Development & Aid, Headlines, Middle East & North Africa

RIGHTS-YEMEN: Civil Society in Crisis

Khaled Almahdi

SANA'A, Oct 18 2000 (IPS) - Yemen’s non-governmental organisations (NGOs) need to be unshackled so they can perform their role of aiding the developmental process, activists here say.

But government and some donors believe the NGO movement in Yemen needs some control because individuals here are using civil society as a commercial entity.

NGOs began appearing in Yemen after the unification of the south and north in 1990. The post-unification constitution gives individuals and groups the right to organise themselves socially, culturally, economically, and politically. Today there are some 2,800 NGOs in the country.

Activists say the movement is being hampered by outdated laws that limit its activities, scarcity of local financial support, the multiplicity of government agencies which supervise NGO work and state attempts to control NGOs.

The Ministry of Social Affairs tracks donations and other financial support to NGOs by insisting that these groups make regular reports to the government on such assistance and their intended use.

The NGOs say this measure restricts their freedom and is aimed at keeping tabs on certain groups such as those involved in human rights.

Jamal Aladimi, head of the Forum of Civil Society, a human rights NGO, says that only those groups which deal with human rights issues are accused of “treason” when they receive foreign aid.

“NGOs are not asked about the foreign aid they receive unless they are human rights organisations,” says Aladimi. “The government accuses only the human rights activists of being traitorous for getting financial aid from foreign donors,” he adds.

Officials argue that the issue is transparency.

“They must clearly specify their financial resources, and expenditure, to be more credible in the eyes of the public,” says Deputy Minister of Social Affairs Ali Saleh Abdullah.

“There are many cases in which some individuals who have good communicative skills and relations with donors take donations for themselves not for their NGOs,” he says.

“Indeed, we deal with all NGOs positively and flexibly concerning the monetary aid, but regrettably, some embassies and international organisations encourage individuals by delivering financial aid directly to them,” he adds.

Many here believe that most NGOs are being established only for securing funds for their founders.

“Most of the NGOs here are far from being associated with the country’s actual realities. They were formed solely for the financial gains for those in charge,” says Dr. Fouad Assalahi, professor of sociology at Sana’a University. “Some NGO leaders have begun to resemble mercenaries more than people who are entrusted with certain social duties,” he added.

Donors also are astonished by the mushrooming of NGOs in Yemen, and some also believe it has become a money-making venture for Yemenis.

“Establishing an NGO here (in Yemen) means for most activists getting donations and money,” says a western diplomat who refused to be identified. “We have always stressed that they must see serving society as their principal task for establishing an NGO. It is a voluntary work, not a business,” he adds.

The Ministry of Social Affairs allocates funds annually to NGOs, but activists say these donations are not disbursed equitably.

“The governmental aid is presented randomly, and getting a decent amount of funds often depends on personal relations,” says Yahya al- Qufaily, chairperson of the Co-ordination Panel of Child Rights Organisations.

For instance, he adds, most of the ministry’s senior officials have their own NGOs and these get a lot of aid.

One more problem facing NGOs in Yemen is that they are still governed by the outdated Law No. 11 that was promulgated in 1963 to control the ‘co-operative associations’ of that time. The law was modelled along the lines of the Egyptian NGO law which dated back to 1923.

Donor states, the United Nations Development Programme (UNDP) and the World Bank have all helped to formulate a new draft NGO law described by activists as the ‘way out’ of the NGOs’ dilemma. The draft has been endorsed by the cabinet and submitted to the House of Representatives to be ratified.

But even if that bill becomes law, it will hardly address one of the main problems confronting Yemeni NGOS – that of administrative weakness.

Many NGOs spring up here only to founder months later because of scarce funds, lack of good management of their meagre resources and fighting for position within the administrative boards.

Faisal Assofi, general secretary of the Yemeni Institute for Democracy Development says, the weakness of the institutional structure is prevalent in civil society organisations.

“Poor institutional structure and the lack of accounting systems that depend upon transparency characterises most of the Yemeni NGOs,” he asserts.

This deteriorating situation has led to spreading frustration and a growing number of Yemenis who refuse to participate in NGO activities.

 
Republish | | Print |

Related Tags