Headlines, Human Rights, Middle East & North Africa

RIGHTS-TURKEY: IPS Journalist’s Trial Starts Amid Protests

ISTANBUL, Sep 29 1999 (IPS) - Journalist Nadire Materthe IPS Istanbul correspondentand publisher Semih Sokmenwere formally indicted Wednesday for the crime of “belittling and insulting” the Turkish armed forces in a book of interviews with veterans of war.

The trial caused an uproar of protests from Turkish journalists and international organisations.

Both defendants pleaded ‘not guilty’ to the accusations, introduced to Istanbul’s Beyoglu criminal court by public prosecutor Mustafa Gursoy. If the court declares them guilty, Mater will face up to six years in prison while Sokmen will have to pay a heavy fine.

The accusation follows the seizure in June of Maters ‘Mehmet Book’, a compilation of interviews conducted by the journalist with 42 former Turkish soldier, veterans of the 15-year old war between the Turkish army and Kurdish guerrillas fighting for independence.

The indictment caused loud protests by journalists and intellectuals present at the hearing. According to the prosecutor, Mater and Sokmen violated article 159 of the Turkish penal code by publishing the book. A second hearing was scheduled for 26 November.

In her defence statement Mater told judges that, “indeed who are being tried in this court room are not myself and my publisher but the 42 veterans who for the first time after 15 years of bloody fighting were provided a channel to express themselves, their frustrations, fears and hopes.”

“All those related to this bloody conflict have already spoken in their own names – the military chiefs , politicians, diplomats, United States and European Union officials; those who were denied the opportunity to express themselves were, however, the main subjects of this war, the rank and file soldiers who have been sent to die or kill with or without their consent,” Mater said.

“All I have done, as a genuine journalist, is to hold a microphone for these young men and reflect their words truthfully. The indictment is ironic in the sense that not even a single word of mine is presented as an evidence of my ‘guilt’. The indictment is based on deliberately isolated quotations from the statements of the soldiers,” she added.

“The prosecutor is indeed indicting the men once exalted as ‘heroes'” – Mater stressed – “I refuse the charges.”

Publisher Sokmen too rejected the accusation. “I am extremely proud of what we have done. For the first time since the beginning of war, we have been able to convey the perceptions and feelings of blood and flesh soldiers to the public, ” he said.

” This may be different than the official perception but this is not a crime. To the contrary, it provides feedback to the Army in order to correct its conduct,” he added.

Since its first edition in April, ‘Mehmet’s Book’ has had four reprints, for a total of 20,000 books sold, until it was banned in June by a local Istanbul court in compliance following a special request by the Army’s deputy chief of staff, General Hilmi Özkök.

Mater said that the “crude intervention” by the military provided further evidence of the judiciary’s lack of independence and of the limited nature of freedom of expression in Turkey.

“This is Turkey’s year 2000 question,” said journalist Oral Çal}~la r, who was serving a 10-month term for interviewing Kurdish leader Abdullah Ocalan in 1993, when his sentence was suspended this month by a conditional amnesty granted by Parliament to journalists and writers.

“As I was reading ‘Mehmed’s Book’ what I heard was the cry ‘no more blood for blood,’ not any insult against any institution,” said Zeynep Oral, a literary critique at Milliyet an Istanbul daily. “Turkey would have benefited from this book. What a pity, we are missing another opportunity because of our paranioas.”

“Mehmed’s Book expresses the truth. And the book is being tried. Our civilian generals are summarily executing the truth, ” said columnist Necati Dogru of Sabah, another Istanbul newspaper.

The leader of the Freedom and Solidarity Party , Ufuk Uras, also attended the hearing in support of the accused.

“It’s so strange that at the moment in which prime minister Bulent Ecevit is praised by US president Bill Clinton in Washington for the progress Turkey has made in the direction of broader freedoms, prisoners are shot to death and journalists are threatened with prison sentences,” he said.

“Nadire Mater’s book has provided us with abundant facts about the other side of the war, the most valuable material for our party’s campaign for peace,” Uras told IPS. “We will be with Nadire to the end, and we will do whatever at hand to keep her and all of our writers and journalists free.”

Mater’s case is already raised for international support by the US based journalist organisation CPJ (Committee to Protect Journalists), London-based rights groups Index on Censorship and Article XIX and Paris based journalist organization Reporters Without Frontiers (RSF) which Mater represents in Turkey.

The Director General of IPS (Inter Press Service), Roberto Savio, stressed in a letter to prime minister Ecevit that conducting and publishing interviews is a legitimate professional activity for a journalist and does not constitute a criminal offence in countries ruled by the state of law.

The journalist “has done no more than practice her profession, which is to inform the public independently and objectively,” said in turn RSF chair Robert Menard in a letter to Ecevit. “Mater should not be harassed for carrying out a serious and well documented investigation which merely reflects the facts.”

“Turkey has a press that in many ways is as lively as any in Europe. But when they write about issues at the heart of modern Turkish politics-political Islam and Kurdish nationalism in particular- Turkey’s journalists cross into a minefield. In their zeal to control national discourse, political and military leaders have criminalized journalism CPJ said in a press release.

“This is an offence to the free word and can only work in a counterproductive way to Turkey’s wish to belong to the family of democratic countries, ” protested Elisabeth-Zila Olin, vice president of the Swedish branch of Pen International.

“I am tired but happy,” said Mater after the hearing. “I would like to thank all those who have come to support me from every part of the world. Still I feel threatened that the court might decide guilty. But having received such warm support I feel I can stand anything and this inspires a second book.”

 
Republish | | Print |

Related Tags