Headlines, Human Rights, Middle East & North Africa

RIGHTS-GULF: Kuwait Riots Expose Plight of Migrant Workers

Hossam Hassan

CAIRO, Dec 6 1999 (IPS) - Recent riots in Kuwait have spotlighted the complex issue of Egyptian labour abroad. Although the Egyptian and Kuwaiti authorities managed to contain tensions, a warning has been sounded in both Egypt and the Gulf region.

The riots were triggered by a quarrel that broke out on in the suburb of Khitan between an Egyptian worker and a Bangladeshi supermarket- owner over the breaking of some China dishes.

The conflict soon escalated and eventually the Kuwaiti police intervened, arresting dozens of Egyptians and evacuating hundreds more from a neighbourhood that houses about 60,000 Egyptians.

Over two million Egyptians live and work in the Gulf area – 270,000 of them in Kuwait – and their remittances constitute a significant proportion of Egypt’s foreign currency revenues.

“The problem in Kuwait was not about the broken china; it was about what many of the Egyptian workers living in Khitan are thinking of as inadequate working and living conditions,” one official source said.

According to this source, many of the demonstrators were frustrated as they recently lost their jobs.

Most of those workers knew they could not ask the local authorities or Egypt’s embassy in Kuwait for assistance because they do not hold work and residence permits. But they still felt betrayed because they had paid to get to Kuwait and were abandoned there.

“So, the china incident was really the last straw,” the source said.

The status of Egyptians living and working in the rich Arab Gulf states has at times given rise to tension, albeit subdued, in Egypt’s relations with them.

Many of these problems, Egyptian officials say, occur when Egyptian workers there act in violation of the laws and rules of these countries, most commonly by seeking job opportunities without permits.

Officials from the Egyptian ministries of Foreign Affairs and Labour tour the Gulf States on a regular basis to make sure that some of the problems are contained.

And while the number of Egyptian workers dropped in the aftermath of the 1991 Gulf War, as the peninsula was hit by a financial crisis, the one exception has been Kuwait, which has seen the number of Egyptian workers double since the war ended.

The resulting decline in job opportunities abroad, especially for the unskilled, has given rise to an illegal traffic in residence permits based on fictitious work contracts.

Thousands of Egyptians have been induced to pay in the neighbourhood of 3,000 US dollars for paper-work that ultimately lands them in a foreign country, jobless, and forced to compete with hundreds of similar workers in a declining job a market.

The Kuwaiti foreign minister, Sheikh Sabah Al-Ahmed, put the issue succinctly before the Kuwaiti parliament when he blamed the Khitan incident on “traders in residence permits who have grown rich over freighting in and exploiting foreign labour.”

He went so far as to say that the treatment to which these workers are subjected sometimes amounts to “slavery.” It is a view shared by the Arab Organisation for Human Rights and the Kuwaiti Organisation for Human Rights.

Both accused the Kuwaiti government of failing to provide adequate provision for Egyptians who find themselves at the mercy of Kuwaiti contractors.

The Egyptian Organisation for Human Rights (EOHR) echoed such concerns. “These incidents are only a reflection of the tragic conditions under which Egyptian workers are living”, a statement by the EHOR said.

The statement praised Kuwaiti officials for being ‘aware” of the negative implications of the current employment system and urged them to work towards its improvement.

During his visit to Cairo last week, the Kuwaiti minister of Social Affairs and Labour reached a preliminary agreement with his Egyptian counterpart Ahmed Al-Amawi.

The agreement stipulates that while Kuwait would address the problems facing Egyptian labour, the Egyptian Embassy would ensure that only skilled labour would be allowed to immigrate to Kuwait.

Egypt hopes to conclude similar agreements with other countries such as Saudi Arabia, which employs between 700,000 to 900,000 Egyptians, Qatar (25,000), the United Arab Emirates (110,000), Libya, Lebanon and Jordan.

Part of the dilemma is that jobs are no longer available on the scale they used to be. According to a recent report by the Economic and Social Commission for West Asia (ESCWA), Egyptian labour has shrunk in countries such as Saudi Arabia -where the figure used to be over one million.

Unofficial estimates say that about 20 per cent of Egyptians do leave their country without a contract. “A thorough review is needed to check the ‘anarchic’ labour market,” wrote Khaled Addul- Kareem of the Egyptian Gazette daily newspaper.

The amended law of 1991 organises the recruitment of Egyptian labour abroad. The law regulates activities of the labour recruitment agencies in Egypt.

However, “up to 75 per cent of the work opportunities abroad are provided through illegal channels. In Egypt, there is an official and licensed labour market and a shady one taking the cream of the market,” said Abdul- Galil Migahid, an official at Cairo Chamber of Commerce.

Criticising the current rules under which Egyptian workers leave for illusory jobs abroad, Migahid said that the black market is dominating the labour activities in Egypt.

“Sponsors in the Arab Gulf states treat the foreign workers as slaves. They force them to pay part of their revenues to them or face deportation,” said Migahid, who is in charge of the recruitment section at the Chamber of Commerce.

The owners of licensed labour recruitment agencies rejected any wrongdoing and accuse illegal brokers for the problems.

“Those brokers facilitate travel for a large number of people without making sure that some work is available for them abroad,” Sayed Al-Kholy, who runs a recruitment agency, said, adding that there should be a tough crackdown on brokers.

“Over a quarter of a century the tensions and distortions inherent in the system began to manifest themselves. Egyptian workers began to experience problems in several Arab countries, problems that officials on both sides were keen to smooth over,” says Ibrahim Nafie, chief editor of the semi-official Al-Ahram newspaper

“The one lesson we should learn from Khitan, however, is that glossing over the problems is no longer an adequate response,” he stressed.

 
Republish | | Print |

Related Tags