Asia-Pacific, Headlines

SOUTH ASIA: Kashmir Films Do Little to Help Peace

Muddassir Rizvi

ISLAMABAD, Feb 26 2001 (IPS) - After fighting over Kashmir on the diplomatic front for decades, Pakistan and India have taken their dispute into the film theatre, which critics say will only fuel animosity among their people.

A series of films released in the past few months by the Pakistani film industry, popularly called ‘Lollywood’, have themes centred on allegations of human rights excesses by Indian security forces against the people of Indian-administered Kashmir.

“These movies are our rejoinder to a number of Indian films that linked Pakistani forces and intelligence agencies to subversive activities on Indian soil, particularly the insurgency in the disputed Kashmir territory,” wrote film critic Shahid Naqvi, in the Urdu-language newspaper ‘Ausaf’.

But not all associated with Pakistan’s film industry agree that the medium should be used for political purposes.

“We should use the popular medium of films to reduce rifts and differences among people,” says Ejaz Gul, managing director of the government-run National Film Development Corporation. He believes that films have potential to create wars.

“Since the people of India and Pakistan have access to each other’s movies and television programmes, the producers should seize the opportunity to promote peace and harmony, instead of catching on to the themes that fuel hatred,” he adds.

Pakistani journalist Najeem Haider Zaidi, who works with a domestic news agency, agrees. “Peace is not an isolated effort made by governments,” he points out.

The release of these films coincides with renewed efforts by the governments of the two South Asian neighbours, to resume peace talks stalled since their undeclared Kargil border war two years ago.

Pakistan, which was created on the basis of religion, claims Kashmir — Hindu-majority India’s only Muslim-majority province.

The two nuclear weapons-capable nations have fought two wars over Kashmir since the former princely state joined India, soon after the subcontinent’s partition by departing colonial British rulers in the year 1947. Pakistan administers a third of Kashmir.

For over a decade, armed secessionists have unleashed a violent campaign in the Kashmir Valley in India’s Jammu and Kashmir state, which has killed more than 35,000 people so far.

New Delhi accuses Islamabad of training and arming the militants, while Pakistan accuses Indian security forces of rights excesses in Kashmir.

However, a large number of cinema viewers in Pakistan think that Lollywood’s new productions, ‘Terey Piyar Mein’ (In your love) and ‘Musalman’ (Muslim), are a fitting response to similar films made by the Indian film industry.

“A number of Indian movies have put down Pakistan and its forces over the last few years…these movies were nothing but a bunch of lies,” says Nadia Rehmat, a student in a local girls college.

Still showing in cinema halls after its release in December 2000, Terey Piyar Mein is about an Indian Sikh girl who falls in love with a Pakistani boy during a visit to Sikh holy shrines in Pakistan.

Her Pakistani lover follows her to India where he is caught by an Indian army officer, who is also in love with the Sikh girl. The film ends with Kashmiri militants helping the Pakistani boy escape jail and cross the border into Pakistan with the Sikh girl.

In keeping with the Pakistan government’s allegations against Indian security personnel in Kashmir, the film shows the Indian army officer torturing the Pakistani man in jail.

“I am glad that Pakistan has finally started using cinema for rousing feelings of nationalism in the young people,” says Begum Tasadduq, an elderly woman who watched the film in Islamabad.

“India has made many movies against freedom fighters in Kashmir that are viewed by our youth…I feel that the government should patronise such efforts that portray the true feelings of the Pakistani nation,” she adds.

She was referring to the high popularity of Indian films ‘Roja’, ‘Border’, ‘Mission Kashmir’ and ‘Refugee’ in the Pakistani home video market.

These films, which depict the Indian view of the Kashmir issue, are being secretly rented after a ban by the government, which dubbed them as Indian propaganda.

“We cannot give out these movies though we get frequent demands,” says an attendant at a home video rental in Islamabad. Films made by India’s Hindi cinema industry, known as ‘Bollywood’, are highly popular in Pakistan.

Terey Piyar Mein is not the first effort of famed producer Shahzad Gul to cash in on the anti-India sentiment in Pakistan.

A year ago he produced the highly successful ‘Ghar Kab Aao gey (when will you return home?) that dealt with subversive activities, allegedly carried out by Indian intelligence agencies in Pakistan.

“The success of the movie has made me work on such themes as I realised how a majority in this country thinks,” Gul said in a press interview.

What Gul did not mention was the help he got from the Pakistani Army’s Inter Services Press Relations department in filming many of the scenes. Terey Piyar Mein was also made with the technical support of the military’s public relations department.

The military’s press relations wing has also given financial and technical help to state-run Pakistan Television in the filming of the popular drama series ‘Angaar Wadi’, (the valley of flames), which deals with the operations of the Indian security forces in Kashmir.

Critics, however, say that by cashing in on such sentiments, the producers of these films are hurting efforts to build trust between the people of Pakistan and India.

“What are we trying to achieve through these movies? Simply, indoctrinating people that we cannot live in harmony with people across the border,” says journalist Zaidi.

 
Republish | | Print |

Related Tags