Asia-Pacific, Development & Aid, Headlines, Human Rights, Population

RIGHTS-SOUTH PACIFIC: CEDAW Comes Up Against Local Ways

Edmond Toka

PORT VILA, Vanuatu, Jul 22 1999 (IPS) - Twenty years since the Convention on the Elimination of All Forms of Discrimination Against Women (CEDAW) was signed, only four of the 12 independent states of the South Pacific have ratified it.

Of the four, Fiji, in central Pacific, ratified the convention with reservations.

The other three, the Melanesian states of Papua New Guinea and Vanuatu and Polynesian Samoa, are the only independent countries in the region to have ratified CEDAW in its entirety in 1995 and 1991.

A further three French territories and three self-governing countries with free association with New Zealand are party to CEDAW by way of France’s and New Zealand’s ratification in 1983 and 1984 respectively.

A total of 163 out of 185 member states of the United Nations have ratified CEDAW, and the UN is aiming for universal ratification by next year.

But across the Pacific and even in countries that have ratified the convention, women continue to battle threats to their rights, ranging from domestic violence to local laws and cultures that conflict with parts of the convention.

“The convention is just a means to an end,” said Emele Duituturanga, women’s development adviser to the Pacific Women’s Resource Bureau.

“Ratification is just the beginning. In itself, it will not achieve women’s rights overnight. It is clear then that implementation is a tougher challenge than ratification,” she added. “That’s a sobering thought, given how few governments have actually ratified the convention at this point.”

Fiji, which provided for an establishment of a Human Rights Commission in its new Constitution adopted last year, has reservations about modifying the social and cultural patterns of conduct of men and women and giving women equal rights with men to acquire, change or retain their nationality.

“We believe that it (Article 5(a) of the convention) impinges on our cultural values and social norms of behaviour,” a Fiji government official said.

Article 5 would come into conflict with local customs like that providing that men have the right to become a ‘ratu’ or chief.

As for men and women’s nationalities, Fiji’s 1990 Constitution treated men and women who marry foreigners differently, making it difficult to adopt the provisions of Article 9 of the Convention.

Under this Constitution, the foreign wife of a Fijian man is entitled to Fijian citizenship at marriage, but not for the foreign husband of a Fijian woman.

Although officials were optimistic about a possible review, the 1998 Constitution does not make specific mention on the rights of men and women who marry foreigners.

“It was felt that this is not something that a state should commit itself to doing but that changes should evolve from the society,” Fiji representatives told a reporting and monitoring workshop on CEDAW last year.

Legal experts note that in many countries in the region, custom and culture is part of the law and would be difficult to see how they would divert from these without questions.

“There might be some Pacific Island countries which are sensitive to the possibility of CEDAW violating their rights to religious freedom,” said Jane Connors, a UN official with CEDAW in New York.

“Conflict often can arise between religion or culture and women rights, she said. “It is important to keep all good cultural and religious practices, but try to eliminate those which prevent women enjoying their human rights.”

Analysts note other challenges to carrying out CEDAW’s provisions.

Many in the South Pacific do not readily understand the significance of ratifying what could also be called the “Bill of Rights for Women”. Likewise, 80 percent of them live in remote rural villages, where discussion of international and legal issues is distant.

Still, South Pacific governments do have progress to speak of in the years since the 1994 meeting of women leaders in Noumea, New Caledonia to adopt a Pacific platform for action for women. This was presented the next year at the Fourth World Conference on Women in Beijing, China.

Since 1995, governments in the region have created separate women’s ministries or bureaus and women’s departments and NGOs have actively worked on women’s issues.

One persistent problem, however, is violence against women.

In Cook Islands, a self-governing state in free association with New Zealand, police and other relevant government departments collated last year statistics on domestic violence cases that were reported and heard by the courts.

It is the only country in the South Pacific where domestic violence against women is a crime.

In other countries the crime is grouped together with common assault, making it difficult to put figures to the number of cases of wife-beating that occur in homes throughout the Pacific.

Despite this difficulty, social research, informal contact and anecdotal evidence suggest that in all Pacific countries wife beating is widespread but rarely reported to police.

In 1985, the National Council of Women supported its proposed family law bill by court records showing that from 1984 to 1991, a significant number of assault cases were of wife-beaters. The lowest percentage recorded was 11 in 1982. In other years, it reached more than 75 percent of cases of assault.

More recently, police records were used to compile more detailed statistics which showed that some 278 cases of crimes against women occurred on one island alone.

Of the 76 intentional assault cases on women prosecuted in the Magistrate’s Court in Vanuatu’s capital, Port Vila, 64 percent involved criminal assault by their partners. With a population of only 190,000 people, these figures are worrisome, observers say.

A February conference in Papua New Guinea had equally worrying figures. The Fiji Women’s Crisis Centre says one in four Vanuatu women are likely to be living in an abusive relationship.

Likewise, it said half of women in Western Samoa suffer from partner abuse, and the number of cases of violence against women in Fiji rose by 30 percent in the last five years.

 
Republish | | Print |

Related Tags