Headlines, Middle East & North Africa

POLITICS-ISRAEL: Israelis Think Peace Process Is Dead

Ben Lynfield

JERUSALEM, Oct 12 2000 (IPS) - The killing of two Israeli soldiers in Ramallah Thursday by a mob of Palestinians, and Israel’s attack on Palestinian Authority targets in the West Bank town, is accentuating the crisis gripping the beleaguered Israeli peace camp as Israeli-Palestinian fighting escalates.

Hours after the killings, black smoke was billowing from central Ramallah after Israeli helicopters attacked in a major escalation that recalled Israel’s tactics during its 1982 invasion of Lebanon.

Peace Now, the leading peace movement in Israel, denounced the killing of the soldiers as a “heinous crime.” It said it had no immediate statement on the Israeli helicopter attacks.

“Nothing but a full condemnation by the Palestinian Authority will salvage any trust of the Israeli public in the peace process,” said Didi Remez, a Peace Now spokesman.

Peace Now however, had not denounced the use of exaggerated Israeli military means against the Palestinians during the latest round of violence, which started on September 28.

The Israeli peace camp had staked its political credibility on the continuation of a partnership with Palestinian leader, Yasser Arafat, to build on the 1993 Oslo self-rule agreement and transform it into a full-fledged peace treaty.

But that approach seems to be going up in smoke after the killings of the soldiers by the mob. In the charged, insular, anti- Arafat climate inside Israel, the peace camp is being portrayed as having been naive and misguided.

While much of the world has viewed the Palestinians as those suffering the most in the conflict, Israelis view the Palestinians as aggressors who are perpetuating the violence in order to extort gains in world opinion and at the negotiating table.

Liberals, often attacked during the best of times, are now clearly on the defensive and even sound as if they are apologising for advocating peace with the Palestinians.

Zehava Galon, chairperson of the left-wing Meretz faction in the Knesset, took issue yesterday with mounting calls for a “national emergency government” that would include the hard-line Likud party and its leader, Ariel Sharon, saying that would spell the end of the peace process.

“We are among those who believe that we have a very, very problematic partner but we have no other choice,” she said.

“Yasser Arafat must make every effort to calm the territories. We won’t accept such behaviour. We won’t accept harming our soldiers or civilians.”

But the killing of the Israeli soldiers comes after 15 days of violence during which 97 people died, 90 of them Palestinians. Another 2,000 people were injured.

The clashes that were triggered by the visit of Sharon to a compound housing the third holiest mosque in Islam, The Noble Sanctuary, which is known to Jews as the Temple Mount.

The soldiers in Ramallah were killed after Palestinian police stopped them at a checkpoint and took them to a police station downtown, according to the Israeli army.

A mob surrounded the building and attacked them. It was not immediately clear whether the police had sought to protect the soldiers or had allowed the attackers to gain access to them. The soldiers had erred while en route to an assignment in the Ramallah area, Israeli state run radio said.

The Palestinian Authority termed the incident “regrettable” but said it was a result of Israel’s escalation of the fighting, including the use of helicopters and tanks. The PA said the soldiers were part of an undercover unit that was on a mission inside Ramallah.

It was the most lethal incident for Israelis since the violence started on Sept 28 and it stunned the country, which had hitherto been fighting a virtually casualty free war with the Palestinians, who were armed mainly with stones and Kalashnikovs.

Palestinian proponents of dialogue with Israelis are also despairing, saying they are disappointed the Israeli peace movement has largely kept silent about the army’s shooting practices in the West Bank and Gaza Strip, which have drawn criticism from Amnesty International for fatal shootings of demonstrators and others when their lives were not in danger.

The army says the soldiers shoot only to defend their lives.

One of the victims of the Israeli shootings was a 12 year old boy, Mohammad al Dura, who was sheltering from the shooting with his father when he was killed by an Israeli sniper.

Communications Minister Binyamin, Ben-Eliezer, told reporters Thursday that the Oslo process that launched Palestinian self-rule in 1993 was “gone”.

“I believe this process no longer exists. Arafat is continuing along the path of confrontations and violence. We have a very strong [military] establishment to give a response. This is a new situation and we must prepare for a conflict, possibly a protracted one.”

Gideon Ezra, a legislator for the right-wing Likud party, said the violence had vindicated its hard-line stance against the Oslo process.

“We always knew Arafat was a terrorist, a killer of Jews everywhere,” said Ezra, former deputy chief of the Shin Bet intelligence agency. “He is not a partner. The army should take off the gloves. Any Palestinian holding weapons is a threat.”

In Beit Sahour, a Palestinian town south of Jerusalem, Elias Rashmawi, the founder of a 12 year old dialogue group with Israelis, said that Israeli peace groups “seem to be in a conflict between their beliefs and whether to support their government. I hate to think that these groups aren’t thinking of what is happening on our side.”

 
Republish | | Print |

Related Tags