Headlines, Middle East & North Africa

POLITICS-MIDEAST: Israelis and Palestinians: Same Events, Different Versions

Ben Lynfield

BEIT JALA, WEST BANK, Oct 19 2000 (IPS) - Two persons, one Palestinian and one Jewish settler, were killed Thursday during renewed clashes near the West Bank town of Nablus.

As many as 15 others were injured when Palestinians and Jewish settlers traded gunfire as the settlers attempted to get to a holy site on a hill near the town. Each side has blamed the other for the incident.

Israel has called the incident a blatant violation of the Sharm el- Sheikh agreement and has given the Palestinians a 24-hour ultimatum – stop violence or else.

The Sharm el-Sheikh agreement was hammered out on Tuesday in that Egyptian resort between Israel and the Palestinians. It was brokered by US president Bill Clinton and Egyptian president Hosni Mubarak. The deal called for both sides to condemn the violence and to pull back their combatants.

Israeli is to re-deploy its forces and re-open the airports, ports and crossroads which it had closed during the clashes.

On Thursday there were also some clashes in Hebron with Palestinian stone throwers pitted against Israeli soldiers.

The situation meanwhile was tense in the scenic Arab town of Beit Jala south of Jerusalem and its Jewish neighbour, Gilo, but there were no incidents on Thursday.

Gilo is a Jerusalem neighbourhood built on territory Israel expropriated from Beit Jala residents in 1970, three years after the Jewish state captured the town along with the rest of the West Bank during the Six Day War.

The valley between the two communities has become one of the many fronts in the Palestinian-Israeli mini-war, with Palestinian gunmen firing at Gilo and Israeli soldiers shooting at Beit Jala. The Israeli army on Wednesday began erecting concrete barriers in Gilo, after shots from Beit Jala seriously wounded a policeman. Israeli forces responded with fire from machine guns mounted on tanks.

The Israelis have kept four tanks on the edge of Gilo to deter fire from Beit Jala.

In Beit Jala, Fuad Rizik, a leader of the Palestinian People’s Party, said Gilo was being fired upon because of Israeli killings of Palestinians, both demonstrators and bystanders.

“I am against shooting between the populated areas, but in this situation you cannot control everything done by frustrated people. The Israelis are killing people every day,” he said.

Israelis counter that the clashes start with Palestinian attacks on army positions. If those attacks ceased, the violence would immediately end, they say.

During three weeks of violence, more than 100 people have died, almost all Palestinians, and more than 2,000 have been wounded. The clashes were triggered by a visit by Israeli hard-line Likud party leader Ariel Sharon to a sacred site known to Moslems as the Noble Sanctuary and to Jews as the Temple Mount.

Israeli police shot dead seven Palestinian demonstrators the day after the visit, fuelling clashes throughout the West Bank and Gaza Strip and inside Arab areas of Israel.

The Palestinian leadership, in a statement read on Palestinian television Wednesday, urged Palestinians “to refrain from anything that would lead to tension or violence and to work for calming down the situation”. But immediately thereafter, the station resumed its broadcasts of footage of youths confronting Israeli soldiers, accompanied by stirring nationalist music. Similar broadcasts continued on Thursday.

The Israeli army had called on residents of one Beit Jala neighbourhood to evacuate their homes Tuesday in advance of possible further Israeli military steps, while authorities in Gilo urged residents to leave lest they be hit by Palestinian fire. Few people on either side relish the idea of becoming refugees, however, so most have stayed put, determined to endure the troubles.

Some residents of Beit Jala are sympathetic of continued attacks on Gilo. The reason: the death of 13-year old Muayid Jawarish, killed in neighbouring Bethlehem Monday, is still fresh in their minds.

Jawarish was gunned down by Israeli soldiers on his way home from school, Palestinians say. The Israeli army said that it is possible Palestinian gunfire killed Jawarish during a clash with Israeli troops.

“We are very happy they are shooting from our house because we are proud of them,” said Nasreen Hajaja, a mother of three, about the Fatah gunmen. “The Israelis kill us and our children and we must not be silent forever. We must do something, because if they don’t feel the pain that we feel, they won’t leave.

“They should leave all of the country, leave Palestine. With force they will leave it. What was taken by force must be taken back by force,” she added.

Jerusalem mayor Ehud Olmert said Tuesday night that the army should weigh using helicopters, missiles and tanks to attack Beit Jala. “If one resident of Gilo is forced to leave his house, no resident of Beit Jala will be able to sleep,” said Olmert, a prime ministerial hopeful from the rightist Likud party.

In Gilo, residents kept away from the street closest to Beit Jala. Aharon Schwartzman, 77, who was born in the Moldavian city of Kishinev, site of an infamous anti-Jewish pogrom in 1903, took a historical perspective on the violence. The gunshots that struck his apartment building are part of a 100 year Arab war against Jews returning to their homeland, he said. “This didn’t start today, and it won’t be finished tomorrow,” he said.

Nearby, two outdoor tabernacles, used for dining and celebration during the Jewish holiday of Succot, which falls this week, were abandoned because they were in the line of fire. Schwartzman disputed the Palestinian view that the shots from Beit Jala were prompted by Jawarish’s death, saying that gunfire from the Palestinian town began two weeks ago. And the Palestinians are to blame for the child fatalities, he said, because they send youngsters to demonstrations.

“They use children so that the world will be appalled and blame us. But they won’t get anything that way.”

He recalled that there had been little trouble between the two communities for most of the 15 years he had lived in Gilo and that workers from Beit Jala heading to jobs in Jerusalem used to peacefully pass near his house every day.

Now he avoids going into his kitchen, which faces Beit Jala, or to his car, parked in an open area. “Many people here have reached the end of their rope,” he said. “But this is our house, and the army is here. We are not alone against the terrorists.”

 
Republish | | Print |

Related Tags