Tuesday, November 17, 2026
Analysis Farah Khan
- In the middle of South Africa’s strike season, the question to ask is how much longer President Thabo Mbeki’s government can continue to be all things to all people.
The ruling African National Congress (ANC) is a hybrid revolutionary movement, which brought together a range of interests and ideologies in the mission to end apartheid.
Business, trade unions, communists and those who believe in a free market combine in this powerful broad church. This movement girded its loins again earlier this year and worked to help the ANC romp home to a massive victory in the country’s second democratic election.
But this week, the newly democratic parliament in Cape Town was home to an anomalous sight. At its locked gates on Tuesday, two former revolutionaries-turned-ministers accepted a petition from thousands of angry and toyi-toying public servants.
The toyi-toyi is a military dance made famous by the ANC’s Umkhonto we Sizwe guerrillas. Many of the marchers were ANC supporters. At another protest in the capital Pretoria, one civil servant held up a placard saying, “We voted for you. Thanks for nothing.”
Both the Minister of the Public Service Geraldine Fraser- Moleketi and the Minister of Finance Trevor Manuel are young leaders who cut their teeth as underground guerrillas in the ANC.
After several years of declining strikes, worker protests are again on the ascendancy. While the public service strike was the largest, there has been action on the mines, in the clothing and textile industry as well as in the steel and engineering industry.
Both the young ministers are now at the forefront of the ANC government’s efforts to curb public spending. And, they are a symbol of the conundrum facing this party. It must deliver to its constituency of trade union members and those who have even less; and it must augment South Africa’s position as a leading emerging market economy.
South Africa and its Finance Minister are proud of the reputation it has earned in the markets for its sensible economics. But that reputation has come at a price. The adoption of a conservative economic model has caused a wedge with its union allies and it’s meant cuts in social spending.
The balancing act the government must perform is clear in the civil service pay fight. Presently, public servants are in dispute with the government which last week implemented a wage increase of between 6.3 percent and 7 percent mid-way through the wage negotiations.
Government claims that the wage bill, which amounts to 52 percent of the budget, eats into the cash available for the crucial development projects South Africa must undertake.
The budgets for the departments involved in human development have effectively been cut since the introduction of the growth employment and redistribution strategy (Gear) two years ago.
Organised labour, in turn, argues in turn that government’s cash crunch is self-imposed because of the strict fiscal deficit it has set itself. South Africa aims to achieve a 3-percent budget deficit by next year.
After this week’s public service strike where trade unions with a joint membership of about 800,000 members marched in centres around the country, government toned down its stance. Fraser-Moleketi said her door was still open to negotiation with workers and while more money will not be forthcoming, it does appear that government’s tone has softened.
“In the public service, you’re not dealing with company profits that must be redistributed,” said Fraser- Moleketi. Again and again, she has emphasised the toss-up between higher wages and basic social development like the provision of water, housing and healthcare.
Such prudence may have alienated the ANC government’s trade union allies and much of civil society, but the business community is full of praise for Mbeki’s presidency.
Under President Mbeki, the ANC will augment its position as a party of business. Its economic policy and support measures for commerce have won a nod of approval from the business sector. It has successfully won business over to its corner by adopting a centrist path.
“On balance, I could live with the statement that business fancies its chances under an ANC government led by Thabo Mbeki,” says economist Tony Twine of Econometrix, Johannesburg.
Its success at winning over the establishment, perhaps at even becoming the establishment, has been no mean political feat for the ANC. It was, at the beginning of the 1990s, still Public Enemy Number One for the espousal of socialism.
The ANC has walked a long distance since then to the market- based policies it embraces today. Its political challenge now is to fine-tune its economic policy to ensure it delivers to all facets of its broad alliance. And the jury’s still out on whether or how the party can achieve this.