Asia-Pacific, Development & Aid, Headlines, Population

POPULATION-NEPAL: Ethnic, Religious Data in Census Under Fire

Suman Pradhan

KATHMANDU, Aug 16 2001 (IPS) - The preliminary results of Nepal’s census exercise, held every decade, are just out, but controversy is already brewing over the reliability of ethnic and religious data compiled by the exercise.

Census 2001, which was carried out in two phases through much of June and July this year, has found that Nepal’s population recorded an annual growth rate of 2.27 percent since 1991, reaching 23.21 million.

The overall population may still be small in comparison to neighbouring giants India and China, but the problems facing this Himalayan Kingdom are in no way insignificant, as the census has shown.

For instance, demographers are looking deeper into trends showing a greater proportion of women compared to men, and worrying about the skyrocketing population growth rates in urban areas such as the capital Kathmandu.

If the trend continues, they fear, social dislocation could result sooner rather than later.

But so far, the greatest controversy has been generated by religious and ethnic data which shows Hinduism, Nepal’s official religion, to still be the number one religion. Ethnic groups are already decrying what they call false attempts to portray them as Hindus whereas in fact they are not.

Village elders in Satungal, a small hamlet bordering Kathmandu, recently protested strongly when the census results showed their village to be 80 percent Hindu.

“We are from this village and we know what the religious make- up here is,” says villager Nhuchhe Maharjan. “Most of us here in fact stated Buddhism as our religion to the enumerators (census officials) but they just ignored it.”

Critics also complain that the Central Bureau of Statistics (CBS) enumerators also recorded Nepali as the mother tongue of many an ethnic groups. But in fact, many of these groups have their own language and culture that is distinct from Nepali, the official language.

Such charges have led to fears that the census data is being doctored to show the continued dominance of Hinduism and Nepali for political reasons.

“Whatever happened in Satungal is just an example of the concerted attempt to produce fake statistics of Nepal,” charges Dr Krishna Bhattachan, a well-known sociologist with Kathmandu’s Tribhuvan University. “It clouds the whole census exercise.”

The issue of language and religion is significant since Nepal is a multi-cultural and multi-ethnic society with a mix of Aryan, Mongol and Tibeto-Burman cultures.

But despite their own clear identity, cultural expression by the latter two groups were long suppressed in a misguided attempt to forge a “national identity” during the autocratic dictatorships throughout Nepal’s history.

The other groups blame the higher-caste Brahmins and Chhettris, who embody the Hindu Aryan culture, for this.

The shackles were largely removed in 1990 when Nepali reverted to multi-party democracy, but old habits die hard. Though religious and cultural expression is officially tolerated now, critics allege that subtle attempts are still being made to show a majority of Hindus and Nepali-speakers for political reasons.

Senior government and census officials deny all the charges.

“The census data has not been compromised statistically,” asserts Dr Prithvi Raj Ligal, vice chairman of the National Planning Commission (NPC), the government’s powerful central planning bureaucracy. “The disruptions occurred in only about one to two percent of the areas.”

Those worries aside, there is also the stark problem of population boom recorded by the census. The annual population growth rate of 2.27 is higher than the 2.1 percent recorded in the 1991 census.

Government officials acknowledge that the 1991 census figures were unreliable and the population growth then was more akin to 2.4 percent. In that sense, they argue, the growth rate has actually come down.

But the worries linger, the chief of these being the rapid urbanisation of Nepal. In Kathmandu district, which is a small part of Kathmandu Valley, the population has exploded to 1.2 million, stretching the district’s urban infrastructure, built half a century ago, to its limits.

The astounding pace of urbanisation can be gleaned from the fact that more than 90 percent of the country’s population were rural in 1991. Today, it is 85 percent, with a full 15 percent residing in urban areas.

The chief reason, says NPC Vice Chairman Dr Ligal, is the concentration of infrastructure in urban centres. “This has resulted because of centralised decision-making,”he argues. “People want to come to these centres because all the facilities are there only. But now we have to prioritise decentralisation to offset these trends.”

Another worry is the trends showing an imbalance in the male- female ratio.

The latest census has shown that women outnumber men by more than 500,000 nationwide, a trend that raises questions among demographers because Nepal is still a very conservative and patriarchic society with a premium on male children.

“It could be that most of our males are out-migrating to India in search of jobs,” says Radha Krishna G C, the deputy director of CBS. “Males migrate more to other countries in search of jobs than females,” he says, which may explain the lower proportion of men as shown in the census data.

Not all the information uncovered by the census is worrying, however.

There have been positive trends in household size, which has decreased from an average of 5.56 persons to 5.38. The average fertility rate of Nepali women has also declined considerably from 6.3 children per female to 4.8.

While these are healthy signs, much work still needs to be done on population.

“We want to achieve 1.5 percent annual population growth rate in the next 20 years,” says Dr Ligal. “The decline in fertility rates gives us optimism that we have good grounds to expect to achieve that goal in two decades’ time.”

 
Republish | | Print |

Related Tags