Development & Aid, Headlines, Latin America & the Caribbean, Population

POPULATION-JAMAICA: More Land For the Poor?

Dionne Jackson Miller

MONTEGO BAY, Sep 16 1999 (IPS) - At 68, Clinton Graham is one of thousands of Jamaicans looking forward to owning a home of his own for the first time.

Graham says that with the help of his children, he will finally be able to build a house. I got a parcel of the land, and I’m (grateful) for it. (If not for PRIDE) I wouldn’t get a piece of land, because I can’t afford to buy, so this helped to push me a little further,” he says.

Graham is typical of many Jamaicans who have no money to buy either land or a house. One lot of residential land in some rural areas will sell for at least 12,500 dollars. In the capital Kingston, residential lots sell for in the region of 40,000 dollars. The construction of a small four-room can cost an additional 37,000 dollars.

So with per capita income of less than 2,000 dollars, many Jamaicans have either resigned themselves to never owning a home or to squatting on state-owned land, a phenomenon that the government has been trying to check.

It is estimated that the national housing stock needs an addition of 14,000 new units annually to meet the existing demand. Hence the development of several government initiatives, including one dubbed Operation PRIDE, which is allowing Jamaicans to buy government land at prices averaging 2,500 dollars per lot – well below market value.

Operation PRIDE has been on stream for the last five years as part of Prime Minister Percival Patterson’s declared intention to go down in history as the Prime Minister who distributed “the most land to the most people”.

“The entire country, should by now be well aware of my fixity of purpose in presiding over the most far reaching programme in providing access to land for the people,” he told the nation earlier this year in the annual budget debate.

Part of that programme is Operation PRIDE, which former coordinator Paul Buchanan says is about land reform. “It was really a land reform programme which would provide Crown lands to the people at affordable rates, so that they could create their own land development history and their own land development designs and administration, and management of the land that passed to them,” he says.

The government was intended to act as a facilitator only, and the communities were envisaged as leading their own development, as slowly as necessary, depending on their income level, and the pace at which residents could fund infrastructural development.

And for a while after its launch, PRIDE did seem to be moving fast toward its goal of facilitating increased access to land for the poor.

More than 100 sites islandwide were identified for development. International recognition followed, as two years ago, the United Nations Centre for Human Settlements cited PRIDE as a Best Practice model for achieving viable human settlement development.

But the programme ran into difficulty. The government first had to live down charges of corruption and political bias made by the Opposition Jamaica Labour Party, the National Democratic Movement and a former employee.

Official government investigations however, indicated sloppy administrative systems, but no fraud. After clearing that hurdle, implementation difficulties began to surface. The sheer magnitude of the work began to tell, and developments lagged.

Potential beneficiaries who were supposed to make their contributions to the purchase of the land through community-based organisations known as Provident Societies became impatient with what they saw as lack of progress.

Their resulting refusal to make the financial contributions which were supposed to drive the developments caused further delays. Some like Denese Fenton simply withdrew their money to try for land through other channels.

“The process was taking too long,” she says. “I said to myself that it looks like this will take forever.”

After four years of little progress therefore, the government took a decision to “fast track” 15 of the housing developments comprising more than 2,000 housing solutions. The state is now advancing the money for development, which is supposed to be paid back as the recipients receive the titles for the land, and apply for mortgages.

The estimated cost of completion of the 15 projects is 52.6 million dollars of which the community organisations have so far paid approximately four million dollars. The planned completion of another 35 sites by the end of the financial year in March, is expected to cost another 52.6 million dollars.

With the government bankrolling the developments, they finally got moving. Nearly 400 persons received land titles in early September for land at Luana in the parish of St. Elizabeth at the southern end of the island, while some 2,000 others islandwide should receive land titles over the next two months.

However, the fast tracking has created problems of its own, making some of the projects more expensive than originally visualised.

“Probably you could say that some of the specifications used for some of the projects are beyond the level of people to really afford it in the short run,” says President of the government’s National Housing Development Corporation, Dudley Shields. “They will have to be seeking mortgages, and it’s going to prove a little difficult for some of them to afford the original solutions.”

The government is therefore now trying to balance its desire to move the programme forward, with the need for the community to lead development at a pace they can afford.

Shields says that experience has now shown that there is no quick solution to the dilemma, and that communities have to accept their own limitations.

“The communities that can’t afford a fast track development have to settle on a longer term development, the incremental approach, which is really doing it little by little as the funds come in,” he says.

For many Jamaicans, however, the only important thing is that the programme continues. “There’s a lot of us that did not have anywhere, and right now we can say we have somewhere,” Duanvale resident Enda Wynter says.

“Going out there now to buy a piece of land is so expensive that we could not buy the land, and (then) buy material to build on it.”

 
Republish | | Print |

Related Tags