Asia-Pacific, Development & Aid, Headlines, Human Rights, Population

RIGHTS-INDIA: Laws to be Tightened against Baby Traders

T V Padma

NEW DELHI, May 22 2001 (IPS) - Indian legal experts are looking to tighten adoption laws after some supposedly Good Samaritan care homes in south India were found cashing in on forsaken babies — and selling them for adoption at a huge profit.

The case not only brought into focus how unscrupulous agencies circumvent the country’s lax adoption laws, but also the government’s neglect of poverty-stricken remote tribal communities who fall prey to the baby brokers’ machinations and sell their babies to them.

The care homes to which the babies are handed over in turn offer them to childless couples for adoption for a huge profit.

In April, Indian police exposed widespread baby trafficking in the south Indian state of Andhra Pradesh. There, destitute parents, usually belonging to tribal communities, sold their infants to adoption agencies that bartered them to childless couples.

In the eye of the controversy are Action for Social Development (ASD) in Hyderabad and the John Abraham Bethany Memorial Home in Tandur, two non-government organisations that are now charged with deliberately pushing up the ‘sale’ of babies rather than taking care of them.

Through brokers and agents, organisations such as ASD and Bethany’s Care Home bought infants from impoverished tribes for 20 to 60 U.S. dollars each.

The agencies then sold the infants to childless couples for 100 times more money. Foreign couples were charged as high as 2,000 to 5,000 dollars and Indian parents were charged more — a little more than 6,000 dollars.

Police investigations reveal that the adoption agencies even prepare brochures and video clips of the children, which prospective parents can access for 100 dollars.

Once a child is selected, the agencies process necessary papers quickly, sometimes without even valid documents to show the child was surrendered or abandoned by its original parents.

Records in Hyderabad, the capital of Andhra Pradesh state, show that last year 706 children were brought to seven placement organisations there. Of these, about 450 were given for adoption, 300 to Indian families and 150 to overseas foster parents.

Police said representatives of foreign agencies set up contact with Bethany Home, which had a license from the Central Adoption Resource Agency (CARA), the office that oversees adoptions in India.

On the heels of the child trafficking case in Andhra, police in the neighbouring state of Orissa unearthed an adoption racket in their state.

An Orissa orphanage told police some babies missing from it had died of sunstroke, but could not furnish records of their deaths. The state police said they suspected that these infants were sold to Andhra Pradesh.

The Hyderabad case threw into focus a debate on whether adoption laws in India need to be made more stringent.

“CARA is now working on plugging the lacunae in the Indian adoption system,” said Lorraine Campos, a legal expert with the government-run orphanage Palna in New Delhi.

So far, care homes get a license from the adoption resource agency to run their centres, but need not take permission from it each time a child has to be given for adoption.

Experts are examining the possibility of requiring from now on that care homes obtain a separate adoption license from a central agency such as CARA for each adoption case.

The case also shows state governments’ lax attitude in dealing with such malpractices, as it is up to them to monitor the care homes, Campos said.

So far, the scam appears to be confined to Andhra Pradesh and have not come to notice in other parts of the country, she added.

Legal experts say unscrupulous adoption agencies are taking advantage of loose laws and tedious adoption procedures to pressure poor tribes into giving away their children and desperate couples into buying them.

According to Indian law, a child has to be surrendered by the parent, or in the case of abandoned children, confirmed free for adoption only after rigorous procedures of tracing the guardians have failed.

The child also has to be registered with the missing persons bureau and the missing status notified extensively through newspapers and other media — which is rarely done.

Most agencies get away by producing fictitious surrender certificates on behalf of parents. Prospective parents desperate to adopt a child do not pay heed to legal consequences of adopting from unrecognised agencies, an official from Palna said.

Social workers and counselors at the Indian Institute for Social Sciences Trust (ISST), a Delhi-based NGO, said while government-run agencies such as Palna strictly adhere to the rules, some private agencies flout them. “Some parents too are in a hurry to adopt, and do not pay heed to rules,” said Uma Nandi from ISST.

But what is unaddressed is the abject neglect of Indian tribal and marginalised communities, which leads them to desperate acts of selling their own children.

Majority of the infants sold to adoption agencies in Andhra Pradesh were from the Lambada tribal community, which sells its girls due to both poverty and superstition.

Lambada and Banjara tribes in Andhra Pradesh have a superstition that if the third, sixth or ninth child is a girl, she is inauspicious for the family.

Tribal parents also sell their girls to escape the burden of paying a dowry for their marriage. Traditionally, young men paid a bride price of seven bullocks and 3 to 30 dollars for a bride. Now, customs have reversed — parents of girls pay from 1,000 to 20,000 dollars.

The neglect of tribals has been a cause for concern in the country, where precious little has been done for their progress in the last five decades since India gained independence.

There is now a separate ministry in the federal government to deal with tribal affairs, and both the federal and individual state governments have on paper several welfare schemes and even reserved government jobs for them.

Yet, Indian tribes remain cut off from even basic education and health care facilities. They have virtually no political voice or say in development-related issues or projects.

It is not baby girls alone who find themselves commodities of barter — families sell young girls and women to tide over their financial problems.

Orissa, a state on India’s east coast and a northern neighbour of Andhra Pradesh, hit the headlines some years ago when a family in the perennially drought- and famine-struck Koraput district sold a young woman to an old man with a blind son to tide over their financial woes.

A child bride racket was busted in Andhra Pradesh, where police arrested three persons for trying to sell teenage girls as brides to grooms in west Asia.

“These cases reveal how ineffective the Indian law and government are in dealing with trade of women in India — be it baby girls, or teenagers or even adult women,” pointed out Amita Joshi, a counselor at ISST who was earlier with the Crimes Against Women cell of the Delhi Police.

 
Republish | | Print |

Related Tags