed to overcome problems created by the economic turmoil. “The prevailing credit crunch has to be overcome, the financial sector strengthened, and the corporate structure restructured.”

There also was a need for reforming the international financial architecture and intensifying regional cooperation, including consideration of a proposal for the establishment of an Asian Monetary Fund on the lines of the IMF, the report said.

The study called on governments to play a critical role ensuring social protection. With that end in view, budgetary allocations for the social sector had to be preserved and augmented.

Among other measures suggested were the establishment of a “social fund”; proper targeting of publicly provided goods and services; strengthening institutional capacity; unemployment insurance schemes and strengthening the rural and urban information sectors.

The study emphasised the expanding range of applications of information and communications technology (ICT) which was expected to help increase the efficiency and flexibility of production, marketing, financial and administrative activities for both the private and public sectors.

These applications offered “enormous opportunities to enhance the competitiveness of industry, increase the returns from trade, attract foreign direct investment and other forms of external capital,” the report said.

It ended with a warning that: “There is a very significant threat that countries which do not enter actively into the information age will be increasingly marginalised in the 21st century.”

 
Republish | | Print |

Related Tags