Headlines, Middle East & North Africa

POLITICS-IRAN: Khatami Victory Welcomed

Nadire Mater

ISTANBUL, Mar 1 2000 (IPS) - Turkey’s secularists have welcomed the ‘moderates’ election victory in Iran believing that it might change Iran’s image as a ‘model Islamist regime’ and end its influence on the country’s islamists.

Turkey’s President Bulent Ecevit applauded the results saying he hoped that a moderate government in Teheran would put an end to the ‘exportation of the Islamic revolution’ to its neighbours.

“I expect that this might end the attempts of exporting the revolution. (The results are) a victory for women and youth,” he told journalists.

However, political analysts say there is still a long way to go.

Ecevit’s statement has received a sharp response from Teheran.

In a memorandum to Turkey’s ambassador to Teheran last week an Iranian Foreign Ministry official, Muhsin Aminzade, said Ecevit’s statement “is a blunt intervention in Iran’s domestic issues and an insult directed at the Islamic regime and the Iranian people.”

“The Feb 18 elections is a step in the implementation of Islamic revolution,” Aminzade is quoted in the Turkish press as saying.

In addition to rivalries for regional hegemony, Ankara-Teheran relations have worsened since the 1977 Islamic revolution in Iran.

A close ally of the West and a North Atlantic Treaty Organisation, NATO, member, Ankara has been convinced that Teheran aims at undermining Turkey’s secularist regime and stands behind Islamist groups and the Kurdish Worker Party, PKK.

Turkish officials and politicians have frequently argued of a ‘Teheran link’, particularly in relation to assassinations of prominent secularist figures such as veteran journalist Ugur Mumcu, and most recently Professor Ahmet Taner Kislali.

Many suspects arrested during the ongoing crackdown on the islamist Hizbollah group have reportedly admitted that they had received military and political training in several places in Iran. The PKK is believed to maintain rear bases within Iranian territory.

Teheran, in turn, accuses Ankara of supporting the dissidents of the Islamic regime.

Islamist Teheran and secularist Ankara are further competing for influence over the former Soviet Central Asian republics as to who would set a model for the future restructuring of these countries.

“The victory of reformists might relax ideological tension between Iran and Turkey and, thus, lead to improved relations,” believes Professor Nilufer Narli of Marmara University.

“Iran’s efforts to export Islamic revolution to secular Turkey has been the major reason behind the conflict,” she told IPS.

Yet, ‘co-operation between Iran and Turkey is crucial,’ she says.

‘Ankara and Teheran are neighbours and non-Arab players in the region. Moreover, enhanced co-operation is important in channelling the resources from the Caspian sea area to international markets,’ she adds.

“Khatami’s ascension to power and the reformist recent election victory has considerably limited official attempts at exporting the revolution,” says Rusen Cakir, an analyst of Islamist regimes who has followed Iranian elections in Teheran.

“Teheran is no more the Mecca of Islamic revolution,” he told IPS.

However, Cakir is of the opinion that the ongoing debate on Islamic politics in Iran would have long term effects on the future formation of political Islam in Turkey although the majority in Turkey is Sunnite while the majority in Iran is Shiite.

“But it is highly unlikely that Turkey might comprise a model for Iran’s future progress,” Cakir believes. “The change in Iran is on Islamic lines not on secular lines. But Turkey is a very important factor in the debate in Iran both politically and culturally.”

“Secularism will reign in Iran sooner or later,” Cakir believes. “But for most Iranian ideologues Turkish model of secularism is something akin to atheism. Secularism for the Iranian elite is simple separation of worldly and heavenly affairs,” he observes.

“Iran’s secularists are rather more striving to strip the priesthood ‘the Mullahs – from their monopoly of interpretation of the Koranic Law, the Shariat – than complete abolition of the Shariat itself,” Cakir told IPS.

“Iran’s change in the direction of secularism and democracy and improved relations with West might change regional balances,” Cakir predicts.

Meanwhile the election results in Teheran has resulted on a mixed reaction from Turkey’s Islamists.

“The reactions against the regime is rather more related with the absence of political liberties and with its economic policies than its Islamic core,” believes Ahmet Kurucan, a political analyst from Islamist daily Zaman.

“In Iran the loser is not the religion of Islam but a model state imposed by the Shiites, and the rulers who govern this system,” he argues.

“The interpretations (by the secularists) of the election results are both erroneous and they reflect hatred against Islam,” he concludes.

Suleyman Taygar, another Islamist analyst, is pessimistic that Khatami could go all the way to implement democratic reforms.

“Imagine a country whose president is practically the leader of the opposition. Khatami has to share his power with the Mullahs who hold the state power in their grip. Under these circumstances Khatami could neither meet the people’s demands nor he could convince the Mullahs,” he says.

“Iranians should avoid extreme optimism. Everything might turn upside down once a few people are arrested,” he concludes.

“Iran has always been a minor element in the PKK-Turkey controversy,” political analyst Rusen Cakir argues. “However, with Syria’s total abandoning of the PKK, the cards in the game are now in Iran’s hands.”

“As long as Turkey-Iran controversy continues, a certain degree of Teheran support to the PKK will go on,” he believes.

“But if Turkey works out a solution to the Kurdish question then the balances might change for Turkey’s advantage.”

 
Republish | | Print |

Related Tags