Asia-Pacific, Development & Aid, Headlines, Population

EDUCATION-THAILAND: Reforms Get a Failing Mark, Say Students

Prangtip Daorueng

BANGKOK, Dec 28 2000 (IPS) - Thai authorities worried about the slipping quality of public education are pursuing “bold” reforms to correct this, but some students believe they should get failing marks when it comes to stimulating real learning.

Two years ago, the government adopted changes in the curricula in primary and secondary schools in a bid to make teaching more student-focused rather than teacher-oriented.

It may be too early to tell what the changes have produced, but it is not too early to see that these are not coming easily.

“It has confused me and many of my classmates,” 14-year-old Supawan Samatapolrom says of the “student-centred” teaching method, which Bung Thong Lang secondary school in Bangkok adopted in 1998.

“It is better to stick to the old one where the teacher explains more about what students don’t understand,” adds the Grade 8 student.

Bung Thong Lang secondary school is one of public schools in Bangkok that caters to low-income families. It has taken in 2,000 children from nearby communities, and has, like other public primary and secondary schools in the country, adopted the new curriculum in two years ago.

This new curriculum, drafted by the department of curriculum and instruction, aims to develop students’ analytical thinking. It replaced the old curriculum that had been much criticised for being too “teacher-centred”.

The effort to reform the country’s primary and secondary education system came after research revealed the weak aspects of the old curriculum.

A government survey in 1998 pointed to the old curriculum’s failure to encourage morality among children, and cope with changes in the fast-changing world.

Recently, a study by the Singapore-based Strategic Intelligence pointed out that Thai education system is behind South Korea by 10 years, and lags behind South-east Asian countries like Vietnam and Malaysia.

In 10 years, Thai students will fail to compete with their counterparts in neighbouring countries, the study added.

This is no secret among parents, who face the challenge of picking the right and affordable school for their children in the search for what they feel is better education.

Thus, many rich families have been sending their children to schools overseas despite the much higher costs. Many middle-income parents have withdrawn their children from school and have taken it upon themselves to educate their children at home.

But for children from lower-income families, who make up the bulk of students, the only option lies in the government-sponsored local education system. This is why these public schools must innovate and improve quality, say academic experts.

Meantime, some students say teachers may be following a new curriculum — but in the process are not teaching in an effective manner.

Students like Supawan and many of her friends, who are supposed to be the principal beneficiaries of education reforms, say they often feel at a loss in school.

“Teachers used to explain more, but now we are told to work on the lessons by ourselves and to ask questions later if we don’t understand,” Supawan says. “But many times, the teachers cannot explain clearly what we asked. We end up being left alone and more confused.”

This is the problem students are facing in trying to adjust to the new curriculum, explains Unchalee Jutatae, who teaches Thai language at the school.

“This method’s emphasis is on encouraging students to think and to solve problems by themselves as well as expressing it to others,” she points out. “This may be easier for students with better school performance, but for others who are slower, they still have problems adjusting.”

Bung Thong Lang school has divided students of the same grade level into different classes based on their scores, so they can keep to their own pace in learning lessons.

For example, Supawan’s class, which is number 12 among the eighth grade’s 12 classes, has extra lessons on practical subjects such as agriculture and typing. Other classes in the same grade that scored higher academically receive extra lessons on subjects like mathematics and English.

This follows the basic principle of the new curriculum, which says different levels of education should be provided to different students.

According to the department of curriculum and instruction development, the first nine years of study should focus on instilling students with knowledge that can help them manage their daily lives and imbue them with a sense of morality.

The three final years should focus on encouraging students to develop their own interests and talents.

Teacher Unchalee says that the school has tried to smoothen the introduction of the new method by slowly adjusting the previous one.

The new curriculum might sound perfect in theory and has shifted emphasis to students, but some students believe it is time their teachers’ performance is also evaluated.

Admits Supawan: “Sometimes I am discouraged by teachers who complain when we ask too much.” She cited the example of a teacher who called her students “stupid” when they did not understand some points she was teaching.

“Using rude words is not something teachers are supposed to do. Teachers should find a better way to talk to students,” adds 14-year-old Sakarin Wittayakul, Supawan’s classmate.

“The new curriculum demands hard work from teachers,” says social scientist Chaiwat Satha-anand, a board member of the Foundation for Child Development here. “Teachers have to be able to see how different each student is from the others, and give him or her suitable lessons.”

According to Chaiwat, teachers’ lack of attention to or understanding of the new curriculum may lead to even more problems among students.

“The old way of teaching is not bad for many people. In that system, we could find some teachers who were really devoted to students. That is why it is difficult to bring back good old teaching methods,” he explains. “Teachers nowadays have too many personal matters to deal with to give most of their time to children.”

That might be true. Supawan says she and a group of her friends are trying to solve their problem with mathematics by getting an extra lesson after school. Each one pays about 800 baht (20 U.S. dollars) a month for their same teacher in school to come to their homes and tutor them.

Asked why they cannot just ask their teacher to explain the lessons in school, Supawan says: “My teacher is very busy because after school, there are a lot of home lessons the teacher has to go to. That is why we can’t ask for additional explanations in her class at school.”

 
Republish | | Print |

Related Tags